Attorney General Alan Wilson is in attendance with the State's prosecution team for today's proceedings. #MurdaughTrial@ABCNews4
@ABCNews4 Melinda Worley is off the stand now. Defense took her to task for the fact she is the footwear and tire impression specialist for SLED, but no SLED protocols were followed the night of the initial investigation re: proper photo recording of footprint evidence.
@ABCNews4 To further elaborate on my previous Tweet, Worley explained in defense cross examination that SLED has a set of steps that must be taken to properly document footprints, shoe prints, etc for analysis. Worley conceded those steps weren't followed, rather general photos were taken.
@ABCNews4 Just revealed several of Murdaugh's attorney colleagues were on scene night of murder. Lee Cope, Mark Ball and Ronnie Crosby. Last week it was noted Murdaugh law partner Danny Henderson was also on scene as Murdaugh's personal attorney when he was questioned by SLED.
Add Chris Wilson to the list of attorneys and Murdaugh's friends who all showed up at the house after the murders, according to SLED body camera video and testimony in court.
State prosecutors introduce the .300 BLK rifle taken from the gun room in the Murdaughs' home. It's not the rifle the State alleges was used in the murders.
Bingo. State introduced this little tidbit just before lunch break, along with details of empty 12 gauge turkey load boxes in the trash.
Amen. Not that there aren't crucial things that happen this early or that the overhaul body of work isn't important, but this trial is slated to go 3 weeks for a reason. We're taking baby steps here.
Harpootlian slipped this in this morning during questioning of Worley: later testing of the shirt Murdaugh wore apparently did not show blood despite original presumptive positive test using LCV spray.
Afternoon session of court resumes with State questioning of SLED Sr. Special Agent Jeff Croft, who collected firearms from the Mudaugh home.
SLED Agent Jeff Croft just testified he'd had reason to be in contact with the person who assembled the .300 BLK rifles for Alex Murdaugh BEFORE the murders ever happened. Hasn't been followed up on to explain why.
The State is about to play video of an interview with Alex Murdaugh conducted by SLED on June 10, 2021.
Video of 2nd SLED Murdaugh interview begins with Alex taking phone call from "sister." Sounded like he said Marian. To our knowledge, Alex doesn't have a sister named Marian, but Maggie Murdaugh did. Marian Proctor, who is on the witness list.
Some interesting bits from the first portion of the Murdaugh 2nd SLED interview:
Alex says Paul's worst qualities as a son were due to ADHD. Irresponsible with guns, clothes, even his Dad's boats. Leaves them "strung out all over the state."
SLED agents ask about who would want to hurt Paul & Maggie. Alex says he can't think of anybody - "no idea" - who would go to the extreme they did to murder both.
Alex said his relationship with Maggie was good as it possibly could be. "Wonderful." They didn't argue about much. Only small source of friction was Maggie tended to want to spend more time with her inlaws and family on visits than Alex and the boys did. Nothing serious.
Alex broke down sobbing in the interview, saying Maggie was a "wonderful girl" and "wonderful wife," "great mother." Always said it was "her job -- being privileged enough not to work -- to make sure Alex and the boys were always taken care of. She took care of everything."
Some more notes from the last portion of SLED's 2nd interview with Alex Murdaugh, June 10, 2021:
Alex says they didn't keep guns out at the kennels ordinarily. Tried not to leave them there, but sometimes did. Paul was the worst. He would "leave anything anywhere," Alex said.
Alex notes Paul used to ride around wih his brother Buster's .300BLK rifle to shoot wild hogs on the farm. Alex notes that .300BLK was not out at the kennels the night of the shooting. Buster's .300BLK was the black one seized by SLED.
Alex said he'd bought one .300BLK each for Paul and Buster years ago. Buster's was black, Paul's was tan. Paul's was supposedly stolen in 2017. Alex says he never reported Paul's missing .300BLK stolen because he wasn't convinced it was stolen as opposed to Paul just lost it.
Alex says while he didn't officially report Paul's gun stolem, he did tell his cousing John Bedingfield 9who assembed the rifles) about it, and also mentioned it to other local law enforcement officers.
Alex mentions they replaced Paul's missing rifle with a new .300 BLK in 2017. Alex takes a long pause, then adds it was his understanding the 3rd .300 BLK had been missing a long time, too. Here he's attempting to explain away 2 missing guns. Alex doesn't say they reported it.
Moving on to possible suspects, SLED said because Moselle / Islandton is so rural and the Murdaugh property is so isolated, it's unlikely someone randomly came out there to commit the murders.
SLED agent Dave Owen tells Alex they're starting to look for suspects within.
Alex asks if that means SLED believes this wasn't random. Agent Dave Owen says he's not sure. He doesn't know what to think. Owen says they're going over evidence, and will need to get DNA sample from Alex. SLED also during the interview took Alex's phone to download contents.
SLED then switched gears to Paul's phone. Asked if Alex knew the passcode. Alex said Paul was incredibly secretive, and would be surprised if anybody knew the code.
SLED brings up Alex trying to check Paul's body for a pulse and the phone popping out of his pocket. Alex said at that point, he didn't do anything with Paul's phone because he knew he needed not to mess anything up. This contradicts 1st SLED interview when Alex said he DID.
SLED in the video asks Alex if he knew when Maggie and Paul went to the kennels. Alex isn't sure, confirms the last time he saw them for sure was when they were eating supper.
(We know from pre-trial there's apparently video of Alex at the kennels minutes before the murders.)
