Bar & Bench Profile picture
Sep 17 35 tweets 18 min read
AAP MLA Amanatulah Khan brought to Rouse Avenue Court by Anti Corruption Branch, Delhi govt after arrest in an alleged case of irregularities in Delhi Waqf Board. @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
Senior counsel @TheRahulMehra appears for Khan.
District Judge raps ACB sleuths: Question is where it should be filed? Don't you know the jurisdiction? Have you asked anyone where it should be filed? Why have you filed this application before another court? Case is pending in one court and you are asking for transfer.
DJ: Direct channel chala rahe hain. PPs ko kuch samajhte nahi hain. @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
Prosecutors Atul Kumar Shrivastava and Manish Rawat are representing ACB.
DJ allows plea of ACB, orders withdrawal of matter from Special Court and transfer to another court. @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah #corruption case
Special Judge Vikas Dhull presides. PP seeks custody of 14 days of @KhanAmanatullah. The complaint is that some persons, relatives have been appointed in the Waqf board.

@AamAadmiParty
PP reads provisions on appointment under the Waqf Act.

@AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
PP: They have shown urgency that people are not there. They gave (ad) in local paper. 22 were appointed from local Okhla, which the MLA represents.

@AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
PP shows an entry of "₹4 crore cash for Amanat sahab".
@AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
PP now showing other entities which he says pertains to money for #AmanatullahKhan
Besides, cash ₹24 lakh is recovered yesterday from 2 places (conduits).

@AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
PP: I'll gotten money has not stopped here, it has gone to Uttarakhand, Telangana. We are at a very initial stage.

@AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
PP while handing over documents to court: We need thorough investigation of this man.

@AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
PP: A person whose income is ₹4.32 lakh, is receiving cash of ₹4 crore, etc, etc.

@AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
PP: ACB official was manhandled, slapped when he went. Entire team was manhandled. Fire arms have been recovered. PP now shows video to Special Judge of the ACB official being reportedly being manhandled.

@AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
. @TheRahulMehra: They can go anywhere. Instead of Telangana they could have said London. What is the endeavour right now?
Applications on police remand are made in a manner jaise ki temple me aaye ho aur prasad le ke jaoge. 14 custody din maangenge, mil jayega. But it's not so.
. @TheRahulMehra now refers to the Waqf Act: It has an umbrella protection. First they have to move beyond this first. First they have to prove that it was not in good faith and second that what is done is beyond the scope of this act. @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
. @TheRahulMehra: For argument propose even if I say, worse case, there is something to do with recruitment, it is an irregularity and not an illegality. What law have i not followed? They have prove case beyond reasonable doubt. @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
@TheRahulMehra: What is the provision? What they are referring to is under the 1954 Act. He is reading the relevant portions of the Act @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
. @TheRahulMehra argues on the nature of employees who were recruited: Just because you have a high hand of the state, you'll say anything? There is still a rule of law. Ye Prasad nahi hai 14 din ka jo leke chale jayenge. I'm an MLA, millions of people know me;
. @TheRahulMehra: What's the purpose? Lakhs vote for me. He is a marked MLA, defame him when he is going to seek votes. Despite that he won with a handsome margin. @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
. @TheRahulMehra: Show how he has not cooperated. You show a diary. Anyone can insert names. Even names of constitutional authorities can be inserted in a diary. Who are these relatives? Even if they are blood relatives. Am I supposed to answer for them?...
.@TheRahulMehra: There is nothing to correlate with him.... As a fair state you must investigate. If he is found guilty, take him to the gallows. As an MLA, is he going to abscond? If he wanted to he would have done it earlier. @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
. @TheRahulMehra: you are doing a fishing and roving inquiry. How is related to Waqf? Anybody, anybody's accounts? Just because media is here. You flash it everywhere. @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
. @TheRahulMehra: How is ₹4 crore cash connected to me.... You can say whatever you want to say. Even that ₹3.2 crore. Where is the material to say this is Mr Amanatullah's? @AamAadmiParty
@KhanAmanatullah
. @TheRahulMehra reads a High Court judgment on remand. "Sitting MLA. You're not a terrorist. Trial will go on. Advanced democracies like the US people are not even arrested." @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
. @TheRahulMehra: Please ask where the accused was when this video was taken. I was in their custody. How can you connect it to me? @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
BREAKING: . @TheRahulMehra moves bail plea for @KhanAmanatullah. Let this be a test case for a sitting MLA, he says. "We must maintain the rule of law. Tomorrow it can be someone else on the receiving end. We must follow the rule of law". @AamAadmiParty
PP Atul Shrivastava: FIR is not an encyclopaedia. He has also said that the Act deals with only permanent employees. It doesn't mention contractual or permanent. @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
PP: Good faith has to be proved by you, not me. @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
Judge: What is the criminality?
PP: 5 relatives hain, 22 oklha se hain (MLA's constituency).
Mehra: He saying there were ads. Show which rules were violated?
PP names MLA's relatives.
Mehra: Ever since Delhi has come in existence, please ask how it was done? It was this way.
. @TheRahulMehra: You don't like the man... For two years, you should have brought before the court. First you wanted to show he is the bad character. Now you want to show the high court that he is an accused also.
Judge to PP: Did you investigate (a statement being referred to by the ACB) for the last two years?
PP: It's been investigated.
. @TheRahulMehra: why did this statement come only yesterday? It was being probed for last 2 years. A lot can be read into this also. @AamAadmiParty
. @TheRahulMehra: They're saying a lot of things. Let them bring all this on record. Give them a day, take how much ever time, and release me. @AamAadmiParty @KhanAmanatullah
Order at 5.30pm.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Bar & Bench

