eugyppius Profile picture
Feb 3, 2023 19 tweets 4 min read Read on X
This is a tobacco leaf afflicted with so-called tobacco mosaic disease.
At the end of the 19th century, people noticed that you could crush up these diseased leaves, bring them into contact with healthy tobacco plants, and the healthy leaves would soon exhibit the same disease. Image
This was noted at the end of the 19th c., when the study of bacteria was very cutting edge. Bacteria were at that point the only causative agent for transmissible pathogens that had been identified. Microscope tech was good enough then, that bacteria could be observed.
A number of different scientists, including Pasteur, began to suspect that bacteria could not be the only causative agent here. Nobody could find any rabies 'bacteria,' for example, despite extensive searching for bacteria in samples from rabid animals.
Also, nobody could find bacteria in leaves suffering from tobacco mosaic disease ... and yet, as I said, the disease appeared to be transmissible from plant to plant.
Enter the Chamberland filter, invented in 1884. It was capable of filtering out bacteria-sized particles.
In 1892, a Russian botanist named Dmitri Ivanovsky forced infected tobacco plant through a Chamberland filter, and used the filtered (& theoretically bacteria-free) sap to infect a healthy plant with tobacco mosaic disease.
This is generally considered the first moment that the action of a non-bacterial infectious agent was conclusively demonstrated, though as always, these processes of discovery are a little more complicated than that.
Ivanovski also noticed peculiar pathological features in the cells of affected tobacco plants("intracellular inclusions"), which he described for the first time in this article. Image
Despite this clear evidence of some kind of sub-bacterial cell-infecting pathogen, he continued to insist that tobacoo mosaic disease must be caused by an unusually small submicroscopic bacteria.
A few years passed. A Dutch Botanist named Martinus Beijerinck became interested in the whole issue. He started out by replicating Ivanovski's experiments with the Chamberland filter. He chracterised the filtered fluid from infected plants as a "living contagious fluid"
His perceptive and intelligent article is online here, and a real joy to read. He noted, for example, that the filtered sap could infect an effectively limitless number of healthy plants and that it must reproduce in its hosts (i.e., is not a toxin).
dwc.knaw.nl/DL/publication… Image
He put a drop of filtered, infected sap in an agar plate (a petri dish with a growth medium). If he waited a few days, he found he could infect healthy plants in a somewhat wider radius, than where he had put the drop – i.e., the pathology was caused by water-soluble particles...
...that could diffuse in a liquid medium. Yet, it didn't seem to grow in the sugars of the petri dish, like bacteria would. he could tell, because when he infected healthy plants from the agar plate weeks and weeks later, they didn't suffer from more virulent disease.
He could even dry out the medium in which he had placed the infectious sap, and it would still infect healthy plants even months later, b/c tobacco mosaic virus is non-enveloped and fairly durable. This too had no effect on disease severity.
All of this was really bizarre, for scientists used to studying bacteria. If you culture the bacteria for a while in a petri dish, the concentration of bacteria should increase, causing more severe infection in a host. If you dry out the medium ...
this should likewise kill or at least attenuate bacteria infectiousness. Beijerinck had discovered that the tobacco pathogen a) didn't replicate on its own, was b) to some degree oddly durable, not like a microorganism, & c) could cause the same severity of disease ...
regardless of concentration. The latter, of course, is down to the fact that viruses hijack healthy cells to reproduce themselves. Infected cells produce so many virions, it's hard to detect differences in infection severity between infections caused by few virus particles...
...and infections caused by many. Beijerinck christened this pathogen a "virus," and the term stuck. Everything else has been details.
Thus we see, that the existence of some virus-like pathogen was anticipated by multiple researchers before the actual thing was discovered ...
because bacteria were insufficient to explain all observed transmissible pathogens; and we also see that in vivo transmissibility was absolutely central to the discovery of submicroscopic viruses. Only by causing mosaic disease in healthy plants ...
could people like Beijerinck demonstrate that there was virus in a sample at all.
Early research on viruses is highly interesting and completely replicable by total amateurs today. You can describe most of the basic properties of viruses by conducting these same experiments.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with eugyppius

eugyppius Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @eugyppius1

Jan 9
(link below) Image
the unhinged hysteria about relaxed censorship on American-controlled social media just continues unabated here in Europe. it is worrying and mystifying in equal measrues. eugyppius.com/p/leading-jour…
Zuckerberg's announcement that he'll phase out fact-checkers *in America* has our journaloids wringing their hands and regulators tweeting veiled threats of sanctions at Facebook. some guy in FAZ is saying it may cause genocide. is becoming hard to describe the levels of crazy.
Read 5 tweets
Dec 22, 2024
Fascinating report from Mitteldeutsche Zeitung about Taleb al-Abdulmohsen's colleagues impressions of him:

"The Staff Called Him ‘Dr Google’: Is the Magdeburg Attacker Really a Doctor?
"Among staff at the Bernburg forensic psychiatric hospital, doubts ... have grown since the 50-year-old Saudi began work there in March 2020 ...

"‘We call him ‘Dr Google’,’ an employee tells MZ.
He got the nickname because he "had to look up every diagnosis on the internet."
" ... The man, who as a specialist in psychiatry and psychotherapy heads three therapy wards, is said to have always done his rounds alone. 'He avoided talking to us staff as much as possible.’
Read 10 tweets
Dec 5, 2024
(link below) Image
This story is about a massive investigative journalism consortium/NGO called the Organized Crime and Corruption Reporting Project. It has been largely (and secretly) funded & controlled by the U.S. State Department for years.
eugyppius.com/p/how-the-us-s…
The OCCRP has an annual budget of 20 million Euro, 200 dedicated employees, and 70 partners/members across the West – from the New York Times to Der Spiegel. They are responsible for a series of major investigative reports often based on mysterious data leaks ...
Read 11 tweets
Dec 1, 2024
(link in reply) Image
This story is about Bairawies, a small village southweast of Wolfrathausen. A developer has leased a plot of land there, and wants to put a container facility on it to house 128 migrants. The population of Bairawies is 280 people.

eugyppius.com/p/local-green-…
This would endow our idyllic village with an immigrant concentration vastly higher than that of cities like Berlin. Locals of course oppose it and the municipal planning authority has rejected the plans, but this doesn't mean much:
Read 8 tweets
Nov 9, 2024
How the German government collapsed and what will happen now

Many asked me for my thoughts on the end of the traffic light. Here are all the tiresome and depressing details:

eugyppius.com/p/how-the-germ…
Contrary to what charlatans like Peter Sweden claim, this is not a new extension of the MAGA revolution. Scholz's government fell apart because of internal ideological contradictions, and because they ran out of money to spend on dem projects.
All the ugly details are in the post, so I'll just emphasise that they're likely to be replaced by the CDU, in a coalition with the SPD and probably also the Greens. Chances are high the market-liberal FDP get voted out of the Bundestag.
Read 8 tweets
Sep 4, 2024
East Germany is not 'far right.' They're voting for right-leaning populist parties at basically the same rate as the French and the Italians. They're normal.

It's the West Germans who are the anomaly.
These theses about the German past are very enticing, I get it. Scratch a German and he must be a Nazi!
Super compelling for ret@rds whose historical vision stops at 1933. Newsflash: National Socialism was a thing for 12 years. It ended 79 years ago.
There are three major reasons that East Germany votes differently from the West. They have nothing to do with lingering Nazi sentiment in the east. Nazis have not been a factor in German history for four generations.

I will list the reasons:
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(