What if tech companies spent way less money on lobbying and managing civil and human rights leaders and spent that all on ending the way their algorithms amplify white supremacists, authoritarians and their mouthpieces?
What if they deeply invested in safety across languages and geographies? And enforced their rules against the powerful to the same extent they enforce against the oppressed?
Just sayin. It doesn’t have to be this way. The people who run these companies make choices. Just like construction projects used to budget for a certain number of deaths, tech companies are budgeting for a certain amount of harm to humankind.
That’s why we have OSHA. Because people shouldn’t have to die to build a bridge. And people and democracy shouldn’t have to die to facilitate online communications.
Haugen's revelation that Facebook only takes down 3-5% of hate speech in violation of its policies doesn't surprise me - I've always thought Facebook's enforcement incredibly weak. But I am shocked by how many times FB has lied or misled us about this statistic. Examples below.
"On hate speech, we’re up to 94% of the content that we take down our AI systems and content reviewers find it before people have to report it to us."
Same man, same day: "And we’ve ramped up our capacity to identify hate speech and incitement to violence before people even see it on the platforms. Our AI and human review teams, you can track our results in the transparency reports that we issue, now take down about 94% of ...
We’ve always known that Facebook is a hate and lie profiteer. Thanks to Frances Haugen, we’re now certain that execs knew this and decided to put profits over public safety, and then lied to all of us about the depth and breadth of its harms. That’s harmful impact and intent.
We cannot trust Facebook to guard the henhouse. We need Congress and the FTC to act immediately, to compel transparency, to protect our civil and human rights.
Today @rashadrobinson@DerrickNAACP@JGreenblattADL and I will meet with Mark Zuckerberg, Sheryl Sandberg & other Facebook execs about the #StopHateForProfit campaign. Our demands are already on the table, they've been on the table, many long before this campaign ever came to be.
We're asking Facebook to: (1) Establish and empower permanent civil rights infrastructure including C-suite level executive with civil rights expertise to evaluate products and policies for discrimination, bias, and hate.