Reports are mounting esp in 🇩🇪 press that after having finally decided to supply leopard tanks to Ukraine, Germany has now been abandoned by countries that had signalled willingness to contribute their part.

I did some research to find out what’s up with 🇳🇱🇩🇰🇸🇪🇫🇮
The Netherlands doesn’t have any own leopards but leases 18 from Germany.

PM Mark Rutte had suggested that 🇳🇱 could buy the 18 tanks from 🇩🇪 & deliver to 🇺🇦. However, after consultations with 🇩🇪, it was decided that the leopards for 🇺🇦 should not come from the 🇩🇪🇳🇱 battalion
Part of the perception that the Netherlands is one of the drivers of the leopard initiative is that the Dutch (both citizens & politicians) are very supportive what comes to military aid to 🇺🇦 and it’s politically pretty much a non-issue.

However, 🇳🇱 doesn’t have much to give.
So instead of the leopard 2s, the Netherlands is financially contributing to the refurbishment of 178 leopard 1s, together with Denmark and Germany.

🇳🇱 supportive stance on delivering fighter jets to Ukraine may have also been muddled into the discussion.
Denmark has 44 leopard 2s, which are among the most modern. However, 14 of those are currently in Estonia on NATO eFP duty, some in maintenance/ getting an upgrade in Germany, and the rest is needed for exercise purposes.
Hence, 🇩🇰 minister of defence Jakob Ellemann-Jensen has repeatedly stated that Denmark can’t spare any of the leopard 2s.

Of the 178 leopard 1s destined to Ukraine, ~100 were sold from Denmark to the German company in 2010. So Denmark is now contributing to fixing them for 🇺🇦.
Norway only has 36 leopard tanks but will donate 8 of them to Ukraine. However, they’re an older model and to be replaced by 54 new ones from 2026 onwards.
Sweden has not announced intention to donate their leopard tanks yet but foreign minister Tobias Billström said last week that 🇸🇪 is exploring ways to contribute to the initiative and 🇸🇪 leadership has emphasised that no future weapons deliveries are excluded
Sweden will also likely be involved in the Finnish contribution via the bilateral letter of intent signed by 🇫🇮&🇸🇪 in Ramstein, in which the countries agreed to use their joint operational planning to enable continued Finnish deliveries to Ukraine
There have been reports about an anonymous NATO source saying that Finland would not contribute tanks until the NATO accession is finalised. I doubt that this is the case since everyone in Finland knows that Ukraine can’t wait for that
🇫🇮 defence minister, foreign minister, president & PM have all said that Finland will be part of the initiative but no details will be given about exact nature (& numbers) of 🇫🇮 contribution until after the leopards have arrived in 🇺🇦. This is the 🇫🇮 line on military aid to 🇺🇦
So to conclude: as far as I’ve understood, the Polish-led battalion of older leo 2s is complete but the German-led still missing about half. Finland has both 2A4 & 2A6 but will hardly to be able to supply half a battalion, since 200 tanks are not a lot for a 1340km border
I’m not sure what’s up with Spanish leos - but Spain hasn’t, for some reason, been in the focus of the 🇩🇪 criticism.

Spain was the first to announce willingness to deliver leopards to Ukraine back in the summer. Subsequently it turned out all of them were in too bad a condition
Now, however, Spain is back on the list of countries contributing and apparently has some (but less than 10?) to donate. 🇪🇸 is supposed to have more than 300 leopards, couldn’t some of them be fixed for Ukraine if they’re currently not in a combat condition…?
Time is running as the Russian offensive is already in full swing and Europe lost lots of precious time, waiting for 🇩🇪 to make up its mind. So other leopard countries better figure out their contributions quickly so that the tanks will arrive in 🇺🇦 in March as planned

(End)

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Minna Ålander 🌻

Minna Ålander 🌻 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @minna_alander

Feb 17
One year ago, a staggering amount of military analysis got both Russia and Ukraine wrong. An important reason for it was that analysis based on counting equipment and looking at (scripted) exercises misses one crucial point: the human element.
If you don’t pay attention to

1) what number of people are available to operate the equipment (see Sweden: lots of jets but not enough pilots)
2) what is their skill level (see Bundeswehr’s puma incident where malfunction of the equipment was partly due to lacking know-how)
3) their motivation: the role of willingness to defend (i.e. motivation to fight)

you’re bound to get the military capability of a country wrong because the number of equipment alone doesn’t tell you the whole story.

