To understand why we have a GERM (Global education reform movement) problem, it's important to understand the chaos of empire. #EducationcaptureKE#Thread
1. With the oil crisis of the 1970s, American profits reduced, and companies decided to compensate for that loss.
2. As all selfish corporates do, they look at workers' salaries and benefits as a waste of money, and decide to cut them off.
The problem is that the unions wouldn't let them get away with it. #EducationCaptureKE
Side bar: What are unions?
Unions are groups of workers legally registered to negotiate for workers' pay and benefits. If unions go on strike, the law prohibits the employers from firing the workers.
Many of our disappearing rights were fought for by unions. #educationcaptureKE
3. So what do corporations do?
They lobby politicians to crush the unions so that workers cant negotiate (done by by Reagan and Thatcher).
Then they campaign for de-industrialization (done by Clinton). #educationcaptureKE
4. Where does that leave our Anglos?
With no industries, no work. Whole manufacturing towns are decimated (eg Detroit), and people are forced to work in service sector.
They start to salivate for social services. They look at public infrastructure like schools and hospitals as high value real estate, and at professionals like teachers and medics as labor for sale. #educationcaptureKE
6. But there's a problem: the public (parents and teachers) is not going to accept for the public schools of their kids to be reduced to business.
What do they do? Capture the narratives on education using the mainstream media. Turn parents against teachers. #EducationCaptureKE
7. With teachers' bargaining power reduced, they are given more bureaucratic work and less pay. US and UK are facing a teacher shortage because teachers just can't take abuse.
So there's a cohort of unemployed and experienced teachers. Where would they go? #EducationCaptureKE
8. GERM is made up of the same companies destroying education in UK & US spreading their gospel of team mafisi in developing countries.
Former teachers know where to hit and our education systems and they know the language of teachers. They can promote CBC. #EducationCaptureKE
9. So they repeat the cycle in Kenya again. This time, they use former UK and US teachers to use the right words, respond to the arguments of teachers, and to write op-eds in the newspapers.
In the 1990s, a civil society emerged from the professional class to fight against tyranny. It should have been a temporary arrangement to open up even the economic space, not just the political one. #EducationcaptureKE
11. Unfortunately, the government transformed this safety valve into a permanent feature for managing political transition in Kenya.
Universities then started to train Kenyans to be permanent NGO professionals to absorb unemployed graduates. #EducationCaptureKE
12. Just like the US and UK teachers, we are now in a space where medics are trained for medical policy, not to treat. Artists and humanities are trained peace-building, not to create. Teachers are trained to work in GERM, not to teach.
12 cont. Researchers are consultants for Western industrial interests, not for knowledge creation. Professors are for regulating and inspecting universities, not for teaching.
So consultants have more say on education than the teachers themselves. #EducationCaptureKE
14. So why CBC?
CBC reduces knowledge to tasks, makes parents fill the gap with "involvement and teachers fill it with constant testing, makes kids busy with "fun" activities which don't enhance learning, paves the way for technology to replace teachers. #EducationCaptureKE
15. The biggest con that the media pulled off is to restrict the CBC conversation to expense. That's exactly where Team Mafisi wants us to be, because now you will demand for more public money to be put in schools.
16. I used to think that Cambridge Analytica, tyranny of numbers was the biggest psychological manipulation pulled off in Kenya. I now see that CBC was much better and more effective, because the KYMs are professors and not rambling politicians. #EducationCaptureKE
17. With teachers, our guard is down. We don't expect them to be manipulated or manipulative. And the manipulation is not as direct.
There's no way to get out of this mess other than putting in the days and months to understand how we got here. #EducationCaptureKE
18. Sadly, kids wont stop growing as they wait for us to understand. But the mess is so entangled and convoluted, that if we want a quick fix, we are going to make things worse. The work we have to do is like disentangling wires slowly by following each wire #EducationCaptureKE
19. What we needed was not a taskforce on TVET, but a Commission to write a philosophy of education (Kenya doesn't have one), then do an investigation of how we got CBC, not remedy CBC. Then we shut off the vulnerabilities of Kenya's education space. #EducationCaptureKE
20. For now, all we can do is tell stories. Tell our kids our stories as a medicine against the fragmentation of CBC. But we too must repair our own knowledge of our stories, and heal the stories we tell education.
