Coming into land at Heathrow… after an eventful week at the IMF, off the plane that Kwarteng was meant to be on … not much can have happened in 7 hours, surely? ✈️ #A380
a lot going on in the world economy that we didn’t get a chance to cover because of the UK focus…
Mentioned on Ten last night, Will write up, but TL DR…
- concerns that in rising rates era, more corners of lightly regulated non bank sector bound to pop as LDI pensions did…
-abundantly clear at highest portals of foreign financial power, in Governments & banks etc, that question marks over UK market credibility matter, eg told UK gilt crisis shifted Federal Funds futures rate.
saying there have been no UK specific factors is credibility destroying
demonstrably untrue “no uk factors” claim is one thing hitting credibility, as it signals a clear lack of willingness to deal with a problem, because it is fundamentally a denial of one… but as bad, poss worse was what I heard about something else …
Market players can discount tall political claims, sure, but when pol figures say things that sound as if they have no clue what theyre talking about - that’s a major issue.
Big ex - idea mortgage rates are only linked to Bank of England base rates, when 2/5 yr gilts v important
Clear to me that in past 3 weeks senior UK officials who do understand these things have had to explain some market basics to some Cabinet ministers in an effort to stop them saying things that weaken market credibility/ seem to deny problems in a way received as a market signal
And we have been in a moment where random comments from even non senior British Cabinet ministers get flashed on Reuters/ Bloomberg terminals, and traded upon in debt markets, in a somewhat unstable way, not at all normal for an advanced G7 economy…
So that is new Chancellor’s challenge (forgive me haven’t heard his interviews yet ✈️ )
-clean up the mess, win back most of the lost credibility, come up with politically viable plan that adds up, BUT against backdrop of further risks from eg non banks in global finance system
I’ll write up reflections from a week talking to some of these players at the IMF meeting, after I’ve had a chance to hear Chancellor Hunt’s interviews.
Also need to relay story of Thursday at the IMF with Chancellor Kwarteng, extraction from embassy in blacked out cars etc
One last thing - having watched this play out in other countries, what could predictably happen is that the finance minister tells colleagues to shut up, and becomes the single point of market contact, delivers on what they say, calms the situation, and then becomes v powerful.
How politically sustainable is that though?
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
“We’re going to have to take some very difficult decisions both on spending and on tax. Spending is not going to increase by as much as people hoped,.. taxes are not going to go down as quickly as people thought & some taxes are going to go up”
Hunt tp @bbclaurak : “for people who’ve got mortgages who want to know, that as interest rates go up all around the world, they’re going up by the absolute minimum necessary in this country as well, they need to know that we’re giving that certainty to the markets”
Hunt: “We are going to have a very big fiscal statement, a bit like a budget…& that’s going to be independently verified by the Office for Budget Responsibility. We’ve been honest that it was a mistake not to do that in mini-budget before and that is now going to be sorted out”
On behalf of all UK broadcasters spoken to Chancellor
Is there going to be a u-turn?
“Our position hasn't changed. I will come up with the medium term fiscal plan on the 31st of October as I said earlier in the week, there'll be more detail that”
Q: Markets are already responding to the idea there's going to be a U turn on corporation tax. Is that not a possibility? Can you clarify that is even a possibility that you're going to u turn on the corporation tax?
“My total focus closer is on delivering on the mini budget”
Q: But Chancellor, you have a situation where, you've come here to discuss important issues back home at number 10 there are discussions filleting the fiscal statement that you made just a few weeks ago that must be humiliating?
overnight news in UK bond markets is incredible 40 basis points fall in 30 year yield this morning, amid expectations of major U-turn. Those expectations weren’t stoked here in DC by Chancellor, but there were some other interesting developments…
here at IMF at G7 finance ministers meeting I did pick up some veiled criticism and surprise from around the table re policies in the mini budget, specifically unfunded tax cuts… “surprise” at the “doubling down” on these policies…
US Treasury Secretary Yellen was on the record here in an interview with CNBC saying: “watching UK developments closely". While she didn't want to comment directly on UK policy, she said: "I am going to try to understand what the impact of those policies and their rationale is."
Morning from DC where Chancellor arrived a few hours ago…
- 20Y gilt yields (effective Govt borrowing costs) just topped 5% again 5.02 for first time since Bank of England first intervened after mini Budget…after Bailey hard line message
- shock August GDP fall
Not sure I buy the idea that there’s private reassurance the bond buying programme will prolong. Bailey not only volunteered the “you have 3 days” comments, he then when asked for reassurance by the BBC outside, reiterated it unprompted, on camera…
BUT..
What there is into next week is a Temporary Expanded Collateral Repo Facility (TECRF)… which will help banks to help those LDI funds with liquidity, which many in the market thought was the appropriate tool to deal with this anyway…