It's been a long trial, and I think we were all a bit tired of the whole thing. So today felt long, much thanks to the grueling repetitiveness of Wright's lawyers.
We did get a flying start from Hodlonaut's side this morning. Haukaas and Myklebust were at their top game today, citing law and picking the opposition's citations apart.
As a layman, I've found Hodlonaut's lawyers relatively easy to follow through most whole trial, in strong contrast to Manshaus and Helle who frequently reached for strange connections to arcane precedence. Such were their closing arguments. "When you have nothing, you put more."
From time to time they slipped into the Chewbacca defence. In particular their argument that evidence Hodlonaut didn't have available to him at the time of the tweets is inadmissible struck me as fully nonsensical.
My favourite moment today came as Haukaas pointed out the power differential between the sides, asking the judge to simply look at the room. Wright's nine lawyers against Hodlonaut's two. It's clear who's Goliath there.
Manshaus said Wright couldn't actually respond to Hodlonaut's tweets because his Twitter account was closed and he does NOT have his own media channel. As we left court we were met with Coingeek's fully staffed production crew who goes everywhere with him. Yeah, no.
I remain earnestly optimistic for a ruling that favours Hodlonaut. The sheer amount of doctored evidence is staggering and must make an impression on the judge. So must the hearsay and empty praise that were Wright's witnesses. Hodlonaut's lawyers showed her all this clearly.
It's been my great privilege to help give the events of this trial more public exposure.
I've found the whole experience a bit absurd, which I'll write about another time.
Thanks so much for reading and being so generous with your messages of gratitude and all your tips!
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
GM Oslo 🌅 It's the last day of the trial, and court will be in session in 90 minutes.
We'll hear the remainder of Hodlonaut's closing arguments in the first session (85 minutes), and the rest of the day will be Wright's closing arguments. And then we all go home.
Be aware that this isn't like in the movies where court ends with the declaration of the verdict and the bang of a gavel. We don't know exactly when the verdict will fall, but we're talking weeks, probably well into October.
What a day, it flew by. And by the end of it, I think we all shared a distinctive optimism. We expected a good day, but it was in fact a great day.
BDO and Cyfor witnessed for Hodlonaut. Well no, formally they were Wright's witnesses, but incredibly they shared KPMG's findings and even praised their report. Their remarks centered around methodology, and came off rather lightweight.
Manshaus pressed on the white paper hash differences, trying to ascribe it to sloppy KPMG work. I had no impression that any of that stuck; instead it felt like grasping at straws. Witnesses themselves largely discounted this.
It's been a nice and sunny weekend here in Oslo, spent seeing the sights and hanging out with awesome bitcoiners. Ready for the final two days of the trial! Court session starts in 90 minutes.
We're scheduled to start off with BDO's witness statement. They were hired by Wright's side to pick holes in the KPMG report. So far we've instead heard that they frequently agreed with KPMG's conclusions. Will be interesting to learn more about their findings.
The final part of the trial will consist of each side's closing statements. Hodlonaut's side starts today, likely to complete on Wednesday. Keep in mind that tomorrow is off due to scheduling issues after Wright changed lawyers before the trial.
Wright's witnesses today were yet more hearsay and praise and vague recollections with no retained evidence. A boring waste of the court's time.
It's hard to have a qualified opinion on Klin's diagnosis, but it having been handed out after three hours of personal interaction must be quite a bit too simple. Interesting that so much time was spent on assuring the court that he's really not a malignant narcissist.
KPMG has done proper work, as expected. Several findings seemed familiar from earlier cases. I got my wish – seeing Manshaus ask some of the world's foremost digital forensics experts if they had made amateur mistakes. These manipulations must be so harmful to their case.
It's KPMG day, rise and shine! In 90 minutes, court will be back in session. #WeAreAllHodlonaut
We'll hear from four more of Wright's witnesses (yes, he brought like 10 of them in total, #WitnessesAreProof). There is Bridges, Sinclair, Yousuf (don't have their full names – do you?) and Max Lynam. This will take the first half of the day.
Second half is all for KPMG and their report where they found a number of manipulations among the filed document evidence. They are the foremost experts in digital forensics, so this should be fun! I expects lots of the usual sloppiness.
Today's witnesses attracted a larger audience on both sides. I enjoyed seeing and meeting more bitcoiners, and still encourage more to show up!
The videos from Hodlonaut's side were old news to many, but they are a good selection of crazy and now the judge has seen them.
As expected, Hodlonaut's witnesses all did a great job. I thought Halseth would talk about Lightning, but instead he picked Sartre apart. Of course Wright would say yes it was fraud, but only to sabotage badman McGregor. Still shows Wright will use fraud as a tool.