#RobodebtRC Greggery suggests that with all the evidence we’ve seen it appears former DSS Dep Secretary Serena Wilson made the decision to mislead the Ombudsman by removing the 2014 legal advice. Wilson insists she can’t recall, but also can’t explain why anyone would. [1/2]
#RobodebtRC Greggery suggests Serena Wilson was “caught out” by the Ombudsman, & went on to deliberately hide the 2014 legal advice.
And that Wilson’s lack of recall is just a case of being “Dishonest”
A brutal end as Wilson rejects all assertions against her. [2/2]
And off I go to collect the kids.
Glad I could squeeze these clips out. They are frightening as Eric Banana suggests 😬
Hope to resume abit later.
Scott Britton on now, got it on in the background.
Don’t forget he was thrown under the bus yesterday by Jason Ryman who said he wanted to push ahead despite inadequate testing on Robodebt.
And that he (Ryman) was only following Briton’s instructions.
Scott Britton tells the Commissioner
“I don’t know what we were thinking at the time” 🤦♂️ #IRemember
Can see Angus Scott now bring up an email from Jason Ryman to Scott Britton, regarding PAYG cleanup. Ryman was grilled about it yesterday and said he would have been under instruction from Britton.
Britton: “I don’t remember”
“I don’t recall”
Scott KC grilling Britton now.
They are emails from 2015, attaching a DSS policy document which Ryman initially said he never had seen, but then conceded he ‘might’ have seen and been under instruction from Britton.
Britton leaning on “can’t recall” as his main evidence.
“I relied on the advice of others” (referring to legal advice he says he didn’t check/see)
Give us a break Britton, you were the General Manager, Ryman’s boss, others relied on YOU. FFS
Commissioner suggests Britton either deceived DSS or acted in coordination with them, to remove wording about averaging in a policy document.
Britton gets defensive, said he would never deceive. But can’t give any other possibility to what Commissioner suggests. Ouch.
Holy crap. This man who says he can’t recall anything including why the scheme went ahead despite shocking testing results. He is pushed on if he can provide any explanation at all.
Britton says its possible people were in fear of now deceased Malisa Golightly. 😒
So his evidence is, the only explanation he can provide for Robodebt going ahead despite BAD test results, is sorry folks, we may have not wanted to upset the DHS Dep Secretary at the time. She was really scary.
Appalling.
Britton asked if he was “in charge” at the time.
A short pause, before shirking responsibility and insisting he was only “following instructions”
Commissioner asks him to name names.
He names Mark Whitwell (next witness, assume tomorrow).
And deceased Malisa Golightly.
Serving scrambled Serena Wilson & a Scott Britton fritter for breakfast tomorrow friends 👨🍳
Greggery may be serving a well done Whitnell for lunch 😂
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
#RoboDebtRC
Evidence shows you signed this document?
MW: ‘Golightly made me do it’
Evidence shows Mr Ryman was the Project Manager?
MW: ‘Yes he was’
Evidence shows YOU were the Senior Responsible Officer?
MW: ‘Perhaps that’s what is written but it’s actually Golightly’
🙄🙄
I left the Ryman bit in there, to just show, any time they found someone ‘else’ responsible, he agreed, yes they are.
Any time he, in a much more senior position, was asked to take responsibility, he shifted blame to Golightly, or said he couldn’t recall.
And sorry for the deletion, it’s unlikely but at times these get picked up by the media so if it somehow ends up in an article, may as well make sure it’s accurate.
#RobodebtRC Former DHS Gen. Manager Mark Whitnell insists he didn’t realise the letters sent to recipients didn’t warn them that their income would averaged.
Angus Scott sets him up with hard propositions only for Commissioner to knock him down 🤕🔥
Mark Whitnell appeared very shaky & frightened in his evidence today.
It only makes me angry. Pretty pissed off to see this shmuck refuse to accept responsibility, say he was busy, say he can’t recall, point the finger.
Commissioner didn’t let him off tho👍 #IRemember
Finishing his testimony, Commissioner asks who he would say was most in charge of the scheme going ahead.
Of course Whitnell blames deceased Malisa Golightly. Says she was difficult and the key decision maker. Nobody else. Ffs.
#RobodebtRC
“I’m not sure”
“I just don’t recall”
DHS Manager Mark Whitnell off to a sketchy start with an already fed up Commissioner not in the mood to cut him any slack. #IRemember
Thread from Whitnell’s previous woeful appearance at the commission. 👇 Seems we are back to having no memory as a main form of evidence. Aren’t we all shocked.
Angus Scott brings up an email showing details of the Feb 2015 meeting which both Ryman & Britton said they don’t recall. Whitnell was present. Let’s see what he recalls.
Victorian Liberal & religious nutcase Moria Deeming’s reported speech after being elected into parliament:
“I did not win on merit, I did not win because I was popular in the party, I did not win by being a part of a faction. I won because God arranged it” 🤦♂️
Here we go again…
She also said in another speech that she is bringing in
“long term financial backers” (without naming who), for her party.
Church groups?
Opposition Leader Pesutto wouldn’t be drawn into it & insists
“She understands the importance of us working as a team”
John Pesutto who for some reason felt the need to label himself a “progressive & modern” leader to the journos, also said that the reason Moira Deeming remains a Vic Liberal is because the party encourages a
“voice for everyone”
Jason Ryman says its not his fault, was only following instructions from boss Scott Britton
Scott Britton then says its not his fault, was only following instructions from boss Mark Whitwell
Whitnell hearing might be a hot one🔥
Britton excused after a thumping finish by the commissioner. With Britton at the end claiming he was under impression there was no issues with using averaging.
And commissioner saying, but you knew, DSS advised you back in 2015.
Britton says that’s the part he can’t work out 🙄
As in, he says he can’t work out how after being advised by DSS of issues with averaging, how nothing was done about it.
#RobodebtRC Greggery kicks off asking former DSS Secretary Serena Wilson about her interactions with Scott Morrison. Wilson concedes she “conflicted” with Morrison’s “rigour of policy development”. RRC now seeking more information on Morrison’s dealings at the time.
Whilst Wilson is being careful in her approach, she did name Scummo as being aware of legislative requirements for Robodebt before pressing ahead with the scheme, saying she was told this by Malisa Golightly. Greggery clearly wanting more.
Wilson was grilled in extraordinary fashion in her previous hearing, if you didn’t see it, see here