1) Even if he mistakenly attributed this saying to Sahih Bukhari in Shahadatul Quran(1893), it's a non-issue. Prophets can make such mistakes
So has the Adam AS (Quran 20:115) and Prophet ﷺ:
'I am only human, I forget as you forget, and I remember as you remember.'
Nasai 1259
So has the Adam AS (Quran 20:115) and Prophet ﷺ:
'I am only human, I forget as you forget, and I remember as you remember.'
Nasai 1259
https://twitter.com/Farid_0v/status/1590038754248781824
2) In Izala Auham(1891) and Haqiqatul Mahdi(1899), the Promised Messiah AS has said there is no mention of Al-Mahdi in Sahih Bukhari and Muslim.
This can mean 2 things:
1 He AS made an accidental error.
2 He AS found a different manuscript of Bukhari with this hadith.
This can mean 2 things:
1 He AS made an accidental error.
2 He AS found a different manuscript of Bukhari with this hadith.
3) Your own scholars have quoted the same hadith and attributed it to Sahih al-Bukhari.
Qari Muhammad Tayyib Qasmi, the Principal of Darul Uloom Deoband has also attributed the same hadith to Bukhari.
Shah Rafiuddin Dehlavi has said the same.
Qari Muhammad Tayyib Qasmi, the Principal of Darul Uloom Deoband has also attributed the same hadith to Bukhari.
Shah Rafiuddin Dehlavi has said the same.
4) Even if no one had ever attributed this hadith to Bukhari, it still exists in multiple books of Hadith and Tareekh.
Furthermore, different Muhaddithin and Awliyah have discussed and explained this hadith. It is irrelevant whether this hadith is in Bukhari or not.
Furthermore, different Muhaddithin and Awliyah have discussed and explained this hadith. It is irrelevant whether this hadith is in Bukhari or not.
5) This is not the first time we had to educate you about the different manuscripts of Bukhari, specifically regarding Yaddaul Harb.
Instead of presenting weak strawmen and trivial matters, we invite you to discuss issues of Aqaid with us.
Instead of presenting weak strawmen and trivial matters, we invite you to discuss issues of Aqaid with us.
https://twitter.com/Farid_0v/status/1372414697035665408?s=20&t=3kPHUAftxV_04r4EBxiTDA
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
