In a world of MASSIVE change - a 4th Turning maybe - where our personal economies, finance, politics and our old ways of life are all called into question as the world seeks fresh answers and a new way forward, the rise of "Speculative Communities" has occurred. 1/
These ideas are influenced by the book I am reading "Speculative Communities: Living with Uncertainty in a Financialzed World" by @ariskomporozos suggested to me by @iancr. Im still working through this fascinating book but here are some initial thoughts...
In a world of change where the future is really hard to know but is moving INCREDIBLY fast, the world fragments into communities of like-minded beliefs. That is fairly common and understood.
Some communities reject the future, some embrace the uncertainty and others see different futures. In this day and age of financialization, we get to speculative on these outcomes and create "Speculative Communities".
The flip side of speculation is insurance....
Futures and options were invented both for speculation and for insurance, creating a deep 2-sided market.
In this case, they become the same thing. Finance becomes like voting based on memes, narratives and myths.
All day on FinTwit and CT this plays out and in markets too.
Everything financial becomes political.
Those that are concerned by the rapid societal change begin to bet on narratives of nostalgia (h/t @DeeSmithTexas), the times of the past that give us comfort - fossil fuels, value stocks, anti-financialization, austerity, etc
Those that wants to benefit from the future, whatever it is, tend to bet on technology, crypto, etc
Both are forms of insurance policy on the uncertain future.
They are all like-minded communities looking to each other for support and comfort in this rapid changing time.
They are narrative voting machines as well as insurance policies.
The financial markets and the strength of their memes and communities are a hope to influence the future outcomes...A way to have say outside of the rigged, bias game of traditional politics.
To ULTRA simplify into memes:
Less money to EV = less change.
More money to crypto = more change.
Everyone is unhappy with the status quo and wants to find a way to take back "control".
Obviously, none of us has control over the outcomes as tech accelerates, exponentially.
It will become even more polarizing as time goes on. Remember this tweet from 2021? This is the point I'm trying to make:
Even crypto has splintered into different factions - for example hardcore Bitcoin philosophy vs the Web 3 philosophy.
The rise of AI will only exacerbate this, especially when we overlay Moore Law and Metcalfe's Law. The sand will be feel rapidly shifting under our feet.
Wall Street Bets, Los Indignados, Occupy Wall St, etc are all part of the same.
We all feel fucked and we want a way out - bringing back the past or trying to profit from or cement a very uncertain future.
Either way, we want to protect/insure ourselves.
Others, like @punk6529, are fighting/trying to insure themselves/ourselves from the potential worst parts of that possible future - complete control of the internet/metaverse (the future internet) by centralized actors.
Greta is doing the same with climate.
The Bitcoinners are trying to fight for the same but for protection of finance/money.
The gold bugs, the same but by reverting to a past state.
They all have opposition too.
The markets are now political voting machines and you feel it every day here on Twitter, the key forum
Politics overall has become the same - nostalgia vs embracing the future, hoping either will be better.
Meanwhile, the technology world keeps spinning faster and faster, exponentially.
We all have to find ways of dealing with it.
There are no right answers. We aren't going back to the past, even if we want it.
We can't tell the future, however hard we squint and study it.
We simply don't have control over any of it.
So, we have a choice...
Bet on an outcome to hope to influence it the flow of capital...
Choose the insurance of betting on those things know - the past. However rose-tinted the spectacles.
Or bet on the insurance of the future - and hope to profit from it, however rose-tinted the spectacles.
Geopolitics is equally uncertain...
The New World Order is being re-written.
Pax Americana is being re-written.
Political economies are being re-written.
The Societal Contract is being re-written.
The unknown IS our collective future... for everyone.
Change is happening faster regardless of our wishes, and the biggest societal event in most of our lifetimes was 2008, where we all lost trust in "those in charge", realizing that we were on our own - a watershed moment.
That watershed event, combined with the acceleration of technology (and who or what wins) is the defining narrative of our times.
At the end of that road lies the potential singularity where the machines becomes smarter overall than the humans in our lifetimes.
