Patrick Fox Profile picture
Sep 10 14 tweets 3 min read
The Izium Pocket 🧵:
With the caveat that this front is developing so fast there may not be an Izium pocket long, some initial thoughts on the development and aftermath of the current situation.
1/
1. Welcome to kesselschlacht, or in English, the battle of encirclement. UAF appears to be conducting a double (north-south) envelopment of Russian formations in/around & north of Izium. Whether this pocket becomes closed, or remains somewhat open - the Russian situation is dire.
In the case of a closed pocket the task will be to reduce the formations inside while isolating it from relief attempts. In an open scenario, the object will be to close the trap, or harry fleeing units to the best of the UAFs ability.
2. The retreat must be harried. When an army breaks as the Russian army currently is, it becomes an opportunity to generate maximum casualties & maximum panic. Defeated armies tend to suffer the most casualties once they begin to rout, it is then they can be comprehensively
destroyed. The UAF must (as it is able) stay on their flanks & rear and continue to shell them. Air strikes on retreating columns would also be ideal, circumstances permitting. This is the time to break them, while keeping yourself from overextending. It will be a balancing act.
3. Russian command & control is, for the moment, absent in any observable sense from the Russian units heavily engaged or retreating. Nor do the Russians appear to possess the combat power to halt UAF advances at present. They will begin pulling troops from the south to
stabilize the sector of front, they have no choice. Once that move begins in earnest, the UAF will be granted another window to hit the Russians hard in Kherson. The Russians are short on manpower, keeping them off balance & reactive will pay dividends.
4. If another "back-to-the-river" massacre of Russian units can be orchestrated at Kherson, it will do incalculable damage to the Russian army in terms of morale, manpower, and materiel. This must be the goal. Killing Russians, in large numbers, while minimizing risk.
5. If the UAF can push the Russians over both the Oskol & the Dnieper rivers, it will be in an excellent position to hold for the winter while it consolidates, trains, reequips, and refits its forces. Spring 2023 will not be pleasant for the Russian army in such a scenario.
6. Keep an eye on the level of equipment captured in the current offensives. It will indicate both the level of panic experienced by Russian troops, and provide a critical source of resupply for non-western systems still in use.
7. Should both the Kherson & Izium sectors fall & fall hard, Russian casualties will be extreme. This will have ramifications inside Russia. If Putin's response is to demand mobilization & fresh offensives, his own position in the power structure will become far less secure.
At some point, a broken & ravaged Russian army becomes a threat to undermine the power structure that supports not only Putin, but the three centers of power in the Russian system: the Oligarchs, the Generals, & the intel/security services. Putin may be willing to throw the dice
& gamble everything he has on Ukraine. It is unlikely the bulk of these other individuals will make the same choice. If they become convinced Putin is no longer a rational actor, the possibility of something drastic happening at a high level within Moscow becomes more likely.
Historically, Russian autocrats do not fare well in the aftermath of major Russian military disasters.
<End>

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Patrick Fox

Patrick Fox Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @RealCynicalFox

Sep 10
The Collapse 🧵:
Conventional warfare is rare in the modern era, even rarer is when a portion of one army effectively collapses. That is currently the situation facing Russian forces between Kupyansk & Lyman. The situation is highly fluid & only those UAF personnel at the
1/
fore of this advance will know for certain what the extent of the advance is. As it stands, despite some increased Russian resistance in areas not impacted by the immediate breakthrough, the Russian forces have not reestablished a coherent defensive line.
2/
This doesn't mean the Russian army will melt away in its entirety. It's still a large, dangerous opponent whose capacity for defensive action demands respect even now. It does means that OpComEast has the initiative & Russia is suffering a defeat with strategic implications.
3/
Read 7 tweets
Sep 9
Achtung Panzer!, Kharkiv Front 🧵
This is what successful armored warfare looks like. There are many aspects to what appears to have made this operation work & I'd like to briefly go over a few of them. We'll start from the top & work our way down.
1/
The UAF have pulled off a remarkable strategic deception. By initiating, even telegraphing, an offensive in OpComSouth as their main effort they have successfully induced the Russian command to transfer a considerable number of troops south. Including some higher quality
2/
formations. This seems to have denuded the Russians opposite OpComEast of ready reserves & robust combat units in general. Furthermore the UAF was able to mass combat power in excess of what many analysts (including myself, I must admit) thought was possible.
3/
Read 17 tweets
Jul 29
On the castration video, short 🧵:
Video evidence of Russian personnel, likely ethnic Chechens, castrating a restrained Ukrainian POW has been widely circulating. I will not be posting it here. If you want to view it, it can be found easily & I warn you it's extremely graphic. 1/
Beyond the obvious facts that this is a war crime & its unlikely the perpetrator will ever face any kind of objective justice, there is another issue at play here. Coupled with filtration camps, where US intelligence asserts executions have taken place 2/
, this conflict is taking on a level of barbarity that historically results in both retaliations & refusals to take prisoners. When it happens from the Ukrainian side, & I believe it will as this conflict continues & Russian brutality escalates, we should not be surprise. 3/
Read 6 tweets
Jul 1
Casualties in Context 🧵:
Currently Ukraine claims 35,000 Russia KIAs over the past 4 months of fighting. Even assuming this number is somewhat inflated, it's indicative of the lethality of conventional peer/near-peer combat. Further assuming a baseline x3 wounded figure, it 1/
is useful to examine what that means in a NATO context. 35,000 KIA, in addition to 105,000 wounded (x3 KIAs), would give us a figure of 140,000 casualties overall. While this figure is certainly imprecise, it's not unreasonable given historical data on similar conflicts. 2/
35,000 KIAs would wipe out over half the German Heer, and the additional 105,000 wounded would wound every remaining member at least 3 times.

Strength: 63,132
3/
bundeswehr.de/de/ueber-die-b…
Read 10 tweets
Jun 30
NATO & the NRF by the Numbers🧵:
Sec.Gen. Stoltenberg has announced he wishes to expand the NATO Response Force (NRF) to 300,000 personnel, up from 40,000.

It is useful to examine what that means in the context of available European forces. If we take current active duty 1/
personnel numbers from European NATO members, excluding Turkey, we arrive at a force just under 1.465 million. On its face that would seem to be more than sufficient to cover the increase. Unfortunately, this number is somewhat deceptive. 2/
Units in any functional military will rotate through various states of readiness as a function of training, maintenance, leave, and other taskings. A good general rule is to assume only about 1/3 of the listed force is ready to be deployed at any given time. 3/
Read 8 tweets
Jun 26
Donbas Front 🧵:
As Severodonetsk is overrun & Lysychansk's encirclement continues, the UAF will be faced with some hard choices. Broadly speaking it has three options before it, the selection of which will be based on available resources & UAF's perception of the battlespace. 1/
First it can attempt a withdrawal under fire to evacuate its units from the pocket currently forming. This is an incredibly difficult operation to execute successfully, especially on a large scale in the face of an attacking enemy force. Successful execution requires units 2/
to progressively withdraw while comrades conduct a rearguard action. The danger is once battered units leave their fortifications, they will be increasingly vulnerable to renewed enemy attack & heavy fires. 3/
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(