VatsRohit Profile picture
Sep 17 14 tweets 7 min read
- Here are some interesting points on the disengagement site discussed by @VishnuNDTV
- First, these Chinese posts are opposite PP15 in the side valley going north from Kugrang River.
- Its NOT in Gogra or Hot Springs region which have PP17A, PP17 and PP18
- Map in next tweet +
- Overview of the Chang-Chenmo Sector.
- You can see PP15&16, Chinese claim line (red) and location of the Chinese site under discussion.
- The LAC here is not in dispute here and this is the first time Chinese have created claim extending across their 1959 claim line and LAC +
+ Why were the Chinese acting antsy here?
- Because PP15 leads directly to upper reaches of Galwan river (blue line) which has large Chines presence.
- Chinese fear Indian attack along this axis.
- Forget direct assault; even Indian artillery placed in Kugrang Valley can +
+ hit Chinese positions.
- Kugrang valley is formed by Kugrang River starting from mountains NW of PP16, included PP16 and extends to PP17.
- Just south of PP17, Kugrang River merges with Chang Chenmo river coming from east and flowing alongside Gogra.
+
+ This is close-up of the Chinese Army position in the upper reaches of Galwan River.
- This serves as a base to support Chinese positions opposite PP14 where clash took place in 2020.
- If this base goes, Chinese lose entire Galwan River valley!
- Also, if IA takes this place +
+ it can use it as a base to turn right/east and gain access to Aksai Chin.
- See the map below.
- Long story short, the Chinese are quite paranoid about Indian presence and threat emanating from this area.
+
- Coming to the post under discussion, it is ~3km behind the Chinese claim line and LAC in this sector.
- I know @VishnuNDTV hasn't mentioned the location of LAC in his report, but the alignment of the Chinese claim line is not exactly a secret.
- So, Chinese have dismantled a +
+ on their side of claim line.
- Satellite from September 2020 on GE shows what was the actual intrusion here; the Chinese came few hundred meters on our side and pitched tents.
+
+ In this close-up, you can see where the Chinese had put-up temporary infra.
- Since this satellite image is of 18 Sep 2020, it also means that the Chinese had gone back within couple of months of stand-off.
- Interestingly, IA did Snow Leopard ops in early Sep 2020!
+
+ This is the satellite image from Sep 2020 of the site discussed by @VishnuNDTV on his program.
- It seems the site was prepared in 2020 itself but not occupied.
- There was another smaller post to its west, across the river here. Present status of this post is not known +
+ This is a recent satellite image of the same post from Apple but the date is not known to me.
- You can see trucks parked in the berm covered area.
- The smaller post is also visible to the west.
+
- This screengrab from @VishnuNDTV's program shows much higher level of development in as of August 2022.
+
- Now comes the interesting point
- @VishnuNDTV said that the post has been relocated ~3km to rear.
- Which means, the Chinese have effectively agreed to ~6km of buffer on their side of the claim line!
---xxxx---
Adding one correction from NDTV - the satellite image they've shared of the Chinese post (in use by the Chinese) is from August 2021 and not August 2022.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with VatsRohit

VatsRohit Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @KesariDhwaj

Sep 6
Future IT Hub?
- Given another episode of infra woes in Bangalore, questions are being asked, again, as to why no other city can emerge as the IT hub?
- Let me share with you a real world experience from my professional life, which I hope will answer this +
#bangalorerains
+ question to some extent.
- Many moons ago, I was consulting for a big developer, who for some reason had huge land bank in Mysore.
- A part of their leadership believed that given the proximity of Mysore to Bangalore, IT/ITES office demand will spill into Mysore as well.
+
+ Some others were skeptical and this is where my company came into picture.
- How do you address this question?
- Well, we devised a plan where we basically went and met a wide variety of IT/ITES companies in Bangalore and Mysore to take their opinion on Mysore as possible +
Read 15 tweets
Aug 7
@elmihiro @arzandc This is the ground reality, one can slice & dice it anyway one wants:
1. In the 90s and before 2014, the Chinese managed to claim & occupy 100s of sq.km of Indian territory with only a couple of Border Defense Regiments (BDR).
2. The Chinese literally fingered +
@elmihiro @arzandc + India so much that the Indian Army started a process of bringing existing formations back to their original strength (diluted earlier as troops were moved into Kashmir for CI Ops) and adding new formations.
3. This happened in Eastern Ladakh, Himachal-Tibet border, and +
@elmihiro @arzandc + Uttarakhand-Tibet border. Plus, Sikkim-Tibet sector.
4. Has anyone tried to understand why the Chinese went to such a great length to induct troops from outside Tibet this time as they tried to grab more territory?
5. Answer lies in what happened in September 2014 in Chumur +
Read 17 tweets
Jul 25
Honestly, haven't read a more pedestrian article on India's defense R&D. There is a lack of understanding about Indian defense set-up at a fundamental level amongst out IR community. One could write a small book pointing out the errors in this piece. Quite pathetic.
Let me take one example from this - NAG ATGM.
- If the authors had done their research, they would not have lamented on its timeline.
- Why?
- Because if you compare the timeline for induction of other 3rd Generation, Fire & Forget ATGMs, NAG is more or less on time + Image
+
- Not only that, it had to meet extreme user (Indian Army) expectations, which no other 3rd Gen, F&F ATGM has been able to meet.
- And except for Israel's Spike LR, there is no other 3rd Gen, F&F missile in same range class as NAG ATGM.
- Plus, look at the benefits + Image
Read 29 tweets
Jun 27
- In spite of how much I hate the casualness towards abortion reflected in this story, I think we've a bigger issue at hand, recourse to, and availability of abortion facility might be the only solution.
- Read on.
- Look around yourself. Casual sex is an society wide phenomenon+
+ which is not restricted to South Bombay or South Delhi.
- Its happening everywhere from cities to villages.
- The average age of boys and girls having intercourse has gone down drastically.
- All you've to do is go to any porn aggregator website and you'll see 000s of videos +
+ shot by youngsters themselves. You can make out their age and the fact that these videos are coming from all over the country.
- What happens when a girl becomes pregnant as a teenager or even older?
- The lady in the story from Instagram comes from a family where she can post+
Read 10 tweets
Jun 14
[Tour of Duty]
- Discussion and analysis on this important change int he manpower policy of the armed forces.
I'll hold my tongue on this TOD for now but I'll say this -
- Move towards creation of All India, All Class Infantry Regiments is a welcome development.
- While the Regiment system will remain, the composition of troops will be change to reflect all India character of the Army + Image
+
- This change is important because (a) you want to draw amongst the best talent available (b) It helps to mitigate against fissiparous tendencies.
- You don't want repeat of 1984 when some Battalions of Sikh Regiment and recruits at its training center mutinied and had to +
Read 51 tweets
May 1
#RussianUkrainianWar - Tank in modern warfare & Indian context.
- Pictures of destroyed Russian T-series tanks in Ukraine have raised questions about the viability of tanks in modern warfare. Again.
- And people are questioning their relevance in Indian context as well.
+
- 1st, I don't take the no about Russian tanks loses in Ukraine at face value.
- There is a 'famous' blog which has been documenting these loses, and to be honest, its far less than convincing.
- There is just too much western propaganda out there on the subject.
+
+
[Tanks versus missiles]
- ATGM vs Tank debate has existed even since the Egyptians surprised Israeli armor during Yom Kippur War using the Russian AT-3 'Swagger (9M14 'Malyutka')
- Israelis lost ~800 tanks during the war and the ATGM accounted for 20%-25% of these loses.
+
Read 39 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(