The Punic Wars poisoned Republican Rome and led to its slow death. The twin devastations of massacring of the middle class part-time warriors & the influx of slave-labor destroyed the conditions that led to Roman strength in the 400s-220 BC.
These devastations can be directly attributed to Hannibal’s annihilation of the Roman Army. In two years & only three major battles, Hannibal killed 20% of Rome’s military age men. That’s roughly the same as the losses of the USSR in all of World War Two!
These dead men left farms to be gobbled up by the rich, flush with cash & slaves from military victories. Many of those who survived lost their farms anyways as they couldn’t maintain them while on lengthy campaigns further and further from home.
As the middle class was gutted, dispossessed peasants flock to the urban slums. Power was consolidated in the elite & “moral decline” was witnessed in desperation of poor & hedonism of the rich. The military was fully professionalized by necessity & generals become more powerful.
This lead to the cataclysm of the Civil Wars & establishment of the Principate. I think people underestimate how completely hollowing these conflicts & their outcome were to Roman culture & society. The facade remained but the people & way of life was exhausted.
From Augustus’s conservative policies to Marcus Aurelius’s Stoicism, the elite presented solutions without resolving the underlying issues. Political stability finally broke in a few centuries’ time as power was slowly consolidated in new, once-conquered peoples & regions.
This breakdown, labeled the Crisis of the 3rd Century, necessitated by the wealth of the East & soldiers of the Balkans, lead to radical restructuring; new internal borders for the Empire, a radical shift in military organization, & collapse of the monetary economy (tax in kind).
Christianity also underwent continued growth as it provided spiritual purpose & community to the urban poor. It was also adopted by the state to bind the Empire, now long bereft of the old unity & conquering spirit of the Republican Romans that once was served as its core.
Christianity & its organizational structures then formed the new nexus of the civilization. Bishoprics replaced the classical polis as building blocks of the Med. World. An over-simplification but cool to see how the Punic Wars affected the trajectory of the Roman Empire.
Hannibal’s father, Hamilcar, also a famed Carthaginian general & enemy of the Romans bound his 9 year old son with the oath, “I swear so soon as age will permit...I will use fire and steel to arrest the destiny of Rome." Even in defeat Hannibal was true to his word.
For hundreds of years the “Wild Fields” of the Pontic Steppe, was a battleground. Millions would be driven to the great slave markets of Crimea and sold to a life of misery in the Ottoman Empire.
This brutal conflict birthed the Cossacks, modern Russia, & changed Europe forever.
The medieval steppe of S. Ukraine was controlled by nomads, any settlement was under constant threat by Turkic bands that drove their great herds across the plains.
After the collapse of the Golden Horde in the early 16th c., massive raids were launched into Russia & Ukraine.
Beauplan, a Frenchman residing in 17th century Ukraine remarked on the awful spectacle of the raids, “During the interval of this week-long stop, they bring together all their booty, consisting of slaves and livestock, and divide the entire quantity among themselves. The most inhuman of hearts would be touched to see the separation of a husband from his wife, of a mother from her daughter, there being no hope of their ever seeing each other again. They are to become wretched slaves of Mohammedan pagans, who abuse them atrociously. The brutality [of these Tatars] causes them to commit an infinite number of filthy acts, such as ravaging young girls, raping women in the presences of their fathers and husbands, and even circumcising children before their parents’ very eyes, so that they may be offered to Mohammed.”
Saint-Emperor Nikephoros Phokas dedicated his life to defeating the Muslim Emirates that for centuries had attacked Byzantium.
His success was so complete that the military manual he penned with his brother Leo, the Praecepta Militaria, begins with an apology:
“[The treatise might not offer] much application in the eastern regions at the present time. For Christ, our true God, has greatly cut back the power and strength of the offspring of Ishmael and has repelled their onslaughts…
Nonetheless, in order that time, which leads us to forget what we once knew, might not completely blot out this useful knowledge, we think we ought to commit it to writing…
Today, 570 years ago, Ottoman Janissaries poured over the Theodosian Walls.
The Genoese fled when their leader, Giovanni Giustiniani, was injured. The Emperor threw himself into the hopeless struggle & died with his men.
After over 2,000 years, the Roman Empire was no more.
The final siege of Constantinople is the last chapter in the swan song of the Late Byzantine Empire & a dramatic tale of betrayal, duty, determination, honor, and horror.
In 1449, Emperor John VIII died & his brother Constantine XI took the throne. Crowned in a small ceremony in Mystras, Constantine was never coronated by the Patriarch in Constantinople thanks to his support for a Union with the Papacy, an unpopular movement in Byzantium.
The fact that the Byzantines basically forgot they ruled Sardinia will always be funny to me.
After the Muslim conquest of Sicily, Sardinia was isolated from the rest of the empire. The Byzantines had more pressing matters & through negligence, Sardinia slowly gained a measure of de facto independence.
The Sardinians repelled frequent raids from Sicily & Africa by Muslim pirates. Such attacks forced them to abandon many of the old ports and cities of the coast, further isolating them from the rest of the Byzantines by making the life-line of communication by sailing weaker.
During the reign of Constantine VII, a raiding party from Tarsus attacked the sleepy village of Herakleos.
The villagers were celebrating Divine Liturgy when they received the grave news.
The village priest, Themel, decided to act. That decision would change his life forever.
As Themel prepared the Holy Mystery a messager burst into the church to announce that Muslim raiders had been spotted marching toward the village.
Themel stopped the liturgy and stormed out of the church at the head of his flock, wearing his priestly vestments and armed with a semantron, a big wooden or iron board to hit as a sort of bell.
If you’ve read Ibrahim you’ll know he isn’t a historian; he’s a polemicist. He uses primary sources to weave a narrative of constant, civilizational conflict between Islam & Christianity.
There is no scrutiny of sources or historiography, these are broad strokes to get the scene set for another chapter in a 1,400 year cage match.
If you are looking for Treadgold or Kaldellis here you won’t find him. Ibrahim understands that the Byzantines after Basil II struggled to adapt to new threats, yet is uninterested in the complex political, social, and material causes.