Arguments like this are why we need more anthropology in economics. Business people and bureaucrats have this naive expectation that reality always goes according to their intentions. They don't understand a thing called "perverse incentives."
Kenya is an extremely cruel country because our political culture is aristocratic. And the idea of using debt, rather than work, to build an economy is also based on cruelty. So CRB in an economy like ours will inevitably end up being used for cruelty, rather than efficiency.
To then tell us "that was not our intention" is naive.
Banks and @CBKKenya need to employ anthropologists in their ranks who can tell them how economic policy will be lived and felt on the ground. This naivete and social illiteracy is inexcusable.
The story of British media and Jeremy Corbyn is a story about how the media picks one narrative, drowns everyone in it, finds irrational and emotional supporters to rant about it, until their story looks like the reality. Kenya media has done the same with BBI and CBC.
The media tactic is to overwhelm us with a single story and go crazy or silence us when we introduce a diversity of stories. I have been called names by CBC supporters less for opposing CBC and more for complicating the stories. The danger of the single story by Chimamanda.
If you look at the pro-CBC replies to my tweets, you will notice that they don't respond to what I actually say. They'll say employment, I'll say employment is an economic issue, then they'll respond using different words about skills that kids need to earn a living.
I started #MaishaKazini because of the lies about education and work that we were being told in defence of CBC. I thought the media and NGO people had flawed ideas and that we were having a debate. Because I was not being heard, I started a channel. youtube.com/c/MaishaKazini
I tackled these lies:
1. We don't need theory, only skills 2. Unemployment comes from bad education 3. Exam obsession is caused by the curriculum 4. Our education is too theoretical
All these lies are racist and designed to keep Africans from thinking #EducationCaptureKE
With @m_ogada we showed again and again how Western capital and Kenyan elites are determined to separate our work from the dignity and material benefits that we should get from our work. #EducationCaptureKE
The roots of TVET are plantation slavery. Once slavery ends, the US had to find a way of making sure that African Americans dont get an education that leads to citizenship. That model was brought to Kenya in the 1920s.
But the racist argument that Africans don't need to think, they only need to work with our hands, led to a misdiagnosis of colonial education as theoretical instead of practical.
Another argument of GERM is that we have unemployment because kids don't have practical skills.
We have unemployment those who get rich on the work of others need the unemployed to be so desperate that they sell their labor for zero. #EducationCaptureKE
There's no point of a state capture investigation when you gazette education capture. Kenyans think what power wants to capture is the state, but what it really wants to capture is the children. Because they tie down power for the next two generations. Nkt. #EducationCaptureKE
Foreigners poach the best talent from Kenya, crush their innovations, give them jobs in global organizations to detach them from contact with people on the ground, then weaponize those they poached to destroy our school system. And then we think state capture is only about money.
Wazungu know that to capture our thinking and our youthful energy is to capture everything, but Hustler government is stuck in the colonial narrative of TVET.
Would the colonialists have come up with TVET if they thought it would lead to development?
I'm no longer in support of CBC. I'm done. I'm not going to say "maybe if..." anymore. My position is we go back to 8.4.4, and we reform our own system, with our own teachers.
It's ok if I'm alone. I've made my peace with this position. #educationcaptureKE
Not that kids go back to grade 3, but they go to std 7 in 8.4.4. Teachers understand 8.4.4 because they've been doing it for years. They can fill in the gaps they notice, and suggest how we can reform our education, our way. #educationcaptureKE
CBC can't be fixed because it wasn't ours to start with. Our schools system was infiltrated by the GERM (global education reform movement) who took us for a ride for 5 years. They captured the narrative, they captured the media, they captured @EduMinKenya