Not to even get started about maintenance & logistics
Read 11 tweets
Feb 17
Bundeswehr-chief Zorn @BundeswehrGI is impressed with the Ukrainian soldiers he has met while they’re training in Germany and believes that Ukraine can keep the initiative even against the odds.

He also says that Ukraine must win. 👏👏

🇩🇪🤝🇺🇦
I hope he can convince Scholz to say the same. Scholz’ reluctance to say Ukraine must win (instead of “not lose”) is probably because then he would have to define a 🇺🇦 victory - which includes the question of Crimea.

Full Interview here:
welt.de/politik/deutsc…
This comes a long way from an interview in September when General Zorn didn’t see a real counteroffensive in Ukraine (while it was in fact in full swing) and suggested that Russia might open a second front at the Finnish border, among other locations.

amp.focus.de/politik/auslan…
Read 5 tweets
Feb 14
Big news today in Finland & Sweden: Finnish parliamentarians informed their Swedish colleagues during a visit that Finland will start drafting the required laws for NATO accession, making it more likely that 🇫🇮 would become member without 🇸🇪 if 🇹🇷&🇭🇺 ratify separately
This comes after NATO GenSec Jens Stoltenberg said today that it’s not so important whether 🇫🇮&🇸🇪 enter the Alliance at the same time, but that they become members asap. This marks a change in tone

on.ft.com/3k0RS5h
However, 🇫🇮 parliament’s foreign affairs committee’s chairperson Jussi Halla-Aho said that there is no unanimous answer within the committee to the question how Finland would proceed in case it was ratified without Sweden
hs.fi/politiikka/art…
Read 12 tweets
Feb 10
Germany has come a long way from initially delivering 5000 helmets to Ukraine to now agreeing to send German-made MBTs - within one year. By German standards that’s nothing short of revolutionary speed. That is understood and appreciated by partners and allies BUT ➡️🧵
The external circumstances (war on the continent & dire state of European defence capacity) are such that there’s no time for a regular thorough (and by default rather slow) German process. 🇩🇪 needs to speed up Zeitenwende.

However, there are path dependencies complicating it
It’s not a bug but a feature that Germany is a slow country to change. After the world wars, the German political system was designed - by Allied powers - in a way that would make efficient decision-making and concentrating power on esp military matters as hard as possible
Read 8 tweets
Feb 10
Finland’s strategic non-communication has a long tradition dating back to the difficult balancing act in the Cold War with the Soviet Union (aka finlandisation).

Although Finland is otherwise very NATO-interoperable, strategic culture needs an overhaul once we join the Alliance
During the Cold War Finland was in the absurd situation that the Finno-Soviet treaty of 1948 obliged Finland to have defence plans against the West (NATO) but it couldn’t have official defence plans against the Soviet Union.
Finland had defence plans for the eastern border but only very few written documents existed & they were camouflaged as things such as fuel supply plan and a travel report. Otherwise the knowledge was kept completely in oral form & in a very small circle

hs.fi/kotimaa/art-20…
Read 10 tweets
Feb 10
Once more louder to the ones in the back:

I never said that Germany is blocking. My whole point was that since this decision will have to be made, and with leopards it essentially depends on Germany, the 🇩🇪govt should proactively make the decision instead of being pushed to it
It was a missed opportunity that Germany didn’t take the lead on this months ago and started forming a coalition.

Let’s remember that Spain already wanted to deliver leos in the summer, but the tanks suddenly turned out completely useless, but are now again deliverable. 🧐
If Germany wants to have some kind of leadership role in European security, the leopards would’ve been the perfect opportunity.

Also idk how it’s a surprise that 🇩🇪 would have to deliver the largest numbers ? It has the largest combined industry + army stock & no border with 🇷🇺
Read 6 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(