Quick thread here on Russian attacks on Ukrainian power plants and electricity infrastructure — major issue obviously, but Ukraine's defenses against cruise missiles and drones are rapidly evolving, which will help, but the real issue is Iranian ballistic missiles...
Ukraine only has very limited and rudimentary anti-ballistic missile defenses via a handful of S-300V systems, and those are needed to keep traditional Russian airpower at bay, which is absolutely critical...
Iranian ballistic missile work, they carry a much larger payload than the Shahed drones and hit way harder than the land-attack cruise missiles. Russia is low on Iskander-M SRBMs so they are not the threat they were, and they need to keep a good reserve of them for...
strategic purposes beyond the war in Ukraine. So, if (really when) the Iranian ballistic missiles arrive, they will likely be turned on electricity infrastructure to absolutely devastating results. These are big targets well within the missile's accuracy envelope...
If the supply is in the hundreds to start as we think is the case, this could be a major problem for Ukraine going into winter. The primary western air defense system that exists in significant numbers that can defend critical areas against these types of missiles is the...
Patriot system, especially later variants including PAC-3, but supplying them to Ukraine is no simple task. They require a LOT of training both in their tactical employment and sustainment, they are technologically sensitive, and they are very much prized...
commodities around the world. Still, America's top uniformed officer has floated that supplying them is a possibility, but once again, unless NATO enters the conflict by directly deploying Patriot batteries to Ukraine or some sort of contractor arrangement (unlikely)...
is put into play, it's not like these can just show up in weeks or even months. I know this is troubling, but it is the reality of the situation...
There are other options but the arsenal depth of interceptors and availability are key here. These could be engaging a lot of targets etc. So, a lot is riding on not seeing those Iranian missile shipments show up in Russia. The world has done little to curtail this with...
the above-board levers it has to pull sadly. The clandestine side of the equation is a total unknown of course and Israel is likely very troubled by all this. The cash and whatever else Tehran is getting for these weapons is certainly a problem for Israel...
But that doesn't mean they will do anything about it at this time. There has been some movement there though, Israel now says it will help Ukraine with acquiring and activating surveillance systems the country needs to help defend against Iranian weapons...
This sounds like too little to many, and that is certainly fair, but don't discount this contribution. Israel has the most advanced layered air defense system on this planet, with unique sensors that enable it. This includes the exact types of systems Ukraine...
needs to be able to spot, track, and help engage Iranian drones and cruise missiles. They have developed this capability out of necessity, it exceeds anything the U.S. can offer. They know the long-range suicide drone war is the next combat frontier for them and they are...
and have been actively developing sensors, including airborne look-down sensors (critical!) to defend against hordes of low and slow flying small signature drones. This is exactly the early warning and track data Ukraine needs badly...
They also have the ability to move fast and get systems in play to impact these Iranian weapons. Of course, once again, other measures could be in play clandestinely...
And Israel knows better than anyone the weaknesses even in Iran's proven ballistic missile capabilities, not just from a battlefront angle but others as well. Even non kinetic countermeasures, cyber capabilities, and more could help here in some fashion...
So I know this is troubling news, but there is movement in positive directions as well. Things can change fast, and what is today, may not be the case tomorrow.

As always, excuse typos, thank you for taking the time to read and I look forward to hearing your thoughts below.
Some supporting links:
And especially this, from last week before Iran was sending BMs: thedrive.com/the-war-zone/c…

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Tyler Rogoway

Tyler Rogoway Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @Aviation_Intel

Oct 20
Andor is finally trending. Best Star Wars anything for a very long time, possibly ever for me. Some people say it's slow/not enough action. I feel like we may as well be on different sides of the force. Cracks my kyber crystal. We finally get...
a political spy thriller of this level in the Star Wars universe with maybe the best world-building I have ever seen, top-notch acting and character development, incredible writing (yes in Star Wars!), and just an air-tight script and insane production values...
& people want constant laser swords & super kid sidekicks, even though there are hundreds of hours of that stuff readily available. Above all else, we have a real empire, not toned down to sell toys, really fucking scary and dangerous assholes...
Read 13 tweets
Oct 19
If it's all about targeting Ukraine's ability to make electricity, specifically major power generation facilities, Centurion C-RAM could potentially help protect a few of those specific & very geographically finite targets. But once Iranian ballistic missiles arrive...
Ukraine will have no robust way to defend its major power facilities from attack.

Once again, Centurian is NOT an area defense weapon and has very limited applications, but it could provide an inner defensive layer at a handful of very high-value facilities, especially...
from drone attacks. But even this is 'off label' for the system. This would only supplement area air defense capabilities like NASAMS and IRST-T SLM, it is no way a replacement for them in any way...
Read 7 tweets
Oct 17
Only the beginning. Iran pays zero price, gains much-needed hard currency and god knows what else, for supply standoff weapons used for indiscriminate 'vengeance weapon'-like attacks on Ukraine.

They will set up licensed assembly in Russia and the ballistic missiles are coming.
Israel is likely very interested in what is being exchanged for these weapons and how it will impact its own security. With a massive foreign export customer now likely taking anything it can get, Iran will be able to fund much greater production capabilities and will use...
the cash for other purposes that Israel will be concerned with. In addition, by mass export, rapid evolution of technologies can occur. Their standoff weaponry's capabilities will be enhanced in a much more rapid fashion with such funding and widespread battlefield use experience
Read 5 tweets
Oct 16
It's not a bottomless pit. NATO has always underfunded PGM inventories. It adds up fast and the long lead times on many high-tech components mean you can't just spin up production and spit them out fast. We need to come to terms with this. A peer state conflict...
would have target sets numbering in the 10s and even 100s of thousands. Conflicts can last far longer than academics, generals and wargamers predict. This means buying more precision weapons and stockpiling AND another route, which we will be talking about this week.
Read 6 tweets
Oct 16
Despite the supposed backstory & the billionaire firebrand intrigue, why does SpaceX have to pay for Ukraine's Starlink service? Are other major defense contractors giving away tons of free weapons & services? Yes and I understand Uncle Sam is SpaceX's big customer. But the US...
has supplied close to $20B in military aid to Ukraine & is doing massive tranches weekly. Starlink is something of a critical asymmetric capability. Why isn't it part of the gov. funded aid? Even an at cost deal? Please, feel free to correct me, maybe I am missing something...
which is certainly possible. But how did Starlink become some sacred corporate donation? Saying Elon should just donate it because he is the wealthiest man on earth is fine, but I mean, that's a pretty strange demand. And why not be a real customer where you can...
Read 14 tweets
Oct 14
Darkstar represents a manned demonstrator-sized aircraft, not an operational one. It would not have a relevant range at that size. It is VERY much like what Lockheed said they could build for $1B (F-22-like size) to demo the tech that would go into the unmanned 'SR-72,' but...
that was over half a decade ago & they said they could fly it before now, so that leads to a lot of speculation which we have covered probably too much (see links at end of thread). Also of note, the forward synthetic vision concept is from NASA's X-59 Quesst supersonic test jet.
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(