In a swing race, a five point win is a blowout. No one wins by more than that. Four points is big. Three points is solid. Any pundit who says it’s bad news for the Democrats because Warnock “only” won by three points, has no idea what they’re talking about, or how elections work.
Fetterman and John Kelly won by five points. Those were blowouts.
Warnock won by three points. That was a sizable win.
Cortez Masto won by 0.8 points. Now that was a close race.
You see the difference, right?
Every candidate, manager, and strategist who’s ever won or lost a competitive election knows this.
Yet most political pundits and analysts, on TV and Twitter, either don’t understand this or pretend not to understand this for effect.
The overwhelming majority of people vote along party lines. So if the party line breakdown in an electorate is 50-50, of course you’re going to see results that are close to 50-50. You want to win those races, you have to do it narrowly. Always true for either side.
You motivate a few extra people on your side to turn out, you embarrass a few people on the other side not to turn out for their bad candidate, and that’s how you win by 51.5 to 48.5 in a 50-50 electorate. It’s how Warnock won. It’s the only way swing races are won.
It’s for that same reason that races with a 65-35 electorate are literally unwinnable for the party with 35. There aren’t enough people on your side to turn out, and you’re not getting that many on the other side to cross party lines or stay home.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
We need to find a way to talk about how Sinema is mentally incompetent AND an asshole. She’s incoherent most of the time. Her positions change hourly. She presents similarly to the owner of Twitter, who is also mentally incompetent and is also being used by right wing “friends.”
Sinema is corrupt. She takes dirty money. But she’s also terrible at it. She’s a terribly incompetent villain. Money is waved in her face, she takes it. She’s told it’ll help her career, she believes it. She sees overwhelming evidence to the contrary, she can’t process it.
Contrast that with Manchin, another corrupt asshole, but he has a strategy to it. He does the precise dirty deals that make him as popular in his state as he is unpopular elsewhere. He knows exactly what he’s doing, and it works out very well for him, if not for anyone else.
Kyrsten Sinema is becoming an Independent but she’s still caucusing with the Democrats. We still have a 51 seat majority. For now nothing changes. She’s probably doing this to avoid a 2024 democratic primary challenge. She’s an asshole. We’ll find a way to replace her later.
She’s betting that for fear of losing her seat entirely, we’ll do what we do with Bernie Sanders in Vermont and Angus King in Maine: run no viable Democratic candidate, and let the Independent be the de facto Democratic candidate in the general election.
To get rid of her now we’d have to beat her in a three way contest. Finishing ahead her would be easy; everyone hates her. Also finishing ahead of the Republican in a three way race would be a lot trickier. But we’ll get into that at the right time.
I know it makes us feel good to say Republicans are spineless cowards who are afraid to stand up to Trump. But the reality is that they're calculated villains who have not yet concluded that ditching Trump is in their selfish best interests. We need to acknowledge this reality.
Making up imaginary motivations for your enemies, just so you can feel the most self righteous outrage toward them, is never a winning strategy. It is a surefire way to lose. You have to accurately understand your enemy to defeat your enemy.
"Spineless cowards" would imply that they care about the right thing, but can't bring themselves to do it.
Republicans couldn't care less about the right thing. They very boldly, very aggressively, do the corrupt selfish thing. Every time. They're not cowards. They're evil.
If the 1/6 committee announces a boatload of criminal referrals, the media will say it doesn’t count for anything. If the 1/6 committee only makes a handful of targeted criminal referrals, the media will say it’s a disaster.
I trust the committee to only make referrals in the instances where the evidence can actually lead to charges and a conviction, and not overplay its hand. If you trust the committee, then trust the committee.
Regardless of what referrals are announced, don’t let the media and pundit class emotionally manipulate you into suddenly turning against a committee that’s already proven itself to you time and again. Don’t let the outrage factory treat you like the product.
Why did most losing Republicans concede in 2022? They finally figured out what the rest of us already knew: refusing to concede just alienates voters in the middle and costs you in the next election. Yelling “rigged election” was never a magic wand, just another dumb Trump idea.
All that time you spent fretting over how Republicans were somehow magically going to get somewhere by refusing to concede, was a complete waste of time on your part. Fretting for the sake of fretting. There are no magic wands in politics. There just aren’t.
Nor does this have anything to do with “growing a conscience.” Concepts like integrity do not exist on the Republican side. This was simply a matter of the Republicans figuring out that Trump’s dumb idea of refusing to concede really was ineffective strategy that was backfiring.
This story Trump’s lawyers fed to the media today about turning over classified documents they found in a warehouse, feels like they’re trying to get out ahead of something. Makes me suspect the DOJ is going to raid something or indict someone within a week. Just a gut feeling.
Trump’s lawyers are essentially making a last minute argument to the public that they’re not guilty of obstruction of justice. They know Trump will see the story and be pissed at them – but they care more about getting this story out there about how they cooperated with the DOJ.
Why do that, unless they have reason to believe everything is about to imminently hit the fan? It’s as if the DOJ has informed one or more of Trump’s lawyers that they’re about to be indicted for obstruction, and one or more of them is saying “It wasn’t me!”