"It is an essential obligation of state government and foundational to life and liberty: New York requires children to go to school and to receive instruction in English and math and other basic skills that are necessary for participation in our democratic society."
"A @nytimes investigation into the state’s Hasidic schools laid bare the extent of the crisis. About 50,000 boys are attending these... schools, operated by Hasidic communities in NYC... where there is hardly any instruction in English & math, & even less in science & civics."
"A benchmark for any government is how rigorously it protects its most vulnerable, and New York is failing this test for most of the 50,000 boys who attend Hasidic schools." nytimes.com/2022/09/16/opi…
"But the changes are inadequate. The new standards allow schools to continue to operate within state law if they show good faith efforts to improve, a vague measure that can allow failing schools to operate indefinitely."
"The immediate crisis confronting the state is that dozens of Hasidic schools are operating in open defiance of state law, often barely offering classes in English. The state needs to establish a firm deadline for these schools to achieve compliance."
"Elected officials have known about this crisis for years and have not dealt with it. Parents, former students and teachers have outlined a systematic denial of education, which they say is intended to prevent them from succeeding outside the Hasidic community."
"Making sure that every child in New York has an adequate education is not only a moral obligation. It is necessary to allow those children to fully exercise their rights in our democracy."
Must read op-ed from @beawebwriter, a mother of 10 children whose children have attended and still attend Hasidic Yeshivas, on the recent @nytimes Yeshiva investigation.
Beatrice has been a vocal advocate for improving secular education in Yeshivas for years. In 2019, she filed a complaint and then a lawsuit to compel the city to ensure that her son's Yeshiva complies with the law:
She's written prolifically about the lack of choice for Hasidic parents, especially for those in custody battles, to switch their sons to compliant schools:
[THREAD] From @nytimes: Tens of thousands of students at Haredi and Hasidic Yeshivas are being denied the right to a basic education. After years of investigation, here are the facts. [1/15]
“The students in the boys' schools are not simply falling behind. They are suffering from levels of educational deprivation not seen anywhere else in New York, The Times found.” Yaffed has known this for years. yaffed.org/report/ [2/15]
We can’t understate how significantly schools are failing their students: “The Central United Talmudical Academy spans an entire city block in Williamsburg. All its students who took state tests in 2019 failed.” That’s more than 1,000 children, at just one yeshiva. [3/15]
Here's an ugly fact about education in New York State.
🧵
If a fundamentalist community chooses to set up shop and deny kids an education here, they are currently free to do so.
The laws may not permit it, but education authorities will turn a blind eye and allow it
It could be a fundamentalist Christian, Muslim, Jewish or any other religion or group.
They can deny an education to boys, girls, or both.
If you don't believe us, go ahead and ask @NYSEDNews Commissioner Betty Rosa what tools she currently has/uses to enforce against that.
Ask members of the Board of Regents. Ask NYC @DOEChancellor Meisha Porter.
This isn't hypothetical. The majority of Hasidic Boys in NY, which now numbers around 60,000, receive no secular education, especially once they enter high school.