Interestingly, every Lab government has left office with lower national debt than when it came to power.

The idea that Lab govts ‘tax and spend’ is another carefully crafted #ToryLie pushed out by the right wing client MSM.

The Tories are useless at economics.
Before the US sub-prime triggered banking crises (yes, Tories tried to blame Lab for that as well), UK national debt was below £500 billion - so about 20% of what it is now. AFTER bailing the banks out it rose to £750 billion. All quite manageable and internationally
respected position. After the crash and interest rate collapse, economists were at pains to make the point that the correct response to a deeply contracted economy was a sustained fiscal stimulus ie a Keynesian response. Cameron did exactly the opposite. The Tories slashed
public spending. As a result, the economy remained depressed vis-a-vis where it should have been, tax receipts declined and just as Keynes predicted, national debt climbed. Between 2010 national debt went from £800 billion to £1.9 Trillion just before the pandemic
The tragedy here is that despite the massive cuts, the country had absolutely nothing to show for the more than £1 Trillion additional debt other than a ruined NHS, schools funding crises, 21 000 fewer policeman and 600 closed police stations (and the attendant rocketing crime)
And everywhere we look, the rise in poverty and deprivation. An EU report during May’s tenure identified 4 of the top ten most deprived areas within the EU as lying within the UK. A shocking indictment of failed Tory economic policies. Added to this, the disastrous #Brexit
that hit GDP to the tune of 4% and the result was the UK economy once again became the laggard of Europe. Under Blair, UK GDP per capita was the highest in the G7 (just think about that for a minute: higher than the US, higher than Germany or France). Today, we sit near the
Bottom of the league table. Add to an already parlous situation the unforeseen pandemic which required an extraordinary response and debt ballooned further. Tories argue that most G7 counties have high debt to GDP ratios. But for the UK specifically it did not have
to be anywhere near the £2.5 Trillon we are now sitting at with the trashed public services and manifest economic problems to boot. All in all, a classic case of ‘how not to do it’ that no doubt will make it into case study histories in years to come. Sadly, there is no
quick and easy way out of this. We can help ourselves though by rejoining the EU ( and immediate 3-4% boost to the economy) if they’ll have us back. The UK has a serious in-work poverty problem that is structural and long term. This will require huge investment and
training with a focus on green energy and high tech agriculture as examples.

To conclude, when Tories claim they are the party of sound economic management, don’t believe them. Their policies and responses to exogenous shocks tell exactly the opposite.

#ToryVoodooEconomics

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Sagitta Veritatis

Sagitta Veritatis Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @SagittaVeritat1

Oct 19
How about we start with this little gem from the Commons Library
Inflation. In 🇩🇪 and 🇮🇹 it’s at 10%, but in 🇫🇷 and 🇪🇸 it’s at c. 6.8% (and slowing) vs our 10.8%. So hardly a case of we have less inflation the Europeans. The outlook for GDP growth for the UK is worse than all the G7 countries except for Russia.
This is the long term effect of austerity (shrunk the UK economy relative to where it could have been) and Brexit (4% hit to GDP). A developed economy is doing well with long term 2% GDP growth. Brexit is strangling the UK - and just about every economist has said that
Read 4 tweets
Oct 19
We’re borrowing huge amounts of money and paying over £100 billion a yr in interest because of austerity.

And it’s likely to get worse.

When Labour left power we had debt of £800 billion AFTER bailing the banks out. You Tories slashed spending and still ran up debt.
This outcome is exactly what Keynes predicted. The Tories are monetarists. They don’t believe a government must spend so thru do the exact opposite of what’s required and the result is a long term structural hole in national finances that will take DECADES to fix
So, far from bring the party of sound financial management, the Tories are the party of slash and burn economics. Slash spending after the 2008/9 crash and the result is the economy shrank, tax receipts declined , so then they had to borrow and have not stoop since.
Read 4 tweets
Oct 15
We’re sick and tired of hearing from ‘small state’ dogmatists like Sinclair. The US government represents 46% of their economy and in the UK it’s 45%

Freeze state pensions and slash ‘non-frontline’ NHS and schools staff, said No 10’s economic adviser theguardian.com/politics/2022/…
In France It’s 55%, while Japan is about 16 % and Australia is at c 11%, and Germany 43%. So, there is no link between the size of the state and the success of a country. Instead, there is a link between societies in which large parts of the populace are demonised
for not being ‘successful’. Not everyone can be a doctor, lawyer or a VP in an MNC (which I was). The vast majority of folks go through life quietly with pretty ordinary jobs, but they are happy and fulfilled. That’s how society is structured. They are the foundation that
Read 7 tweets
Oct 7
A chart is worth a thousand words. The UK bounced back in 2021 from the 2020 pandemic lockdown induced contraction which was the worst in the G7 and then settled at 3.7% in 2022 - part of that the ‘hangover’ boost from the 2021 bounce back.
However, the UK’s average growth over the same period is the lowest in the G7 bar Russia (not shown) and the outlook is indeed dire. With inflation running at 10% (not the worst it should be added), the low growth only adds more misery to an already difficult situation.
The average growth rate over the period under consideration is just 0.6%. This is a stagnating economy. #Brexit has cost the UK 4% of GDP or a cobtrzction of £10 billion a year. The pre-Brexit bilateral EU<>UK trade was 470 billion Euros and UK exports to the bloc €200 billion
Read 10 tweets
Oct 6
For the Tory neolibs that look to America as a role model of small government, ‘government off the back of people’ and ‘individual freedom’ it’s interesting to note that that US govt share of GDP is 45.3% vs the UK’s 44.6%.

So, the US is more of a nanny state than the UK?
Then think about the fact the US has a privately funded healthcare system which runs at 18% of GDP vs the UK’s 10% and it has worse clinical outcomes than the nationalised UK system. Further, inequality and mortality in the US are the worst in the developed economies
Of course, we must point out America has chosen to spend its money on guns and the UK on butter to paraphrase the ‘guns and butter’ analogy used by economists. Nevertheless, what these figures show is that in advanced, wealthy economies, governments play an enormous role
Read 8 tweets
Oct 5
Suella Braverman: ‘Britain has a benefits culture problem’. Under the Tories, benefit costs have ballooned from £135 billion to £212 billion while poverty has soared. What’s going on?

Answer: Britain has an in-work poverty problem made worse by Tory policies and #Brexit. Period
Braverman and her ERG colleagues believe in small government - so no social security, no publicly funded healthcare etc. Tories claim their economic management over the last 12 yrs has taken Britain to full employment - 96% of ppl are in employment.
However, if these figures are correct, why has benefits expenditure (despite real world cuts) increased and like for like tax receipts declined? The answer is the economy has stagnated, as expected under austerity, and then we’ve had #Brexit and the pandemic
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(