"Steve, we need your help. Bloody medics are kicking off about the guidance change. They're refusing to see patients without FFP3"
"I thought the airborne HCID declassification was meant to sort that?"
[*Unverified date]
"Seems not. Twitter is kicking off; probably the source for this. Too many cottoning on the the fact that coughing releases aerosols & these have to be assumed to be infectious"
"Shit. We don't have enough even for ICU right now; what do you need from me?"
"A letter"
"Oh?"
"CAS Alert. You know; immediate national access all areas"
"Sorry, of course. Sure. When do you need it?"
"Saturday [28th] at the latest. Think you can do it? It'll need to be convincing on the IPC. But don't worry, @doyle_yg is on side, as is @AoMRC President"
"Wow. OK, fine. What are the essentials?"
"Great. Knew we could count on you.
Number 1: thank the staff for their dedication & say that their safety & PPE supply is a priority"
"Number 2: say you know there have been PPE supply problems, but you're confident these have been resolved"
"Number 3: The key is to make it clear that we are RECOMMENDING surgical masks for all staff in all covid19-facing roles except for AGPs & ICU.
We must stop general ward staff from getting their hands on FFP3 - there are just too many of them"
"Bloody hell JVT, it's going to be carnage. Do hospitals have enough staff to fill the gaps?"
"Don't worry Steve. It's sorted. You know the plans to bring forward provisional registration for doctors & nurses, & Trusts are up-skilling medical students to fill ward posts"
"And there's one more super important thing.
The most important.
You MUST include this exact phrase:
'COVID-19 is not airborne, it is droplet carried'
OK?"
"Hang on JVT. Chris blabbed to the bloody Health & Science Select Committees that covid is airborne on the 5th. Won't they remember?"
"Don't worry he hid this with his later answers. Plus the huge operation with PHE pushing hand hygiene, dispensers everywhere. Confusion reigns"
"But what if someone asks? I mean, asks for the data to support this 'not airborne' bollocks. What do we say?"
"Blimey Steve, stop being paranoid. It will never come up. But if it does, 'we do not hold any documents that falls within the scope of your request' usually works
Note: Clearly an imagined conversation between key leaders of the UK pandemic response, early March 2020
But the FOI request, & reply I received are the truth
‘Healthcare leadership has lost its way. Its foundation should be in love, not lies. We are truly sorry for what we have done’
** ‘testimony’ 🙃
/🧵
‘We knew SARS2 transmission was airborne in Jan 2020, but instead of showing love to healthcare workers & being honest with them about the RPE shortages, we lied to them & kept on lying’
‘…we are truly sorry for what we have done’
/2
We knew AGP-only aerosol risk was a smokescreen - a thinly disguised rationing tool for RPE - but instead of being honest with HCWs, in love, we lied to them & kept on lying’
If you missed what Prof Sir Chris Whitty said on IPC & PPE, or just couldn't carry on watching after the amazing @Kevin_Fong [God bless you sir, & thank you for all you do 🙏]
TL/DR
/1
Sir Chris worked shifts on the wards in every wave
Wore FRSM mainly - as per IPC guidance, he said
HCID declassification had no bearing on IPC guidance
"I am not an expert on IPC'
/2
On national IPC guidance:
'quite a lot of people had partial responsibility'
Now we've seen IPC Cell minutes from 22/12/2020 & the plea from 'CB' for wider FFP3 use because:
'Our understanding of aerosol transmission has changed'
🚨Would you like to know whether very late 2020 was when *all* 🇬🇧Gov departments knew of the importance of aerosol risk?
/1
Obtained via FOI request
🚨From the Department of Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy
🦺Working safely during coronavirus (COVID-19)
10 July 2020 update
'You should ensure that steps are taken to avoid people needing to unduly raise their voices to each other...
/2
'This includes...refraining from playing music or broadcasts that may encourage shouting, including if played at a volume that makes normal conversation difficult. This is because of the potential for increased risk of transmission, particularly from aerosol transmission.’
Over the last 2 days at @covidinquiryuk the NHS has shown its dark & ugly side
There was never going to be an apology from IPC guidance authors whose guidance drove disproportionately high rates of death & COVID19 in non-ICU HCWs & huge rates of nosocomial SARS2, but…
/1
the level of obfuscation, evasion & incompetence on display from those tasked with keeping HCWs safe, is jaw dropping
I was one of the lucky ones: my NHS Trust ALWAYS provided HCWs with FFP3 when caring for those with COVID19 - my IPC remained precautionary
As a result…
/2
by Dec 2020 the number of consultant staff working on Covid wards testing positive was: 0
🚨The ONLY deviation from national guidance was universal FFP3!
The last & most vital line of defence - FFP3 - *is life saving* @SMHopkins
TL/DR in evidence to @covidinquiryuk, CH stated SARS2 transmission is via large droplet & fomites
But:
Following peer review triggered changes 6 Jul 2022, CH's own work stated that SARS2 transmission is via 'fine aerosols & respiratory droplets, & to a lesser extent...fomites'
Why omit the empirical truth that SARS2 transmission occurs importantly via the airborne [aerosol inhalation] route?
Why do this, particularly as David Heymann's 13th Oct 2023 evidence to the PI clarified the @WHO position:
WHO knew SARS2 transmission was via aerosols, Jan 2020
'Arguably the most fundamental misstep in the UK response was the presumption that covid would be an unstoppable flu-like wave'
This
underpinned the early (Chris Whitty) position on T&T, & the Vallance view on 'herd immunity' (later air-brushed)'
Aside
Early SAGE minutes clarify the UK rationale for stopping community SARS2 testing: it was deemed unnecessary because with rapidly increasing case numbers there was no point in testing, as there were insufficient personnel to contact trace
Good to know whose plan this was
'But there was an alternative'
'This led us to question...though we found ourselves quietly dismissed as not understanding the science'
'Ironically, the pride in our science & our capabilities, slowed our ability to learn lessons from other countries'