Bar & Bench Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @barandbench

Sep 19
#SupremeCourt to hear pleas by Gujarat cadre police officer Satish Chandra Verma, who assisted CBI probe in Ishrat Jahan encounter case, challenging his order of dismissal from service one month before his retirement as well as Delhi HC allowing the same till it next hears matter Image
Bench of Justices KM Joseph and Hrishikesh Roy hearing case.

Sr Adv Kapil Sibal for Verma: my lords either this Court should hear or the HC, i should not be left like this.

Bench notes that HC had earlier granted interim protection.
Sibal: My writ has become infructuous, they came to this Court they got notice not stay.

Justice Joseph: what was your original prayer?

Sibal: That chargesheet can't be filed. So this Court can hear on any day.

Justice Joseph: You're retiring on 29th.
Sibal: Yes.
Read 26 tweets
Sep 19
Day 7: [Hijab Ban hearing]

The Supreme Court will soon resume hearing a batch of appeals challenging the Karnataka High Court verdict that effectively upheld the ban on wearing hijab in government schools and colleges.

#SupremeCourt #SupremeCourtofIndia #Hijab #HijabBan Image
Senior Advocate Dushyant Dave: I will show constitution assembly debates for Article 25.

I will show what Sardar Patel, and Dr Ambedkar had feared. This was exactly what they feared. They forewarned us.

#SupremeCourt #SupremeCourtofIndia #Hijab #HijabBan #HijabHearing
Read 42 tweets
Sep 19
#SupremeCourt hearing plea by Income Tax Dept against HC dismissing plea against DK Shivakumar challenging discharge in connection with tax evasion cases. Image
Sr Adv Mukul Rohatgi: Your lordships may set it aside but please hear me ... If i have been assessed.

Justice Khanna: 277 and 276b are concerned.

Sr Adv Aryama Sundaram: We've not been proceeded with under 277 ...
Rohatgi: They've been given liberty what's the problem.
Justice Khanna: You file a return, he'll escape.

Rohatgi: they can levy any penalty... It's not that it is res judicata

SC says it may issue notice

SC: We have to set aside some findings. Other contentions we'll examine on merits.
Read 9 tweets
Sep 19
Supreme Court hears a plea by Enforcement Directorate seeks plea for transfer of investigation in the NAN scam case relating to IAS officer Anil Tuteja

CJI UU Lalit: But why is this an Article 32 petition? @dir_ed Image
SG: This is such a case that this court can excercise Article 142. A matter of this magnitude before the highest court of the country

CJI: Let us see the offences

Sr Adv Dwivedi: this scam is one which occurred during the BJP rule

SG: i will argue on facts and not allegations
SG: These highly placed officers in connivance with Authorities in constitutional posts took advantage. I have not mentioned names. But I have whatsapp charts
We have not revealed names so that faith of people is not shaken upon system
Read 23 tweets
Sep 19
#SupremeCourt delivers its verdict in the Delhi Sales tax matters challenging if exemptions can be provided in sales tax laws. Image
Order: In our view there is no conflict between the Kothari and Agra Belting cases. In the Kothari case, the question was whether tobacco can be made put under sales tax. Agra Belting was about the interplay between UP State tax laws.
Order: The reference to the Constitution Bench is incompetent and the question may be placed before a Regular Bench.

The Second Bench is answered by another Constitution Bench decision in JL Rao. There was no dissent to the view, in view of Article 145(5) ...
Read 6 tweets
Sep 16
#SupremeCourt hears the plea filed by the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) Bar Association Kolkata regarding vacancies at the Calcutta Bench of CAT
ASG Balbir Singh: two new members have been appointed against the vacancy of 17. This was done around two weeks ago #CATVacancy
Justice DY Chandrachud: There are 7 vacancies for judicial members. For Calcutta two appointment orders have been issued?

ASG: yes till they join, the other two have been given extension of tenure
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(