Just a reminder that the #SeattleVote just did what the Indian Constitution (Articles 15 & 17) already do.

So anyone opposing the bill as anti Hindu or anti India is calling the constitution of India as anti Hindu or anti India.

#JaiBhim
Pic 1: Constitution of India
Pics 2 & 3: What the #SeattleVote did. Just added caste where you see.

What exactly is anti India or anti Hindu?

Send this tweet to savarna Hindus who whine about the ordinance.

Ask them if they are opposed to the Indian constitution itself. ImageImageImage
It's innocuous if you fundamentally oppose systemic discrimination. Then it's just one word added, just one more category.

It *IS* substantial given
a. The industry & social influence of Seattle
b. The "memetics" inherent in grassroots US politics.

Remember that American politics is not top down "high command" culture anymore.

It used to be.

But in the last 100 years, it's become much more diffused. Decentralized.

Social change starts innocuously and then cascades in US politics. Cos others mimic success.
That's how we first saw homosexuality fully legalized in US in the 90s, then same sex marriage in 2010s, and a majority of the population now in weed legal states and the President having declared a federal amnesty for weed crimes.

All that started with such small steps.
There are dozens of aspiring politicians, activists, or even just idealists who look at Kshama Sawant and think, hey, why don't I try this in my city?

It's a fundamentally good idea in line with civil rights AND it raises my public profile, boosts my career options!
If this had happened in Manmohan days or even Vajpayee days, it would not have been that big a deal.

In those days, India generally collectively used to at least say in public that casteism bad.

Modi years have created a constituency for actively denying casteism even exists!
A lot of the social progress America has seen in the 21st century has started in local regional politics.

As Congress has gotten more lethargic, cities and states have gotten more nimble.

And unlike India, there is real power at local levels, not an IAS fiefdom.
And yeah, the meltdown seems disproportionate cos you & I are not apologists for casteism.

To those who are, it is cause for meltdown.

If NYC bans goat meat, my wife won't care cos she doesn't eat goat. But I will have a meltdown.

Same thing.

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Gaurav Sabnis

Gaurav Sabnis Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @gauravsabnis

Feb 24
Bro @akshaykumar, before you apply for an Indian passport, you need to apply for an Indian citizenship. You keep pretending or implying you have "dual citizenship", "honorary citizenship". How much will you lie, man?

First get Indian citizenship like Adnan Sami.

Then passport.
Modi govt will ignore all his jugaad as long as he stays in their good books, but use it against him when needed.

Like Modi govt was ok ignoring @AatishTaseer's illegally obtained jugaad OCI as long as he was cheering Modi. And as soon as he was mildly critical, hammertime!
I know Aatish and Tavleen like to pretend like it is something that was taken away from him, but the truth is, by law, he should never have gotten that OCI in the first place. Clearly there was some jugaad in his even getting it.

Modi kept it in mind until he needed to use it.
Read 6 tweets
Feb 23
Further proof that HAF is primarily a grievance based fundraising operation for whom incoherence is a key feature.

This is so incoherent!

If you're against discrimination, your stance makes no sense.

And communities with systemic discrimination deserve extra legal scrutiny. 🤷🏽 Image
The basic logic underlying all these HAF whines over treating caste as a protected category in discrimination statutes is "everyone discriminates,y u single us out" which is incoherent given that that there like 20 protected categories and no one is being singled out.
"this will lead to discrimination against all Indians in hiring" is also an incoherent objection cos national origin is a protected category under the discrimination statutes since decades.

So if you see evidence of Indians being systemically discriminated against, focus there!
Read 6 tweets
Feb 23
Today in class we do the Disney case study, and historically, this is a class that "ruins" a lot of childhood and even current favorites 🤭. When I break down their "product" as something put together with a lot of marketing variables, but a lot of it being basically the same. /1
This is a generation to which Frozen means a lot. So when I tell them Frozen is basically a marketing product, just repackaged Wicked, right down to Idina Menzel and a petite blond sister, a lot of them are like NOOO😭.

They appreciate the marketing insights though.
During the Netflix case, when I talked about how the company uses data in its content creation and even story structure, I used Wednesday as an example. That it's basically a diverse and lgbtq-friendly Harry Potter. Mixed with old Addams family. Plus throw in 90s Wednesday.
Read 22 tweets
Feb 23
Why so many Indians commenting on internal matter of Seattle? 🤔
LOL at sanghis and wokephobes (getting hard to tell the two apart) earnestly responding to this. For people that deal exclusively in rhetorical questions, they sure can't identify one from someone else.
Best of all are "extra taxpayer money will be spent on this 😤😤" and it's like o baba, you are not paying taxes in Seattle. You're avoiding taxes in Delhi. Why taking load?
Read 7 tweets
Feb 23
Recognize the attempts after Fadnavis took over to inject l0vej1had hate tactics against marrying Muslims as the second stage of fascism that they are.

Culturally and historically, this has just never been even an under the surface issue in Maharashtra's daily life. /1
Not like Marathis are totally cool with inter faith couples. They face opposition from the family. But historically, we've just not cared about strangers or even neighbors doing those. We might not rent to them. But actively going out and targeting requires a Northie paranoia. /2
The Northie paranoia is based on considering the north Indian Muslim a legit threat in the romantic arena, primarily based on looks. The north Indian Muslim stock has a lot of central Asian blood. A higher likelihood of the conventional tall fair skinned good looks. /3
Read 11 tweets
Feb 23
Nikki Haley has played Trump like a fiddle. She knows there's never actually going to be a mental ability test. She targets Sanders tho. She knows Trump weirdly believes he's young vigorous cos Biden is older. But she knows that age isn't on his side either. But he's taken bait.
He supports her absolutely pointless and ageist mental test, which will never happen, in the process making age a repeated issue in the GOP cycle. And you know who's got two thumbs and is definitely under 75? Nikki Haley.
Her strategy is announce early, stay in the news, above the fray and below the radar, as Trump and DeSantis bloody each other. And Trump gets multiple indictments. And DeSantis wilts like TPaw, Walker etc. She can hope for a late 2023 surge.
Read 9 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(