Fewer than 4000 GRCs have been issued to males identifying as transwomen since 2004.
This means the 32K transwomen saying their sex is female cannot be explained by them having a GRC.
This leaves 28K transwomen answering that they were BORN THE FEMALE SEX /3
The same observation is made for transmen. 28K transmen said that they were BORN THE MALE SEX /4
We can hypothesize many reasons for this anomalous result. However one possibility is that huge numbers of trans people simply lied on their Census return. /5
Sex data matters to all of us, including people who identify as transgender.
Policy makers use it to develop policies to support different groups in society, including the trans community.
Corrupting that data set is a bad idea. As well as unlawful. /6
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
THREAD:
Yesterday we received an email from a woman who had checked the meaning of a “woman-only” fitness class at her local gym. With permission, we’re sharing the story verbatim. Well done that woman 💪… /1
“Warrington's major sports centre is run by a company called LiveWire. They are widely publicising "women only fitness classes", saying how "empowering" these will be because they are "women only"…. /2
We have had multiple meetings with the chair, head of complaints and the head of standards and regulation. In 2020 the head of IPSO promised updated guidance was on the way /2
New guidance is now being written and a draft has been promised by end of January 2023. In light of the avalanche of press coverage regarding the transgender double rapist in Scotland this guidance is more urgent that ever. /3
THREAD: Supporters of the Scottish GRR bill are now spinning a crazy narrative to push the UK government into accepting self-ID south of the border. They are trying to impose their bad law not just on Scottish women, but on women in England and Wales too. /1
For a Scottish GRC to be recognised outside Scotland, the UK Government will have to agree. @RishiSunak and @KemiBadenoch must say NO otherwise they are giving away enhanced rights to prisoners and school children to access female only spaces /2 fairplayforwomen.com/self-id-by-bac…
@RishiSunak@KemiBadenoch The Scottish Government is now cynically exploiting a bureaucratic oversight to shame the UK government into accepting self-ID south of the border.
It claims that the UK already accepts self-ID from other countries so it should do the same for Scotland. /3
2. You pick your "gender" at the start of the season, and you're done. No more fair racing for females then, because any male can declare themselves a woman and race in women's and girls' events.
3. With one exception - when letting males claim female seats in the boat would make it unfair on men. Yep, in mixed crew races, the women rowers must be "assigned female at birth". Otherwise it wouldn't be fair on their male opposition now would it?
Mark Coles interviewed disgraced ex-BBC LGBT correspondant Ben Hunte telling listeners Kemi is anti-trans. Also claimed she has stopped the CT bill without giving listeners any context about potential harms. /2
Worst of all the programme repeated false claims that @KemiBadenoch had men and women signs put on the gender neutral loos at her leadership launch venue. Totally untrue. Very poor fact finding by @BBCRadio4 /3
Scottish committee convenor @JoeFitzSNP won’t give way to questions about the work of the @SP_EHRCJ and it’s approval of the #scottishGRRbill /1
MSP Rachel Hamilton repeats question about whether a GRC changes sex for purposes of the Equality act. A question put by @murdo_fraser but not answered by minister @ShonaRobison /2
Rachel Hamilton MSP says only a small % of the 11,000 written submissions from public were considered by @SP_EHRCJ due to time contraints /3