OBR confirms on record my story from 9 days ago that it prepared a draft forecast for new Chancellor waiting for him on first day at Treasury 6th September, and that an offer for a legally compliant forecast to accompany the mini-budget was rejected.
* We sent a draft economic and fiscal forecast to the new Chancellor on 6 September, his first day in office. We offered, at the time, to update that forecast
“In the event, we were not commissioned to produce an updated forecast alongside the Chancellor’s Growth Plan on 23 September, although we would have been in a position to do so to a standard that satisfied the legal requirements of the Charter for Budget Responsibility”… OBR
HM Treasury have previously told me that the OBR acknowledged that the forecast it could have published alongside the mini Budget, would not have been as full a document as normal, which is acknowledged by OBR, but it still would have been to legal standards.
Many market participants, traders, & eg ex BoE Governor Carney have identified this rejection of borrowing forecasts in mini budget as an important factor in the loss of market confidence seen… part of a “pattern” of undercutting independent institutions Carney told @bbcr4today
And to add to this, as I reported earlier this week, it is clear that the Bank of England insisted on more prominence for the OBR process as part of its “calm the markets” statement - and that will have some consequences…
Standard & Poors announces UK sovereign rating now on negative outlook from AA rating due to “rising risks to UK fiscal position… sizeable budgetary loosening announced Sep 23rd risk a substantial widening of the U. K. 's fiscal imbalances”
S&P: mini budget measures: “we believe risk raising cost of government borrowing and complicating the task of bringing inflation, which measured 9. 9% in August 2022, under control.”
“we estimate general government deficit will rise to an average 5. 5% of GDP annually 2023-25”
S&P: “for now it is unclear whether the government plans to ultimately introduce fiscal consolidation measures to bring debt back on a downward path and we assume that the package will be funded by debt, as announced.”
As PM meets OBR, £ is back up to USD levels during mini budget..
Not aware of precedent for this, eg Chote didnt meet Cameron in this way.
..OBR, whose offer of mini budget forecast was rejected, despite having provided a draft on first day of administration, in strong position
Why strong?
OBR demonstrate fierce independence, by insisting on offer of forecast and publishing transparent letters detailing how rejected.
Now, as Charlie Bean told World Tonight, he anticipates that Treasury might disagree with OBR over long term growth impact of Govt plans
Ex OBR/ BoE’s Bean says “quite likely” Chancellor/PM will take “different view” on impact of supply side policies incl tax cuts. OBR cautious without “genuine evidence” whereas gets sense Truss/ PM have a “particular view..not shared by bulk of economists or empirical evidence”
🚨
IMF says in statement “We are closely monitoring recent economic developments in the UK and are engaged with the authorities.” /1
🚨 💥
IMF on Truss/ Kwarteng mini budget
“given elevated inflation pressures in many countries, including the UK, we do not recommend large & untargeted fiscal packages at this juncture, as it is important that fiscal policy does not work at cross purposes to monetary policy.”
3/ IMF:
“the nature of UK measures will likely increase inequality. The Nov 23 budget will present an early opportunity for UK government to consider ways to provide support that is more targeted & reevaluate the tax measures, especially those that benefit high income earners.”
Sterling trade weighted at the end of play yesterday, was close to record lows, 12th weakest day on record, according to Bank of England data… 26% lower than 2005 values.
This is a broader measure of strength or not of pound
Other indices, which weight dollar higher were at record lows…
On BoE measure (trade weighted so more sensitive to euro value) interesting to see weaker days - pandemic meltdown, one day of 08 GFC, and various no deal Brexit points.
2016 Theresa May Con conference speech too.
But sterling was weaker against a basket of currencies last night (ie not even the record low in morning trading) than after Black Wednesday for example, Northern Rock, RBS collapse, immediate aftermath of Brexit vote.
That wouldn’t be driven, for example, merely by a strong US$
Sterling fell to an ALL TIME LOW against the dollar in early trading - lowest basically since the dollar was created… $1.035 recovered some of that in last hour, now at $1.06. But this is some slump after investors questioned the policy of massive tax cuts and borrowing…
It was down 5% at one point this morning vs dollar and 4% vs euro… now recovered to 3% down vs $ and 2% down vs € as we await market opening in Europe…
Markets awaiting some sort of intervention
Last on record comment we had from Chancellor about moves such as this was in an interview with the FT on Friday “I’m always calm… markets move all the time. It’s very important to keep calm and focus on longer term strategy”.