All the people calling what happened in Makiivka a "war crime" know fuck shit about surrender procedures.

Surrenders of enemy forces larger than one's own force are TRAINED and follow procedures. The Ukrainian troops followed the procedure and because of that they are alive.
1/7
If the enemy wants to surrender but outnumbers you, then you tell the enemy soldiers to move unarmed and with their hands up to a spot in front of one or two of your machine guns.

Make all the enemy troops lay down. Now if one of them changes his mind - he is in the machine
2/7
gunner's sight and can be neutralized easily. And the machine gunner's task is TO FIRE immediately if an enemy soldiers moves without being asked to do so.
Once all the enemy troops are on the ground, you call them one by one over to a spot BEHIND the machine gun. You never
3/7
move to the enemy on the ground as then you block your machine gunner's sight. Call the enemy troops over one by one, search them, handcuff them, sit them down behind the machine gun to the side.
Proceed until all enemy soldiers are searched and handcuffed.
This is trained!
4/7
Troops are expected to follow this procedure to ensure the safety of their own side.

The Ukrainian squad set up their heavy machine gun, told the russians to follow protocol, and all of them would be alive if the last russian didn't decide to murder them all by opening fire.
5/7
The machine gunner did as trained - open fire immediately to ensure no risk comes from the line of russian soldiers on the ground.
Smaller units taking larger units prisoner is dangerous for both sides, that is why this is trained.
If you now say that this was a war crime -
6/7
you show you know shit. The only war crime committed was the russian soldier opening fire. And he took all his comrades with him by forcing the Ukrainian machine gunner to do his job and open fire.
I feel pity for the russians, who surrendered, but this wasn't a war crime.
7/7

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Thomas C. Theiner

Thomas C. Theiner Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @noclador

Nov 16
Here is a photo of Poland's RAT-31DL FADR radar at Łabunie.
This radar is 40 km from Przewodów, where the missiles exploded.
That radar is barely 10 years old and has a 11x7 m antenna. It is one of the best radars NATO has. And it feeds directly into the Polish Air Force's
1/4 Image
Air Operations Centre in Pyry. The Poles see in real time EVERYTHING that flies towards their country from the East for 500 km.

Poland knows EXACTLY where those missiles came from.

AND Pyry feeds directly into NATO's Combined Air Operations Centre Uedem.

NATO knows EXACTLY
2/4 Image
where those missiles came from.

And the US has a Patriot battery at Rzeszów, which also covers the area of the missiles impacts.

The US knows EXACTLY where those missiles came from.

And there was an AWACS plane in the air... in short: Poland and Ukraine know that if they
3/4 Image
Read 4 tweets
Oct 31
The reasons Italy's Army never received all the funds to modernize its heavy equipment are:

1) an army doesn't need main battle tanks, tracked IFVs, long range air defense systems, self-propelled artillery, armored bridgelayers, etc. if its adversary are the Taliban.

1/n Image
2) Italy focused heavily on modernizing its Navy and Air Force equipment, which costs muuuuuuuch more than army equipment.

Two F-35 (or two Eurofighter) cost the same as the yearly salaries for an entire army brigade. Italy bought 96 Eurofighter and 90 F-35.

2/n Image
A modern frigate costs the same as raising and equipping a tank battalion with brand new Leopard 2A7V. Since the war on terror startet Italy bought/is buying 17 frigates (and 2 aircraft carriers, 4 destroyers, 8 submarines, 3 amphibious ships, etc. etc.)

3/n Image
Read 7 tweets
Oct 31
🇮🇹 Italian equipment for Ukraine:

• M109L, confirmed. Quantity depends on how many can be overhauled by the Italian Army's Heavy Maintenance Pool in Piacenza. They might have to cannibalize some M109L for spares. 20-30 are a realistic number
• M270 MLRS-I, a rumor. These
1/n ImageImage
would have to be taken out of the three the army's Artillery School has. The army wants more M270 or M142 HIMARS for years... but the government never provided the necessary funds for that.
• PzH 2000, also a rumor. The army wants at least 22 more PzH 2000 for years already,
2/n Image
so donating 6x to Ukraine requires that funds for replacements are made available.
• more FH70, very possible. The army wants to replace the remaining 100+ FH70 with a mix of M777A2 & CAESAR NG for years... alas no funds were made available.
• SIDAM-25, all remaining can be
3/n Image
Read 11 tweets
Oct 28
As people are wondering how the Ukrainian national symbol, the Tryzub (photo), became the most common Italian Army heraldic symbol - a Italian Army heraldry 🧵:

1/n Image
Italian Army regiments are awarded medals or crosses for feats of arms or exceptional service, which are then affixed to their regimental flags.

Here the flag of the 11th Bersaglieri Regiment with from the top:
• 1x Military Order of Italy
• 1x Gold Medal of Military Valor
2/n Image
• 4x Silver Medals of Military Valor
• 1x Bronze Medal of Military Valor
• 1x War Cross of Military Valor
• 1x Bronze Medal of Army Valor

The medals of valor are added to the right & left of regimental coat of arms. Here the coat of arms of the 11th Bersaglieri Regiment:
3/n Image
Read 18 tweets
Oct 22
Today I had some time to ponder a few of the lessons of the war in Ukraine for NATO armies.

Doesn't mean I am 100% correct and everyone will draw different conclusions, but here are mine:

1) Main Battle Tanks (MBT) are indispensable. russia has lost more than 2,000 so far,
1/n Image
but this doesn't mean they are obsolete. Quite the contrary. Ukrainians use them competently and have shown that during an offensive nothing can replace tanks.

However due to the massive proliferation of Anti-Tank Guided Missiles ALL (!) armored vehicles now require Hardkill
2/n Image
Active Protection Systems (HAPS). Without APS armored vehicles that cost $10m will be lost to $200k ATGMs.

And it is imperative that these HAPS will be able to detect, identify and destroy loitering munitions (aka suicide drones). Air defense has no chance to shoot down all
3/n Image
Read 26 tweets
Oct 19
After putin loyalist Yanukovych's troops killed people on Euromaidan Steinmeier raced to Kyiv on 21 February 2014 to try to keep Yanukovych in power.

And on 2 October 2019 Steinmeier tried to force Ukraine to submit to all of putin's demands about its future and Donbas.
1/4 Image
In 2016 Steinmeier worked tirelessly to help putin take back control of all of Syria for the Assad regime.

And every day he defended Nord Stream 2 as a "purely commercial" project that "Germany owes to russia".

And Steinmeier is one of the biggest cheerleaders of doing
2/4 Image
business with Iran's mullahs, while they murder Iranian girls, wage war in Yemen, and help bomb Kyiv.

In spring 2022, after russia invaded Ukraine, he demanded to be invited to Kyiv to whitewash his subservience to putin and his betrayal of Eastern Europe. When he wasn't
3/4 Image
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(