It's still insane to me that Hoeullebecq was making arguments like this a generation ago and I'm still only hearing them stated—at least this plainly—when I go back and read him
I believe this exhaustion is the fundamental condition of liberalism. Its Rosetta Stone
He hit this point even harder a few years later in The Elementary Particles, where he dramatized this condition as a paralysis that *leads* to the exhaustion
Infinite choice, total freedom, leads paradoxically to the inability to judge, and thus to act, subverting the will
The thing that *clobbered* me about Elementary Particles was how he also correctly diagnosed the two promises of post-War liberal human ascendance—science, and sex—and wrecked the both of them
It's made dramatically clear that something critically human is missing from both
After reading a bunch of right-wing political thought, it became clear to me that paralysis is the fundamental condition of post-war liberalism.
E.g. what causes trans? Sexlessness? Malaise itself? Paralysis.
Was like a bolt of lightning to read fiction that understood this
And the beauty of Houellebecq, the reason he's so celebrated, even though he's an obvious reactionary, is that his insights hit so hard they still resonate with the people predisposed to hate him
He's so truthful—and so funny about it—he beguiles even his enemies
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
GoT hooked me, as it did many, for its "gritty realism," its willingness to discard le tropes
But the further I got into it, and the more it revealed its vision of human nature, the more unreal it felt to me. It felt like Martin didn't actually understand people at all.
It seemed to think nearly everyone, certainly those that ever "won," were only motivated by pure power, sex, material etc
But that's a huge blind spot to the human craving for religion, ideology, and frankly, glory—think Theoden's speech, at the battle for Minas Tirith
Yes, a huge part of this was about music critics trying to just allow each other (esp. themselves) to just *enjoy* pop music instead of being guillotined by Pitchfork etc for their plebeian taste
The hipster internet circular firing squad kind of predicted the leftism to come
Art being immeasurable, its criticism was always meant to be something of a brawl
Once critics couldn't come out and say "Best Creed album in years!" without risk of Total Social Death, and were too timid to resist this pressure, the "experts" pretty much ceased to be of use
The premise here was that you increasingly weren't *allowed* to like (certain forms of) pop music and remain a Member in Good Standing, admitting you liked Group X rendered your entire taste moot, exposing you as a kind of "music chud," all opinions discarded
No, we're not doing this again. Imperial units are proportioned to the human body (measure your forearm against your foot sometime) over thousands of years of living
Metric system is just something murderous French rationalists made up to scrub the world of our connection to it
The most brutal refutation of this is that we never switched to a metric system of time. Why don't we have re-standardized "10 hour days," composed of 100 "minutes" each, composed of 100 "seconds" each?
Because people don't live by factors of 10. They live by *the planet*
The inventors of the metric system *did* try to make this happen, of course, but it never took hold because it was deranged
Because, extend the logic further. Maybe we should divide the year into 10ths, too? Now we have 10 months and each month has 10 days. Very reason
Do you remember how after the assassination attempt on Donald Trump the left created a conspiracy theory it must be fake based on the idea no person would stand up like this after he was just shot in the head
These are both examples of "prey morality." Life-forms who are biologically unable to understand the concept of humans who are willing to directly challenge other human predators. Who tell you to "freeze" when they get preyed on
My personal stories about illegals aren't even that bad. No murders, rapes, etc.
But if you work with immigrants for long enough, they will eventually start bringing in co-ethnic workers even *they* can't trust. And you won't know what these people are like until after the fact