New on PITT: Results of summer 2022 informal survey of parents of ROGD boys. Many interesting statistics. 🧵⤵️ pitt.substack.com/p/summer-of-20…
This survey was taken by 124 parents of boys who fit a Rapid-Onset Gender Dysphoria #ROGD profile-not the childhood-onset type of gender dysphoria. Let's look at some results!
The majority of these boys announced they were trans during puberty, with two waves corresponding to the age they enter high school (age 14) and college (age 19).
Families with ROGD sons appear to have elevated rates of experience with death/chronic illness or a major upheaval.
Rates of anxiety, depression, isolation and trauma for #ROGD boys were high before they announced.
Rates of depression, anxiety & cutting INCREASED after sons announced, but social isolation decreased. Suicide ideation nearly doubled, but the rates of attempted suicide remained around 4%. Note: # respondents shifted between these two “before” and “after” questions.
A large majority of parents believe that COVID played a role in creating or worsening their sons sense of gender dysphoria.
As earlier surveys suggested, these boys with ROGD are disproportionately high IQ.
As earlier surveys suggested, these boys are socially awkward.
As earlier surveys suggested, these boys were gender confirming as young children.
For many of these boys, their “trans behavior” is not persistent or consistent nor evident outside the home.
Around half of these boys are actively presenting as trans, around 30% are inconsistent, and around 10% are desisted.
Around 30% of these boys are probably gay or bisexual. Around 18% are “Who knows? He’s really pre-sexual – it’s too early to know.”
At least a 30% of these boys are unsure of their sexuality.
The greatest number parents of ROGD sons follow a “watch and wait” model.
Post announcement, most of the boys remained or became depressed.
While this survey is not scientific, it does offer a number of insights into the emerging cohort of #ROGD boys.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
"NHS England has announced plans for tightening controls on the treatment of under 18s questioning their gender, including a ban on prescribing puberty blockers outside of strict clinical trials."
[We will have data in the future]
2/15
"The services, which will replace the controversial Tavistock clinic, will be led by medical doctors rather than therapists and will consider the impact of other conditions such as autism and mental health issues."
🧵UK: 1/ Labour MP Rosie Duffield, SNP MP Joanna Cherry & Conservative peer Baroness Jenkin of Kennington are launching a biology policy unit to stop gender identity ideology “compromising” women’s & children’s rights. archive.ph/2022.10.22-235…
2…”to help ensure policies across the public sector that are based on gender identity theory are documented and scrutinised.”
3/“Their shared belief that “scientific fact and reality have become the victim of an ideological revolution” will be addressed by a dedicated “biology matters” unit at Policy Exchange, the influential think tank.”
'..he wanted Mailchimp to be an inclusive company but the pronoun practice was never required and “in the long run this approach does more harm than good”. Forcing people to behave a certain way was “the opposite of inclusion”.. 1/4 thetimes.co.uk/article/pronou…
'Forcing (either with orders, or through guilt) approximately 1,390 other peeps to adopt a new communication paradigm that humanity has never had to use in our 300k year existence, and in our 150k years of spoken language, in order to make things slightly more comfortable.. 2/4
...for an extremely small group of peeps is completely illogical'
And Chestnut continues
'Coercing peeps into proclaiming their pronouns is not about creating an inclusive, creative, productive work environment. It’s becoming a political statement.'
3/4
Ireland:
Brilliant reporting by @MarkLTighe on the fight between the adult National Gender Service who believe WPATH are 'unsafe' and the children's national gender service who cling to the discredited gender affirmative model of care.
🧵with quotes 1/12 independent.ie/irish-news/new…
..'the NGS doctors made it clear to the minister [..that..] two senior HSE managers — Philip Crowley, head of the quality improvement division, and Siobhán Ní Bhriain, the national clinical director for integrated care...had “consistently worked to undermine” their model of care'
..'Given their behaviour, the four doctors said they could not trust the two HSE managers to work with them “in good faith” so they “will not work with them in the future”. They would only work directly within contractually defined reporting lines..' 3/12
Some brilliant points raised in @jk_rowling's article today, it would be amazing to see more of her writing in the newspapers.
Here's a 🧵 with some selected quotes: 1/13 thetimes.co.uk/article/4c8f57…
"Remarkably, nobody seems able to explain what living in an acquired gender actually means, so how those granting certificates can judge whether the criteria has been met is anyone’s guess." 2/13
'As Rachel Cohen, campaigns director of Stonewall wrote in 2017: “Being trans is not about ‘sex changes’ or clothes, it’s about an innate sense of self.” You may ask how anyone can assess the authenticity of somebody else’s “innate sense of self”. I haven’t a clue.' 3/13
Mermaids users are directed to private online clinic GenderGP as a fast-track to hormones.
Dr Michael Webberley was struck off the UK medical register for “wide ranging failings”, & providing treatment without adequate tests, assessments or examinations.
Dr Helen Webberly was suspended for putting patients at "unwarranted risk of harm".
On Mermaids website and forums, staff without medical qualifications declare puberty blockers totally reversible, and persistently laud their “hugely positive impact”.