Thread by @SteB777

Liz Truss' demonization of what she is calling the #antigrowthcoalition seems to actually be identical to what now disgraced former Conservative MP, and former Environment minister Owen Paterson called, the "green blob".
theguardian.com/environment/20…
1/🧵

Here is Paterson's description of what he called "the green blob", which seems to be identical to what Truss is calling the #antigrowthcoaltion. This is highly significant, as both Truss and Paterson were former Environment Secretaries.
theguardian.com/politics/2014/…
2/

When Michael Gove was Education Secretary, he also claimed to be opposed by "the blob".
3/

It's very difficult to know what's going on here. Specifically, whether these politicians are as confused and deluded as they sound, or if they are knowingly being mendacious, and are knowingly creating imaginary enemies and conspiracies they know to be false i.e. propaganda.
4/

Liz Truss, seems to be grouping the Labour Party in this supposed #antigrowthcoaltion, which is just absolutely bizarre because the leader of the Labour Party announced his own all out "mission for economic growth" 2 months before Truss.
labour.org.uk/press/keir-sta…
5/

It really is bizarre, because Liz Truss is grouping together political parties, organizations that range from being growth obsessed and apparently neoliberal, to those actively campaigning for degrowth i.e. polar opposites.
6/

It's also impossible to know whether Truss is just reading from a script, a pre-worked out strategy emanating from some right wing thinktank or similar, or whether she is genuinely and personally confused.
7/

One thing I do know a lot about is conservation, sustainability, ecology, thinking about the climate and ecological crisis, and the positions of the various political parties, organizations and individuals, Truss is calling the #antigrowthcoalition.
8/

One thing I know for absolute certain, is that these organizations and perspectives have never been working together, in any sort of way. Many are fundamentally opposed to each other, and about the only thing they have in common is opposing Conservative Party policy.
9/

The really deep irony, is that this supposed #antigrowthcoalition never previously existed, but Truss has created a self-fulfilling prophecy by essentially declaring war on the natural world. Creating a potential real coalition that never previously existed.
10/

Overall, the deep serious problem, is that whilst in practise declaring war on the natural world, and practically engaging in active climate change science denial, that Truss' government, denies both.
11/

This is the huge problem in dealing with such utterly dishonest people, who say one thing, and are self-evidently doing what they deny i.e. knowing what you are dealing with i.e. someone who is totally confused, or a bare-faced liar.
12/

You see you need an entirely different strategy to deal with someone who is just confused, and someone/group, which is knowingly dishonest. You can reason with a confused person, but not a bare-faced liar who knows exactly what they are doing.
13/

This problem of "disingenuity" is I think one of the major dilemmas facing environmentalists, conservationists and NGOs, today. I feel a massive amount of effort has been wasted trying to reason with people who are just utterly dishonest.
14/

As I imply, it is completely futile trying to reason with an ideologue, who just sees the natural world and natural systems as meaningless, and which are just commodities to be exploited.
15/

If you try to argue or reason with a politician who is knowingly disingenuous about the natural world and natural systems, they will make hollow and false promises, because their focus groups tell them it is a box that needs to be ticked.
16/

The UN Secretary General, says action on the climate crisis is a litany of broken promises, and these politicians are actual liars. What is the point of climate talks etc, if these liars just make promises they have no intention of putting into action?

17/

In some way, it is useful that finally we can see who the real enemy of the natural world is, even if they are still lying about it. Let's give Liz Truss the #antigrowthcoalition coalition that never existed before.
18/

@threadreaderapp Please unroll?