Aditya Shah Profile picture
Dec 16, 2022 21 tweets 5 min read Read on X
Life insurance is said to be a sunrise industry!

The analysis of a life insurer is completely different from normal companies!
Many people find it very complex!

A thread🧵simplifying the complex jargon of the life insurance industry.

Lets go👇

(1/20)
Why Life insurance?

The Financialisation of savings is a rampant theme over the last 5 years.

This means the share of life insurance in the overall savings has increased from 13% to 14.5%

(2/20)
Insurance on an accelerated growth phase:-

The new business premium has grown sharply in the last 5 years by 17%.

Financialisation of savings, as well as young people needing life insurance, will continue to make sure the industry grows at fast pace

(3/20)
What is life insurance?

Life Insurance is a contract b/w insurance policyholder & an insurer,
The insurer promises to pay a sum of money to the beneficiary when the insured person dies or after a pre-determined period in exchange for the premiums paid by policyholder.

(4/20)
Product Mix:-

Companies have two types of products
🏦 Savings Plan
🏦 Protection Plan

(5/20)
Savings Products:-

These combine investments with insurance.
They generally promise an assured sum of money at some point:-

🏦Partipating
🏦Non-Participating
🏦ULIP

(6/20)
Protection

Pure play life insurance plan:-
Here the companies only pay an amount in case of death. No assured payout are given

🏦Term Plan
🏦Annuity

(7/20)
Profitability of each business(VNB margins)-

Protection(Term Plan)-50-70%
Annuities-25-35%
Savings 2-10%

Protection plans are very profitable for insurance companies.

(8/20)
So how does product mix affect company analysis?

Look for companies that have a balanced product mix and are increasing the protection part of the business!

For eg HDFC Life has a balanced mix and is growing the protection part of the business

(9/20)
Some terms used in analysis now-

New Business Premium (NBP) -

New business premium is the premium acquired from new policies for a particular year.

This tells us about the basic premium growth of the company and is an important metric

(10/20)
Persistency ratio-

The proportion of policyholders who continue to pay their renewal premium.

It is a barometer for the quality of sale made by the insurer.

Higher the persistency ratios..the better it is!

HDFC life shown here has some of the best persistency ratios

(11/20)
Distribution mode of the policies:-

A strong bank(bancasurrance) network together with agent relationships helps distribute the products better

A large part of HDFC Life's policy comes from Banks

(11/20)
Value of New Business (VNB) -

Present value of expected future earnings from new policies written during any given period.

It reflects the additional value to shareholders expected to be generated through the activity of writing new policies during any given period

(12/20)
VNB Margin-

It is a measure of the expected profitability of new business.

Just like the profit margins

For example:-

HDFC Life is an as a VNB margin of 26.1%.It means for every Rs 100 of new premium written,the company expects to makes 26.1% as profits

(13/20)
VNB Margins across insurers show:-

HDFC Life and ICICI Pru Life are the most efficient.
LIC is the least efficient.

(14/20)
Embedded Value(EV):-

EV is the sum of the net asset value+present value of future profits of a company.

This is one of the valuation metrics for life insurers just as a P/E is used for a normal company

HDFC Life here explains the changes in EV for the company

(15/20)
Valuation:-

Life insurers are valued on multiples of Embedded Value(EV)

HDFC Life trades at 3x P/EV
SBI Life trades at 2.5x P/EV
LIC trades at 0.8x P/EV

(16/20)
So normal analysis parallels used to analyse Life insurance

P/E becomes P/Embedded Value
ROE becomes Return on Embedded Value
NIM becomes VNB margin which is unearned and is an assumption of future profits and dependent on future interest rates, persistency etc.

(17/20)
Sales growth becomes New premium growth
Long term relationship with clients is measured by persistency ratios

(18/20)
Conclusion:-

1. Valuing a Life insurance company is just not based on the Embedded Value
2. Product Mix,Distribution network,VNB margins as well as persistency ratio are some of the important things that need to be monitored!

(19/20)
Disclaimer:-

This is just my study.

This is not investment advise.

Please consult your own investment advisor before making your own investment decisions

(20/20)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Aditya Shah

Aditya Shah Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @AdityaD_Shah

May 30
🚨 Suzlon- Is the turnaround finally completed?

After decades of Hardships,
Suzlon is reported 67% revenue growth in FY25
It is order book of 5.6GW(highest in last 25 years)

Is the wind energy and Suzlon's business on a massive turnaround?🤔🤔

A thread🧵on the business of Suzlon and what lies ahead?

Lets go👇Image
The history of Suzlon:-

Suzlon undertook aggressive expansion within the wind energy space.

This led to a massive build-up of debt and after that huge problems for the company

Here is a brief history of the company Image
So what is changing for Suzlon?

