Lying about us and what we do seems to be a hobby for certain elements of political Scotland. We don't expect Duncan (Fiona, Euan etc etc) to set the record straight, so here goes. 🧵
We did not co-organise this event.
We were invited by @acadofideas, a respected organisation who frequently host conversations between people of widely different political opinions in the belief that discussion and robust examination of ideas is the best way forward. We agree with this.
Do we agree with everyone on the list here on all points? Assuredly not. But we maintain that we have to be able to express this disagreement openly & properly (rather than in the form of death threats, for example!).
There were several different panels & topics of conversation.
It is also true there were left wing speakers which, strangely, the critics have conveniently been selectively blind to.
We are in a mess in Scotland because groups like Hothersall's EN refused to talk to critics. #NoDebate is a rubbish tactic. You only win arguments by arguing!
Finally, Hothersall, again, claims we use "paedophile smears" against gay men. What we said was that the founder of the paedophile information exchange (accused of abusing under age boys) was not a good man. Why on earth does Duncan keep defending him?
Post script. One of Marion's points was the deeply homophobic LGBTY guidance for young women (16+) who have sex with women which advised them what to do if their partner had a penis.
The audience were pretty horrified (rightly) by this gaslighting of young lesbians.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Another day, another confected attempt by the @scottishgreens to malign us.
@MaggieChapman needs to be careful in her hyperbolic lies - we have never appeared at a "festival of hate". As we repeatedly told the journalist, all the film will be online soon archive.ph/PIMaB
We spent most of Friday dealing with emails from the journalist & told him many times that we were not on the same panel as the SFP. Despite this, the @ScotNational has printed a lie. Probably because saying we were on a panel with a paediatrician & an academic isn't so fruity.
The "row" & "backlash" we were told came from the Rainbow Greens & @humanistsociety
The Rainbow Greens are a less than credible group, but we did ask for the SPECIFIC concerns about what Marion said from the Humanists & where we could see their official statement about us,
This is shocking & chilling. Tomorrow, MSPs will vote on GRR, @NicolaSturgeon will tell us this has nothing to do with the vote. That will be a lie. @NHSScotland has betrayed vulnerable children on the watch of this Gov in the name of a cultural shift. 🧵telegraph.co.uk/news/2022/10/2…
"A gender identity clinic’ branded “Sturgeon’s Tavistock” has been offering patients irreversible sex-change treatments despite senior clinicians admitting that its methods are not backed by “robust evidence”, a leaked recording showed."
"A consultant clinical psychologist at Sandyford openly admitted at an online NHS event in June that there were huge gaps in evidence around trans healthcare and claimed that work was ongoing to find “a robust evidence base for the treatment that we offer”.
OTOH, Scottish Council on Human Bioethics & an extensive report from a senior paediatrician. OTO, gov funded, ideologically-driven, non-medical lobby groups. Guess which one @scotgov@ScotGovFM listens to?! They've prob had enough of experts. #No2SelfID thetimes.co.uk/article/scotti…
We wonder if @MaggieChapman or @Cmacf76 are going to pick up the bill for the Local Authorities and the Scottish NHS when the inevitable negligence claims begin. We wonder why they presume to think they know better than Hillary Cass and the Council of Human Bioethics?
Dr Calum MacKellar said: “The proposals in the bill are unreasonable since the latest and most comprehensive studies to date [2022] show that a high prevalence of mental disorders, such as autism spectrum traits, often exist in persons with gender dysphoria/incongruence.
"If any woman or girl suffers voyeurism, sexual harassment, assault or rape in consequence of the Scottish government’s lax new rules, the blame will rest squarely with those at Holyrood who ignored safeguarding experts and women’s campaigners." thetimes.co.uk/article/jk-row…
Thank you @jk_rowling for being in this fight with us and for your voice.
"Sturgeon [argues] that it’s transphobic to suggest any man would fraudulently claim a female identity. This claim is extraordinary. Nobody but the very naive can fail to be aware that predatory men are capable of going to great lengths to gain easy access to victims"
"Like most women in politics, Eddie’s policies have been side-lined in favour of talk about her appearance, misogynistic comments and doubts over her ability to do her job because of her gender." Nobody who writes that in non-parodic fashion is a feminist! metro.co.uk/2022/10/14/im-…
Honestly, Metro, we already have Pink News for misogynistic claptrap and idiocy. You won't beat them, but you will make yourselves look very silly!
We've been testing the claim that Nicola Sturgeon made on @BBCr4today@BBCScotlandNews@LBCNews and others about her history of feminist action.
We thought we'd look at the easy stuff, the bare minimum for an MSP; supporting motions. Thread
We searched on the Parliament website for motions with key words from 1999 when parliament opened and Sturgeon was elected to 2007 when she became a minister (and unable to add her name).
First we tried "international women's day"
This returned motions relating to victims of trafficking or domestic abuse. Familiar names, like Johann Lamont, Elaine Smith, Pauline McNeil, Sandra White, Kenny Gibson, etc reappear. Curiously, not the "real" feminist FM.