Varangian Chronicler Profile picture
Medieval stories from Europe’s eastern frontier
প্রদীপ্ত মৈত্র (Pradipto Moitra) Profile picture dumb_coiner Profile picture Maleph Profile picture Jovan Marjanovic Profile picture Hakan Profile picture 19 subscribed
May 10 9 tweets 3 min read
During the reign of Constantine VII, a raiding party from Tarsus attacked the sleepy village of Herakleos.

The villagers were celebrating Divine Liturgy when they received the grave news.

The village priest, Themel, decided to act. That decision would change his life forever. Image As Themel prepared the Holy Mystery a messager burst into the church to announce that Muslim raiders had been spotted marching toward the village. Image
Apr 30 5 tweets 2 min read
A lot of people are sending this to me.

If you’ve read Ibrahim you’ll know he isn’t a historian; he’s a polemicist. He uses primary sources to weave a narrative of constant, civilizational conflict between Islam & Christianity.

Whether or not you agree; that’s the motive here. There is no scrutiny of sources or historiography, these are broad strokes to get the scene set for another chapter in a 1,400 year cage match.
Apr 5 17 tweets 6 min read
The Byzantine army was the most multi-ethic force in the pre-modern world.

Mongols, Turks, Africans (Zanj), Saxons, Norse, Rus, Normans, Huns, Alans, Cumans, Pechenegs, Germans, Italians, Georgians, Armenians, Iranians, Albanians, Catalans, and more.

How did they manage it? Image Many came as mercenary warrior bands looking for employment. These were enrolled within the military and given regular pay & orders under the watchful eye of Byzantine officers.

This prevented mercenaries from becoming a nuisance & the Byzantines to use them expertly in battle. Image
Mar 9 12 tweets 5 min read
During the reign of Emperor Theophilos, ships from the misty North slid into the harbor at Constantinople. The envoys entered the Imperial Court & sparked curiosity among the Byzantines. Who were these strangers? Image The men explained to the Emperor that they were Rhos, and subjects of a Khagan who ruled the river lands north of the Black Sea. Their way home had been blocked by steppe nomads and they asked for his help in traveling back. Image
Jan 23 18 tweets 7 min read
Few people realize how close Europe was to a second Dark Age in the 9th century. The world that emerged from that chaos created the Medieval World far more than the Age of Charlemagne, a glorious & ephemeral vision of European unity not unlike Napoleon. Image By the end of the 800s AD Charlemagne’s Empire had collapsed into a mess of squabbling warlords. Vikings overran England, besieged Paris. Magyars trampled over the fertile interior. Muslim raiders reached the walls of Rome itself. These attacks degraded central control further Image
Dec 5, 2023 12 tweets 5 min read
In the spring of 718 AD, the once mighty besiegers of Constantinople limped southwards. Sources say only 5 ships out of almost 2,000 returned to Syria.

The Byzantines smelled blood in the water & attacked ferociously, immortalized in Islamic prophecies of the apocalypse. Image With most of the Caliphate’s fleet now charred flotsam in the Sea of Marmara, Leo III took advantage of his enemy’s weakness. In the same year of his victory at Constantinople a fleet was dispatched to Latakia, the main naval base of the Caliphate. Image
Oct 28, 2023 7 tweets 3 min read
It’s difficult to overstate how precarious the Empire was in the 7th & 8th centuries. Iconoclasm itself was largely a crisis of confidence in the face of Muslim depredations & immiseration. The continued belief in imperial legitimacy, that only the Emperor in Constantinople can rule, allowed political survival. This was largely thanks to a centralized tax system & Constantinople’s size/impregnability. Image
Oct 17, 2023 25 tweets 9 min read
In Autumn 1116 AD, a dying Alexios Komnenos marched East.

The Turks were once again encroaching on lands he had dedicated his life to returning to the Empire.

The last major battle the Byzantines had fought against the Turks was 45 years ago & 600 miles East; Manzikert. Image In the decade of chaos following the battle of Manzikert, Byzantine rule in Anatolia was swept aside as the imperial government convulsed in coups & rebellions. The largely demilitarized population of W. Anatolia surrendered as resistance continued in the better-prepared East. Image
Sep 18, 2023 20 tweets 9 min read
There is much debate on how to properly periodize the ~2,200 years of Roman history. I have created a system that I believe works well:

Kingdom (753-509 BC)
Republic:
Early (509-264 BC)
Middle (264-146 BC)
Late (146-27 BC)
Principate (27 BC-235 AD)
Crisis of 3rd Century (235-284 AD)
Dominate (284-602 AD)
Crisis of 7th Century (602-718 AD)
Basilean/Byzantine:
Early (718-867 AD)
Middle (867-1081 AD)
Late (1081-1204 AD)
Interregnum (1204-1261 AD)
Despotate/Palaiologan (1204-1453AD)

