The problem with MAiD is not just about poverty and if you don't understand that you keep spreading that you are playing into the Liberal Party of Canada's hands - why tf do you think they have this national benefits long drawn out dog and pony mystery show going on?
Also, I have crips in my DMs who have housing and have sufficient income.
But they are hit by ableism in different ways.
I know you want to make this all about things you ableds can relate to - or that are your situation if you're disabled. But it's wrong.
Analysis is not a laundry list.

Do you all think affirmative action solved racism?
Do you not understand why racialized people fear police regardless of their class?

OK, so if you do, then try to think bigger with ableism.
You all are out here acting as simplistic as the NDP. How close are some of you to coming up with a rebate to fix MAiD.

It's so frustrating watching these tweets go viral.

'MAiD is because food bank.'

OK grade five public speaking contest.
Lowest hanging fruit is going to end up with more charity & bs takes like Picard's.
Why are disabled people poor?
Why is it tolerated in this society?
Why is our healthcare not created let alone covered?
Why is there no housing we can get into- never mind fcking cost of it?
You think these things are all just oopses?
You think that it was all an accident? Oversight?
The why is where we fight.

The manifestations and consequences of the why are magnitudes of harm - levels and layers of it. But the why is the part that you have to grasp.
No one needs to explain poverty & its effects on me. But I'm not prepared to leave any crip behind. I'm not prepared to leave ableism in place. I'm not using MAiD as 'leverage' to up benefits. Yes we need to raise the rates - or guaranteed income - fights overlap but are not same
Non-disabled people are poor too.
No one is offering them MAiD - yet.

The ableism is key not just to the oppression of disabled people but it is actually important to dismantling other oppressions and preventing them from creating new 'others.'
Why are we forcing people into nursing homes when we know people are offing themselves via MAiD because they fear being forced into those nursing homes?

Why are people literally choosing to die rather than wear a diaper or have someone help them pee for few minutes a day?
Why did this country turn a father who murdered his own daughter into a folk hero?
Why did so many facts of her life and the case get successfully suppressed?
Why have disabled people been fighting people like Singer and his terrible offspring alone since forever?
You think raising the rates is going to fix this?
This is Canada. Maclean's magazine 1994.
If people who are not familiar and haven't been working on MAiD want to support, one really good way would be to talk about ableism - all of it - the everyday ableism, the history of it, the myriad of ways it presents in our society. That would be a huge help.
Threads about medical ableism would be very helpful.
Likewise housing.
Also really needed are threads about how ableism intersects with other oppressions. Just add hashtag #MAiD if possible. Because opposition to MAiD is about those things. About all of it.
If you are disabled and poor, one thing I'd really appreciate more documentation on is how the system restricts and policies you and limits your autonomy.
The bottom line is they want to entirely redirect this to have a discussion about poverty - skeptical that they plan to do a single real thing to end it but they'll discuss it.
What they don't want is to discuss ableism.

And we must.
The thing about disability poverty & society co-signing along with it, is that unlike welfare (which is also way too low), it is not intended as a stop gap measure. The assumption of welfare is no one lives their whole lives in that level of poverty - some do but assumption is no
With disability poverty you have a situation where a science-based medicine physician that they entrust to make this judgment, says - this person can not participate in capitalist work force, ever. And they say - OK lifetime of destitution for you.
So the fact that society has continuously felt that was appropriate life sentence for some for being disabled - is a reflection of a deeper devaluing of disabled people and the way 'value' to a human is assigned in our society.
So the discussion must be about ableism.
Why are people left in pain?
Why do disabled people face such crushing isolation?

Why are we so staggeringly more likely to be victims of violence?
Why are we always made to feel in the way and like burdens?

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with G Peters "rejected as too radical by some"👩🏻‍🦽

G Peters

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @mssinenomine

Dec 6
This man should be alive & it rips my heart out how he died.

As I've said for years, we need to train some advocates who are unaffiliated with hospitals who are on hand in emergency dept 24/7.

In interim, I have an idea & would love to crowdsource help

toronto.ctvnews.ca/he-could-ve-be…
I think we can create a Crip Tips for Advocating at the Emergency Ward Sheet. This is crip area of expertise and most all the advocacy tip sheets I've seen are ridiculously unrealistic. I want us to talk about what we really do to get help.
If you are interested in sharing your tips you can drop them here or email cripcarehq@gmail.com

And then the final version will be uploaded to CripCare.com and we can also make a downloadable PDF sheet
Read 21 tweets
Dec 5
ok I just read that NYT's piece.

fucking American columnists.
'oh goody look, a terrible human rights atrocity in another country and I will comment incorrectly about it because who tf cares because it's not US...and use it as a pivot point to push my totally unrelated domestic political agenda'
someone build me a time machine so I can go back and slap younger me who spent her tip money buying copies of the Sunday NYTs.
Read 5 tweets
Dec 4
Oh ffs now the resident has a thread going saying I compared her to a Nazi.
Do doctors not *read* as part of their training?

mssinenomineblog.wordpress.com/2022/12/04/the…
I, first of go into a tiny part of the hours long exchange we had where she choose to ignore everything I was saying and just keep wringing her hands.

I then said, I couldn't get the words "Who am I?" out of my head so I wrote what they made me think of
I assume she is referring to this part:

Who am I?

The person who didn’t hide Anne Frank.

Who am I?

The excuse the didn’t work at Nuremberg.

So the first is not a Nazi but a coward
The second is a reference to 'just following orders/law' not being excuse
Read 4 tweets
Dec 4
I appreciate the attempt but that account doesn't follow me - nor do most large US disability accounts. They will talk about Canada and speak to Canadian disabled people who have had zero involvement on this issue and they will get it wrong and do harm and just honestly IDK.
There is a huge amount of US disability activism that assumes there is zero difference between their history and politics and ours.

They really bring in that superpower energy into the room.
The exceptions being Alice, Gregg & Andrew at crip the vote.
They actually reached out and asked for resources. They hosted a chat about it and included some of us in prep and as hosts.

That, to me, is activism. That is solidarity and organizing in a constructive way.
Read 8 tweets
Dec 4
Stop trying to make discrimination-by-not-killing us happen.

T-2 MAiD is open to disabled people only - that’s where the discrimination happens.
Ableism plus other intersecting oppressions cause suffering & fail to mitigate, alleviate & prevent suffering also discrimination
But not creating a separate stream that kills only disabled people is not discrimination.

This is so obviously a talking point created by some pr strategists and circulated by the lobbyists and govt because the same bs line keeps coming up.
I’ve literally been in rooms when this kind of stuff gets crafted - hell I’ve crafted some of it in the past - so I know how this got manufactured. They really thought they could play to ‘yeah why are you treating us differently!’ And no one would notice it is utter rubbish
Read 8 tweets
Dec 4
Just a reminder many disabled people and some allies in Canada have spent years working on the issue of opposition to MAiD. We know the legislation and the social political context of this country. There are some things which are universal but please defer to our leadership.
I honestly would not insert myself into another country's political argument without great care because you could do unintentional harm and trust and believe your wording will be used against us - they won't bother to point out what country you are from.
I again ask disability twitter why you can't ever speak to people doing the work and ask how you can be of support? Why do you not amplify Canadian disabled people who research, write and testify about Canadian law?
Read 15 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(