BREAKING: DOJ files reply in 11th Cir. Highlights point from Special Master today. 1/
2/
3/ True, but Trump's lawyers would have access to what is charged.
4/Based on briefing to 11th Cir., my gut is they grant stay on use of info. for criminal investigative purposes but not on allowing Special Master/Trump's attorneys to review. That later point, DOJ is very weak on & add Special Master's handling shows 11th Cir. taken serious.
5/ And from today's hearing & case law cited Special Master is not going to give Trump's attorneys access unless Trump establishes it it was declassified with evidence. This is civil case. Trump's burden since presumed from marking. So I think SM got that right.
6/ Although, SM should review to ensure all marked classified. But from gov't reply brief, even if Trump presents evidence he declassified everything, DOJ is going to claim still no right to see b/c we seized it legally even if "personal record" and "no privilege possible."
7/ But D.Ct. said to review for privilege including executive so SM shouldn't refuse by saying no privilege. How Trump handles declassification is tricky because his attorneys have been using criminal defense lens & Dearie won't let that control in the civil case.
8/ So, if Trump has to come forward with evidence, question is how specific is he: 1) I declassified any materials I had brought to executive residence? 2) I declassified any materials I had mailed to Mar-a-Lago? 3) I declassified all materials related to Crossfire Hurricane?
9/9 But what if something was boxed up by GSA that Trump neither intended to be shipped nor saw? And Trump didn't intend to declassify? My gut is there are several documents that fit in that category. We'll know the strategy soon and 11th cir. ruling.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
THREAD: I haven't written on developments in Trump's Special Master case because I've wanted to noodle on things more & also it is so fast moving by time I wrote, edited, etc. it could be outdate, but here are my thoughts starting with 11th Circuit. 1/
2/ From briefing, my gut is 11th Cir. will allow DOJ to continue criminal investigation but not prevent Special Master from handling materials marked classified. I'd wager a decision will hit today or tomorrow on that & losing party will immediately seek S.Ct. reversal.
3/ On Special Master process, this here is key: Dearie and Cannon can talk without parties being informed, involved etc. IMNSHO no way Dearie doesn't talk with Cannon before proceeding & Cannon will be deferential to his input b/c of his experience. My gut is she will say
THREADETTE: Let's play a little "what if," experiment. What if Special Master reviews documents marked classified & NONE are still classified. That destroys entire "national security risk" peddled by DOJ & leaks to media. Yes, they will pivot to "obstruction," but problem 1/
2/ there given everything gov't says, it understandable those searching missed documents out of some 11,000. See here. thefederalist.com/2022/09/02/dej… Now, could there really be obstruction? Sure. I'm just doubtful.
3/ On other hand, if review shows documents marked classified remain and should remain classified & are damaging to national defense, that would be devastating to Trump as would solid evidence of obstruction. Yet it is DOJ who knows what is in those documents that DEMANDS
Per @CommandMagnetic request for tl;dr summary of THREAD: Yesterday Trump & DOJ filed "agenda" items of what they want to discuss with Special Master Judge Cannon appointed at today's 2 p.m. meeting. Several key things learned detailed below, but in sum. 1/
2/ Trump's agenda letter revealed Special Master had already put together proposal which suggested: 1) everything done by Oct. 7; 2) that magistrate who signed search warrant decide issues related to property return called Rule 41; 3) that Trump tell him NOW what he declassified.
3/ Trump objects to all three of those points, proposing longer time frame & saying other points are not within Special Master's authority. Key is that Trump claims what he declassified is relevant to his request for return of property which is what I've been saying all along.
BREAKING: DOJ & Trump file proposed agenda items for Special Master. Key take-aways: Special Master proposed schedule to end in early October; DOJ is acting as if it already has a stay while it waits for 11th Circuit to rule on its motion for a stay. 1/storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.usco…
2/ For instance, DOJ doesn't propose way forward for documents marked classified AND doesn't propose protective order for them. That's not how this works. You do it until 11th Circuit says you don't have too.
3/ Gov't wants 2 days notice to object to people on Trump's team seeing documents. And wants everything kept secret with protective order...while DOJ leaks.
2/ So this is how the gov't will prove Danchenko invented Millian phone call.
3/ First portion of Durham's brief addresses Danchenko's argument that questions were ambiguous or his answers literally true. Danchenko' attorney made strong argument but Durham's counter fully and completely devastates the argument IMNSHO so that argument should fail.