Total asset growth stalled in March. iShares IBIT (blue) is taking a bigger and bigger share from Grayscale GBTC (orange). Everything else (red) is about a third.
3/9
Daily/Cumulative Flows
$18B in cumulative flows (black). Where did most of it come from?
Hedge fund basis trades (not directional bets) and transfers from on-chain to tradfi accts.
$COIN retail flows are down as they compete with ETFs for retail flows. Stock down too.
China's Govt keeps firing one stimulus Bazooka after another.
Today's installment ...
SCMP: Shanghai, other top tier-1 cities ease ownership curbs in boost for China’s housing market
Results in ...
*CHINA PROPERTY STOCKS GAUGE JUMPS 11% AFTER EASING MEASURES
And causing ....
*CHINA'S CSI 300 UP 22% FROM SEPT. LOW, HEADED FOR BULL MARKET
(biggest such rally since 2008)
2/3
The Chinese finally stimulating domestic demand gives hope that they will start to consume more.
This idea is significantly contributing to this unfolding rally in industrial metals.
Example
*IRON ORE SURGES ALMOST 8% AS CHINESE CITIES EASE HOME CURBS
3/3
Why should we care?
If the Chinese keep firing these stimulus bazookas, the commodity rally should broaden to energy. The Chinese consume more energy than the U.S. or the EU.
Remember, Powell wants a 12-0 vote for every policy decision. He is now working the phones by calling every FOMC member to "horse trade" into a 12-0 vote.
He believes that a 12-0 vote gives policy credibility. Dissents, in Powell's opinion, create doubt and uncertainty.
Powell explained this to Davis Rubenstein in July.
---
From the raw transcript, I edited it for readability
7:58 Powell: The way it works is I talk to the other 18 participants regularly. I speak to them at least once ten days before the meeting and think about this three or four weeks before.
What should we want to achieve? What data do we need to see? How do we want to change our Communications? All those things.
So, I talk to people, listen to them, and try to put together an answer that has broad support on the committee. So when we go into the committee on Tuesday morning [its start], I'm usually confident that I know where this will go.
8:55 Powell: These call calls are generally scheduled and go all day. The Friday before the meeting, I think I have 11 half-hour calls. We talk about the economy, we talk about very specific aspects of the economy, about our mandate, and then we talk about policy, so there's a lot to talk about. I take careful notes.
You can hear him explain it here.
3/3
Since Powell wants a 12-0 vote, he effectively gives everyone a veto.
See the chart above and the annotation about Waller. Waller is arguably the most hawkish member of the Fed. So, if the Fed wants to cut, it can only go as far as the most hawkish member agrees.
The probability of a 50 basis point cut was 60% right before Waller spoke, and it was 20% after he was done. In other words, Waller left the strong impression that he was good with a 25-point basis cut, but no more.
The Fed has only seen two dissents in the last four years. Both in 2022 (highlighted). This is the smallest number in over 70 years.
Again, this is how Powell designed it.
So, as he explained above, when Powell went through his 11 half-hour calls yesterday, and the market was 50/50, he had a lot of "horse trading" to do before a decision could be made (a 12-0 voting agreement).
Then, certain reporters are viewed as "Fed whisperers" who can be called and told "blue horseshoe likes a cut" and let them write a story that "signals" to everyone what will happen at the meeting.
I expect this story on Monday morning.
If not, then this process I described might be changing and could stay changed going forward, leading to more uncertainty and higher volatility.
Before the June 15, 2002, and March 22, 2023 FOMC meetings, the odds of a Fed move were very uncertain, ~50/50.
@NickTimiraos's stories right before these meetings removed uncertainty.
Yesterday's story created uncertainty (chart).
🧵
2/5
Going into the June 15, 2022, FOMC meeting, things were uncertain with a 35% - 45% odd 75bps hike.
@NickTimiraos cleared it up with this:
June 13, 2022 (48 hours before the meeting)
Fed Likely to Consider 0.75-Percentage-Point Rate Rise This Week wsj.com/articles/bad-i…
3/5
Mar 7, 2023 SVB fell. The odds were 100% for a 25 bps hike before March 7. They fell to 55% a week before the Mar 22 FOMC meeting.
Timiroas cleared it up on Mar 20, sending the odds back to 86%