Alex immediately after the question about last time seeing Maggie & Paul breaks down crying:
"It's just so bad. I did him so bad. He was such a good boy too," Alex says.
SLED agent Croft testifies Alex said "I did him so bad."
(Many reporters are split on "they" vs. "I")
Gonna break out on a tangent here about the .300 Blackout from a gun enthusiast's perspective.
.300 AAC / .300 Blackout is a type of ammo. AAC stands for the company that developed the cartridge and brought it into widespread circuation and use among gun owners.
.300 Blackout was developed to work with AR-15 style rifles. The original AR-15 was a civilian variant of the military M16 designed to work with the same 5.56mm ammo. The 5.56mm is a near twin to the .223 caliber cartridge. Most standard AR-15's can fire both 5.56 & .223
5.56 / .223 is not a do-all cartridge. That's why Creighton Waters had SLED agent Jeff Croft note .300 BLK is often used to shoot wild hogs.
But the AR-15 is so ubiquitous & reliable, many gun & ammo makers have spent time developing other cartridges that work in the gun.
Think of AR-15s as a Jeep. You can trick out your Jeep with mods & suped-up parts, but the basic vehicle is still a Jeep. That's what AR-15's are in the gun world. You can change caliber from .223 to .300BLK by just changing the barrel, but the rest of the gun doesn't change.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
OK, that felt like breakneck speed in this morning's session. Biggest takeaway: SLED Special Agent Jeff Croft testified multiple times in cross examination he is confident he heard "I did him so bad," not "They did so bad." Says he didn't read a transcript before, either.
We're in lunch break, I'm fully caffeinated thanks to the fine folks at the Live Oak Smokehouse food truck, and I'm -- more importantly -- all caught up on testimony from the first half of the day. So let's update this thread with some interesting stuff, shall we?
I'm seeing lots of "circus" and "how embarrassing" discourse over my hometown's decision to recruit food trucks for the Alex Murdaugh trial.
The circus was already coming regardless, and we ("the media") are the clowns and carnies drooling over the chance to exploit this place.
Y'all want to act like it's tacky? Let's explore that.
You're probably interpreting food trucks from a farmer's market, cul-de-sac, take-your-dog-to-brunch perspective. This ain't that. We all know it. The people in Walterboro know it, too.
But what's the alternative?
The point is there AREN'T any realistic alternatives. But we'll put a pin in that for a sec.
There's a maxim that goes something like "I can talk trash about my family all I want, but YOU can't."
So let me extend that to my hometown & "brag about Walterboro" real quick.
New filings from state prosecutors in the Alex Murdaugh murder trial. Biggest revelation in latest production: Murdaugh's former law firm was suspicious he was stealing money re: boat crash BEFORE the 6/7/2021 confrontation over missing fees in case involving friend Chris Wilson.
Let me rephrase. PMPED *WAS* suspicious before the confrontation. This has been established. What I mean is the new filings Wednesday suggest PMPED was suspicious because of another case, not the Andral Faris estate case Murdaugh worked on with Chris Wilson.
More: Prosecutors say PMPED noticed a check made out improperly to "Forge" in an unrelated case around the same time as the missing fees were discovered in the Faris case. The other case was one involving someone named "Hershberger."
Checking last week's Murdaugh-related court filings, I found an interesting one.
The ACLU of South Carolina wants to file an amicus brief in support of Alex Murdaugh in his ongoing federal lawsuit against Richland County for releasing his phone calls from jail.
An amicus brief is when a third party feels the need to offer its own legal analysis due to a particular interest in the legal issues at hand, or if the outcome may impact them.
In this case, the ACLU says it's FOIA & govt. transparency vs. Murdaugh's 14th Amendment rights.
"(The ACLU) routinely investigates civil rights abuses in South Carolina jails and prisons. Unfettered public dissemination of all recorded messages and phone calls will chill the speech of incarcerated persons and will impede (our) ability to correspond with such individuals."
NEW: South Carolina prosecutors say Alex Murdaugh's motive for murdering his wife and son was to cause a distraction so Murdaugh could avoid imminent discovery of his multi-million dollar financial fraud schemes, using the sympathy gained to buy himself time to cover his tracks.
This is from a new filing by the South Carolina Attorney General's office in response to a motion earlier this week by Murdaugh’s defense attorneys, who had asked a judge to order prosecutors to state their theory of motive via an antiquated legal cure (bill of particulars).
The state in today's filing says Murdaugh's defense attorneys' motion for a "bill or particulars" re: motive is improper in modern legal procedure, but nevertheless lays bare why investigators believe Alex Murdaugh shot & killed his wife, Maggie, and son, Paul, on June 7, 2021.
Wanted to share a few thoughts on the Laffitte trial.
But first — Yes, I got the 90+ page filing by Alex Murdaugh's defense attorneys today.
No, I haven't fully reviewed it. Thanksgiving prep.
Basically it accuses SLED of destroying evidence showing Alex didn't kill Paul.
As for the Laffitte trial, there's first the issue of sentencing.
Laffitte was convicted on all six charges he faced. Here they are with suggested sentences:
Conspiracy to defraud
– 5 years
Bank fraud, wire fraud, misapplication of bank funds (×3)
– Up to 30 years each
Sentencing will take place at a later date, probably about a month from now. Maybe sooner, maybe after the first of the year. It's usually about a month after the verdict in federal court, in my experience. But there's no scheduling order from Judge Gergel yet.