And the secure world of Pax Americana, New World Order and our system of politics and economics (behavioral economics will throw out the old models too) and political economics will die.
If all that doesn't scare the fuck out of you, you are made of stone.
But the probability is v high over the next 25 years. WHEN we generalize quantum computing, it's GAME OVER.
To many who have spent time on this topic (I have), it is an inevitability. How that future looks?
Who the fuck knows! But we might be able to influence it.
But in the meantime, realize that EVERYONE is dealing with the same, but in different ways.
Have some empathy for others. These times are not easy and will get even more scary/exciting/terrifying all at the same time.
If you want to go down the rabbit hole read:
Ray Kurzweil - The Singularity
Homos Deus - Noah Harari
Crazy Smart - Mo Gawdat
Speculative Communities -
It's ok to be tribal and to hold onto a narrative but realize that we are not really in control of it and our actions are us trying desperately to hold on to something we understand or influence it.
Thanks for being part of my learning journey in 2022. 🙏
Its been a tough year made tougher by the bear market sentiment of anger, confusion and personal attacks. I've had my share of them and its all part of online life, sadly...
1/
My advice for 2023 is:
Learn to be nicer to each other. Karma works. 🤝
There are no guru's. I m not a guru, you are not a guru. We will all be right and wrong at times. 😳
Your investing game is yours and yours alone. It is a lonely pursuit by nature. Own it.👍
Listen and debate divergence views and don't attack them. They might well be right and you, wrong. 😇
Share knowledge and your ideas. We are better all better as a community for it. The Hive Mind works. Fact. Twitter is the worlds best Hive Mind.🐝
Something I've noticed in the past is episodes of low 30-day realized volatility have coincided with lows in the crypto market...
The magic level in BTC is 20%... every time it got there it was the cyclical low or preceded a larger leg higher in an early bull market. 1/
The same vol structure occurs in ETH... but the key 30-day vol level is 40%. October saw 30-day vol at 20%! Again, more evidence that the low was in June.
This likely cyclical low in BTC is the most oversold in history vs the long-term log trend (the Metcalfe's Law adoption curve) at 2 standard deviations...
One of the greatest "moments" of my life was 1996 to 2000 and why it reminds me of now... 1/
I lived in London over that period and it was SPECIAL.
We were at the center of a global cultural revolution.
It was ALL about the UK, and London in particular.
Music was the big culture carrier. Blur, Oasis, Suede, Pulp, etc ruled the world. Every bar in every country I went to sang Oasis songs at the top of their lungs every time it came on the stereo. Oasis filled 2 nights at Knebworth (and could have sold 10 nights!)...
There is some magic happening here in Paris at the @Ledger#LedgerOp3n event. Firstly, the incredible event itself, which felt more like a fashion show or an art experience than a product launch. The new Ledger Stax is a game changer… /1
All designed by the killer dream team of @iancr Ian Rogers (Apple music, LVMH) and @tfadell Tony Fadell who designed the Apple IPod. Ledger Connect and Ledger Vault are to come too… all vital and groundbreaking.
But the real piece of magic is the people here who never would ordinarily get to meet from technologists, developers, product designers, fashion designers, musicians, brands, NFT artists, finance people - all deep into web 3 culture together.
Several of you asked for my Metcalfe's Law mode for ETH. ETH trades at a premium to its raw network value. I need to adjust for burning which makes up the difference but haven't yet done the work... 1/
The number of users is very steady, barring a couple of peaks... adoption in ETH remains robust.
But value of transactions have fallen (mainly driven by lower NFT values)
Just an update to my Metcalfe's Law model for BTC. The model is the total $ value exchanged monthly x number of active users and has a correlation of 97% to total market cap. 1/
Network activity peaked in 2020 and again in 2021 and has been drifting lower. The slow trajectory in decline in network activity is why this liquidity cycle correction in magnitude has so far been less than previous examples thus far.
It also prices the network correctly in value versus 2018.
For the network value to rise from here, we need to see the total value transacted increase or the number of active users increase.
The number of active users is pretty flat on average (Chart from @MessariCrypto )