A series of steps have been taken by policy makers to reverse earlier policies that hampered wind capacity addition between FY18-FY23.

Policy makers decided to do away with reverse auctions.
Read 17 tweets
May 22
🚨Indusind Bank- Can it get any worse?🤔🤔

As if derivative accounting problems were not enough,

Indusind Bank reported shocking numbers with even more problems:-
🏦 NPAs hidden in microfinance
🏦Inflated fee income
🏦The board suspects fraud by some employees🤯🤯

A thread on 🧵on the results of Indusind Bank and what lies ahead?👇Image
What is happening at Indusind bank?

In March,
Indusind Bank reported an accounting error in the derivatives book.
This led to 2000 cr and exit of top management.

That was just the tip of the iceberg,
The stock price has tanked from there

Let's find out more👇 Image
First of all.

Let's break down the current fiasco,

1. Accounting discrepancy in the derivatives book

From 2019,
Indusind Bank did not report losses in the derivatives portfolio,
This lead to massive loss of 1960cr this quarter,

Third party investigation confirms the loss and that this is all of the loss,
It is suspected many insiders were involved in this cover upImage
Read 15 tweets
Apr 28
🚨IDFC First Bank-Poor Capital allocator?

IDFC First Bank spent
🩺400cr on Indian cricket sponsorship
🩺180cr in dividends
But to fund this
The bank raised nearly 10,000cr in the last 1 year😅😅😅

Now, as NPAs surge,
The bank reported a very poor set of numbers

A thread🧵on the business of IDFC First Bank & what lies ahead?👇Image
What has happened?

From the high of nearly Rs 90,
IDFC First bank has now lost nearly 30%,

The bank is seeing a surge in microlending NPAs,

Lets find out what lies ahead for IDFC👇 Image
Lets first analyse the Q4 results:-

Loan growth:-
🏦The Bank reported a loan growth of 20%.
🏦Predominantly a retail asset bank.
🏦Unsecured loans remained 60% of the book.
🏦Credit cards book has started to grow sharply
🏦Home loans are now growing well Image
Read 16 tweets
Apr 20
🚨ICICI Bank-The new market leader!

ICICI Bank reported a superb set of numbers!
Led by pristine asset quality,
The results were blockbuster

ICICI Bank has now taken over from HDFC Bank as the true market leader

A comprehensive thread🧵 analyzing the results of ICICI Bank 👇 Image
Credit growth:-

System loan growth at about 10%
🏦Overall loan growth at 13.3%
🏦Retail loan growth at 8.9%
🏦Corporate loan growth at 13.9%

Steady from ICICI Bank Image
ICICI is a Retail Bank now:-

54.3% of the total loan book was retail
the rest 45% was the wholesale book
Read 10 tweets
Apr 19
HDFC Bank is nearly 11% of the Nifty.
Falling Net Interest Margins have been a big concern for the bank🥲🥲

The Bank has just now posted its results
Is the Bank on the road to recovery?🤔🤔

A short thread🧵analyzing each and every aspect of the HDFC Bank result!

Lets go👇 Image
Advances+Deposit growth:-

YoY numbers are not comparable due to the merger

🚨Advance grew by 5%
🚨Retail loans grew by 9%
🚨Deposits grow by 15%

Loan growth has been slowed down to lower the LDR
Deposit growth is firing up for HDFC Bank!

Loan growth must pick up in the coming quartersImage
The cost of borrowing has come down to 4.9%

HDFC's wholesale borrowing has come down 14%

The bank is doing the right things to bring down the cost of funds, Image
Read 13 tweets
Mar 11
🚨Indusind Bank(IIB)-Weak internal controls?

As if the surge in microfinance NPAs wasn't enough,

IIB disclosed discrepancies in the accounting of the derivatives portfolio,
This could lead to a loss of up to 2000cr for the bank,

Mr Sumanth Katpalia says:-
RBI isn't happy with him and cut short his tenure
What is happening at IndusInd Bank?

A thread🧵on the business of Indusind and what lies ahead?👇Image
What has happened?

Indusind Bank had asked for a 3 year extension for Mr Sumanth Katpalia,
RBI had only approved a 1 year extension,

Further bank disclosed yesterday,
Discrepancies in derivatives portfolio which could lead a loss of 2000cr,

This at a time when the bank is seeing a surge in the microlending book NPAsImage
Bank disclosed a negative post-tax impact of 2.35% of net worth arising from a markdown on internal derivative trades

These internal trades pertain to 5–7 years up to 31 March 2024 (stopped thereafter).

These were internal FX derivatives on the bank’s FX borrowings (mainly multilateral) and deposits.

The time line is discomforting—the CFO resigned just before the Q3 earnings, the CEO recently got a one-year extension instead of 3
Read 16 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(