We hear it often: "Kaiser spends $50M on housing," "United HC donates $3M to food security..." so we asked, how much are private insurers REALLY spending on #SDOH?
Our work in @JournalGIM attempts to answer this Q -- you may or may not be surprised.
After identifying social spending for the top 20 US health insurers by market share (66%+ of the total market), we found that:
1. 💰 Bw 2017-2021, social spending was at least $1.87 billion
2. 🏩 The top 6 insurers made up nearly 3/4 of that spending
2/x
3. 🏡 Most funds ($1.2B) went to housing and food security ($238M) programs
4. 🚗 The fewest funds ($13.4M) went to transportation
You may be wondering -- did Covid-19 impact spending? It certainly appears so.
Funding for nearly all SDOH categories spiked in 2020...
3/x
But many private insurers had record profits, so we looked at social spending as a percent of net income before and during the Covid-19 pandemic.
As a % of net income, the top 6 insurers, on average, spent 0.11% of dollars on SDOH in 2017, 1.6% in 2020, and 0.67% in 2021 📈
4/x
So it looks like private health insurers are spending substantial dollars on social programs, but that spending constitutes a small share of their profits.
How much should they be spending on these efforts?
5/x
Well, that's a Q that requires much more deliberation, esp since the impact of these programs is often unclear and social spending dollars may be used to reduce insurance premiums and cost-sharing.
Before starting my junior year of college, I made a trip to the local Walmart. I shopped for chicken, eggs, and milk when I noticed a man shyly approaching other customers.
He looked to be in his forties, and I could overhear him nervously speaking in Spanish.
1/x
The first customer he approached waved him away. Then the second, and the third. I continued shopping until I felt a hand lightly tap my shoulder.
It was the man, we'll call him Miguel. He asked for spare change, but I remorsefully told him that I barely had enough $ for..
2/x
..my own groceries. He understood, but Miguel's ask prompted me to look into my wallet. Voila, a $20 bill that I did not know existed. I called him back.
"Why are you asking for money?" I asked in Spanish.
3/x
My 59-year-old uncle died last night from #covid19. He was one of my biggest supporters, a devoted father to his children, and a loving brother to my mother and her siblings.
His name is Jorge Garcia and this is my part of his story.
1/x
I first met my uncle Jorge when I visited Guatemala as a child. He lived with his wife and children in a barrio filled with family and friends--they never had much, but he worked tirelessly to maintain their home.
When opportunity struck however, he traveled to America.
2/x
He successfully earned enough income to support both himself and his family back home.
Some days, he even visited us in Palmdale, CA, with a huge bag of Pollo Campero (really good chicken). Without fail, he always slipped a few dollar bills into my pocket before he left.
3/x