1/ Is General Sergey Surovikin, Putin's newly-appointed commander of his 'Special Military Operation', being set up as a scapegoat for the failures of the Russia forces in Ukraine? A commentary by the Donbas separatist Alexander Khodakovsky suggests so. A 🧵 and translation:
2/ Khodakovsky says that Surovikin's appointment will bring two advantages: he will have quicker access to 'the first person' (i.e. Putin) and "the opportunity to make his position known directly, bypassing the upper echelon of the military hierarchy," who he blames for failures.
3/ But, he says, "a responsible person has been appointed on whom all the sins [of the operation] will be pinned. I am sure that this appointment does not make Surovikin happy at the moment."
4/ Khodakovsky suggests that there is a power struggle going on within the Russian Ministry of Defence, in which two figures – Surovikin and General Alexsandr Lapin – are vying to take over the position of Chief of the General Staff, currently held by General Valery Gerasimov.
5/ He writes that Lapin and Surovikin "both represent different centers of power, there is no better way to bring down Surovikin than to appoint him responsible for the course of the operation", particularly when the war is going badly and the Ukrainians have the upper hand.
6/ The war has prompted "everyone, including the army chiefs of different ranks" to seek to reinforce their positions and ranks, which they want to hold on to despite the current difficulties.
7/ Lapin and Surovikin and their respective centres of power "both love the Motherland in their own way and wish the best for it, but the means and methods [by which they want to pursue the war] are different."
8/ "What is happening now in the upper echelons, when two powers come into competition, is a very important process, the outcome of which will determine the outcome of this global confrontation.
9/ "No one is saying that the old guard should be rounded up and given a handshake, wishing them a productive retirement, but a new type of anti-crisis thinking is needed. This applies to all sectors, including the economy. Next year will be difficult – we need to be prepared."
1/ Newly mobilised Russians with little or no training are already being killed and wounded in Ukraine, according to Russian media outlet It's My City (IMC). IMC says that three mobiks from Krasnoturyinsk in the Sverdlovsk region have returned – two injured, one dead. More ⬇️
2/ IMC initially reported that a local man named Yevgeny Bizyaev (pic ⬆️) had been killed, but an update to the report has clarified his status as wounded. He was called up on 28 September and sent to the combat zone only a few days later along with others from Krasnoturinsk.
3/ According to the mobiks' relatives, they were sent without training, contracts or even a medical examination to check their physical fitness. The relatives have sent a complaint to the Sverdlovsk regional prosecutor's office outlining the situation.
1/ The independent Russian media outlet Verstka ("Layout") has published a noteworthy piece on the devastating effect that mobilisation is having on Russia's schools. Thousands of teachers have been conscripted or have fled, bringing schools to the edge of collapse. 🧵 follows.
2/ Verstka reports that at one private school in St Petersburg, 80 percent of the teaching staff have left or are going to leave, due to themselves or their partners either being mobilised or fleeing abroad to avoid the draft. The school may now close as a result.
3/ In some schools, teachers have been handed mobilisation notices in front of their entire class. Star teachers have not been spared. One was awarded the title of 'Honored Teacher of the Republic of Bashkortostan' but was mobilised the following day.
1/ What tank repair doing? The Russian Baza Telegram channel reports that a clumsy tank repair crew in Crimea managed to accidentally fire a shell at a house 8 km away, injuring a child. (No word on whether vodka was involved.) Translation follows. ⬇️
2/ In Crimea, a tank was being repaired and accidentally fired – the shell flew eight kilometres and hit the wall of a private house. A girl was injured.
The tank was being repaired in the village of Novostepnoye. During repair works there was an unintentional shot.
3/ The shell hit the house located on Sadovaya Street in Dzhankoy. At that moment, 11-year-old Diana was there - the girl received a laceration to her forearm and was hospitalised. /end
1/ With hundreds of thousands of Russian men having fled the country to avoid mobilisation, a law may be introduced to ban those registered for military service from leaving the country. Translation follows of a report from the independent Russian media collective ASTRA. ⬇️
2/ "The chairman of the Crimean State Council, Vladimir Konstantinov, has said that the Crimean parliament will propose to introduce relevant amendments to federal laws.
3/ He proposed that a clear prohibition be imposed on a citizen of the Russian Federation who is or is obliged to be on the military register to leave the country during a general or partial mobilization,…
1/ The independent Russian media outlet Sota is reporting that 100 newly mobilised Russian troops are refusing orders to mount an attack on the recently liberated town of Lyman, after only one out of a previous group of 100 men returned from Ukraine. Translation below. ⬇️
2/ "More than 100 mobilised men from the Bryansk region, who are now in the village of Soloti in the Belgorod region, have refused to go to war with Ukraine.
3/ The mobilized men themselves told Sota that they are meant to go to recapture Lyman, although according to their information, only one of the previous Bryansk group of about 100 men returned and is now in hospital.
1/ Did the Crimea bridge explosion happen in the wrong place, and what does this suggest about how it might have been triggered? A 🧵 collecting some thoughts and observations that have been gathering in my mind over the last couple of days.
2/ When I first heard about the bridge explosion, my first thought was that it was in an odd place. This aerial photo shows what I mean. The arrow shows the approximate point of the detonation (which the Russians blame on a truck bomb) and the fuel train that also caught fire.
3/ This photo from before the rail bridge was completed is taken from almost the exact spot where the explosion apparently happened – just before the road slopes up to the twin arches over the shipping lane.