André Gonçalves Bidá Profile picture
Oct 15, 2022 • 21 tweets • 9 min read • Read on X
1. Crimea Bridge explosion occurred 1 week ago.
It will disrupt dramatically Russian invasion logistics through their main and safest route. Follow a longer 🧶 to evaluate the damage at Crimea Bridge, from a failure analysis engineering perspective.
#CrimeaBridge
#Engineering
2. How long repairs will take? That's the key question.
In order to try to answer is necessary understand, considering the bridge design and construction aspects, damage details, evaluate possible structural damages, in order to access how complex such repair will be.
(The event) The explosion occurred at automotive bridge towards Crimea, by a detonation between piers 237 and 238. The bridge girder collapsed. Other girders fall from its piers, some damage to bridge towards Russia occurred and a fire in a close train fuel cars was ignited.
4. (Causes) Explosion hypothesis:
(1) explosives in a truck or VBIED,
(2) a ballistic missile,
(3) an attack from sea with a drone vessel and
(4) a submersible drone.
All physical evidences support a detonation above the bridge, and not below.
5. Basically, there is no physical evidence which sustains any detonation below the bridge. For more details about cause hypothesis, please check @OAlexanderDK analysis, which is very consistent.

6. There are experts which defended the ballistic missile theory, like @ChuckPfarrer. But at same time the rupture in the bridge center is consistent with missile impact, the energy of detonation is not consistent to any energy estimative, more in this 🧵

7. Regarding the truck source, @ChrisO_wiki made a long tread about the truck and its load transit, from Odessa to Crimea Bridge, based on Russian media, with a lot of evidences of its trail.

8. Recent evidences reinforce truck explosion hypothesis, like the identification of the truck front axle, stuck 100m from detonation location into the girder side of pier 239, close to external bearing support.

(Failure Analysis) In order to evaluate the damages, it is necessary understand the sequence of events, and how much bridge elements were affected, mainly girders, piers and bearing caps. The events sequence was well explained at this @andrew_barr tweet

10. The girders are 260m long, between expansion joints. The girder in the lane where the explosion occurred, is completely damaged in multiple points. It will need be replaced by a new one. The side bridge presents significant deformation downwards, aligned to detonation point.
11. Despite “minor” damage to side bridge, its concrete support at pier 238 bearing is completely cracked, compromising the bridge structure at this point. In the original pier design such bearing supports were cast directly into pier cap.
12. Based in such failure and the location of explosion, it is likely to have other bearing caps at piers 238 and 239 severely damaged as well. That's why Russian engineers reduced the bridge load, allowing only few cars in one single lane, in low speed.
13. To repair the concrete below each bearing support, it is very difficult. Each bearing support will inspected by NDT, likely ultrasonic inspection. Any concrete element with critical cracks will be rebuilt, in lengthy process to clean cracked elements and recast the concrete.
14. (Explosion force estimative) The pier 238 bearing failure allows estimate the reaction forces at this point, and the explosion energy itself. The concrete below bearing support shows very long cracks, following the max shear stress planes, consistent with compression loads.
15. With bridge design details and some material science, it is possible estimate the minimum load necessary to crack the concrete support: 7,000 kN. Doing some beam calculations, the normal load in the plastic deformation area is ~ 10,000 kN. See bridge cross section below.
16. Considering the truck load position, blast direction, and the force magnitude that caused the plastic deformation, the energy necessary to cause such deformation can be estimated at ~19 GJ, equivalent to, at least, 5 tons of TNT.
17. (Railway Bridge) Regarding railway bridge, I made a detailed failure analysis, but I need correct a detail, as I found a design weakness which makes the fire damage worse than expected: there is no concrete or ballast between steel deck and sleepers.

18. In the Crimea Bridge design, the sleepers seats directly on top of a EPS (expanded polystyrene) layer, covered by a geoblanket, and not on top of the ballast, as usual. What looks a nice cost and bridge weight reduction, will make the repair way more costly and difficult.
19. With the fire, it is likely that all EPS melted, and now sleepers will seat directly on top of a heavy deformed steel deck, without a ballast (3) layer to compensate any heat induced deformation (2) of the structure. Another lengthy repair for the Russian engineers.
20. The explosion at Crimea Bridge was huge, and the damage, extensive. Just yesterday, Russia’s ordered contractors to repair the bridge by July, 1st 2023. A huge engineering challenge.
And the “deadline”, defined by decree. (end)
PS: Special thanks to people that helped a lot, sharing detailed information of bridge design and construction, mainly @IntelCrab, @MarcinOzdzinski and @dram_at. You rocked.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with André Gonçalves Bidá

André Gonçalves Bidá Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @andre_bida

Oct 11, 2022
@Osinttechnical I am a materials engineer specialized in metallic materials and failure analysis.
Nice videos. It can help to understand somehow damage the fire caused.
🧶
First we need understand this is not one railway bridge. Are 2 railroad bridges, side by side, additionally to road bridges.
@Osinttechnical In the Crimea Bridge design, each girders shares same pier cap, on top of double piers. Based on construction pictures, ballast decks are done of steel, with a concrete slab and curb to bed the rail track on top of double I beams. ImageImageImageImage
@Osinttechnical In your pictures we can see 2 distinct damages on the north rail girder: steel walk pass and rail tracks severely damaged. Other potential damages to concrete slab, girder main structure, and pier bearings, critical for structure safety, are not visible.
Read 7 tweets
Jan 20, 2021
@cnpaiva @mab_sp125 Claudia, este trabalho da Lagier tem umas coisas bem estranhas.
Bruno, sou das exatas. Se falar bobagem, me corrija!
Vou pontuar detalhes que, para mim, nĂŁo passariam numa revisĂŁo de artigo (PS: sou revisor da ASQ). O fio vai ser meio longo.
@cnpaiva @mab_sp125 Aqui é 1° trecho do artigo que eu torço o nariz: “não alocado randomicamente, mas...”. Não-aleatório na estatística pode, mas é terreno perigoso.
@cnpaiva @mab_sp125 A estatística (Fischer e chi-square) que ele escolheu assume resíduos aleatorios, normais e com média zero, mas ele escolheu dados “não-aleatorios” e faz um matemática que requer o oposto? Tudo bem. Sou liberal até no método científico. Esperava uma análise de resíduos. Não tem.
Read 11 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(