Let me explain my reasoning…
Traditional periodization of the Roman State has revolved around political changes, largely the form of government. The use of Kingdom/Republic/Empire(Principate/Dominate) is common and largely uncontroversial. I’ve extended this to 1453 AD. Here’s how I characterize each period. Image
Sep 14, 2023 7 tweets 3 min read
I don’t think any other empire has been able to match the Assyrians for their gruesome & terrible proclamations of victory. They sound almost like something an evil alien invader would say in a bad science fiction. Image “I rained destruction upon them. I scattered their corpses far and wide, filled the face of the desolate plain with their widespreading armies. With weapons I made their blood to flow down the valleys of the land. The plain was too small to let their bodies fall, the wide countryside was used up in burying them. With their bodies I spanned the Arantu as with a bridge. In that battle I took from them their chariots, their cavalry, their horses, broken to the yoke.”
Image
Sep 14, 2023 9 tweets 4 min read
This hill is not natural, it is the byproduct of thousands of years of human settlement.

A thread on tells. Image Primarily found throughout the Fertile Crescent, tells rise from the flat floodplains like small mesas, distinct for their low sloping sides and flat tops. The first residents of these places lived in agricultural communities & towns at the same level as the surrounding area. Image
Sep 7, 2023 19 tweets 7 min read
Once on the shores of the wine-dark Euxine, reaving Vikings established a foothold among the Slavic tribes. These men fought for control of the trade routes of the area, adopted Christianity, & were ruled by a Khagan in the steppe fashion.

A thread on the Rus Khaganate. Image A Norse Khagan ruling on the gateway to the steppes, ranging at the head of an armada across the open seas instead of the grass oceans of Eurasia seems too curious to be true & although still shrouded in mystery, the Rus Khaganate is not without precedence. Image
Aug 9, 2023 29 tweets 11 min read
2,240 years ago, Hannibal Barca met the Roman army on the plains near Cannae.

Outnumbered & deep behind enemy lines, Hannibal displayed his unmatched tactical genius, annihilating the Roman army at the bloodiest day in military history until World War One. Image In the 3rd Century BC, the dominant Carthaginians & the rising Roman Republic fought a series of wars for control of the Western Mediterranean. This titanic struggle, named The Punic Wars, spanned decades & set Rome on the path to superpower status. Image
Aug 4, 2023 26 tweets 10 min read
Did you know The Last Samurai is based on a true story?

A thread on the incredible life & adventures of the real “Last Samurai;” Jules Brunet. Image Jules Brunet was born in Alsace, France in 1838. His father was a veterinary doctor in the army. Jules followed in his father’s footsteps & joined the French Army in 1855, attending the prestigious Saint-Cyr & École Polytechnique. Image
Jul 26, 2023 9 tweets 3 min read
“Three centuries before, it was the Goths who had been a turbulent unruly aristocracy, ruling a nation of serfs, and the Saracen had swept their monarchy off the face of the earth in two years. Now the Moslem had become even as his Gothic predecessor… Image Luxurious, proud, untrue to his king, a hard master to the peasantry who paid him toll and tribute. Religious persecution was not rare, & Andalusia could count many martyrs; the accusation of having blasphemed the name of Mohammed always stirred the Moslem crowd to sudden cruelty Image
Jul 19, 2023 26 tweets 10 min read
In 711 AD a Muslim army landed on Gibraltar.

Within a few years Islam seemed destined to absorb Iberia…

However, one holdout remained in the mountains of the North. The survival of Christian Iberia fell to a few warriors. Or, as the Muslims described them; “30 wild donkeys.” By Augusto Ferrer-Dalmau In the preceding decades the armies of Islam had swept across North Africa meeting little resistance. The Amazigh population readily adopted this new faith, the Bedouin ethos meshing well with that of the hill tribes of the Atlas Mountains & herders of the scrublands. Image
Jul 5, 2023 25 tweets 9 min read
The Byzantine Empire experienced both eddying heights & devastating catastrophes in the 11th century, what is the reason for this?

The inability to solve the security predicament of their geopolitical situation.

Was this rise & fall inevitable or could it have been prevented? With the fading of Arab raids in the 10th century, the Byzantines conquered the Muslim Emirates near their borders. This was a strategic imperative to make the core of the empire safe & now possible with the breakdown of the Caliphate.
Jun 30, 2023 14 tweets 4 min read
Some criticize the Byzantine Empire for failing to “Romanize” the lands it conquered from 934-1045 AD. However, there simply weren’t enough “Romans.” Arab depredations during the preceding 300 years had depopulated much of Anatolia. People first came down from their troglodyte villages & resettled the productive plains. Some paleoenvironmental evidence is now emerging regarding this process in Cappadocia specifically. journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.117…
Jun 29, 2023 4 tweets 2 min read
A poignant excerpt from Toynbee; the haughty exploits of the conqueror often weaken his power & his bloody acts are repaid in kind by other peoples.

Toynbee mentions that many of those under the Assyrian yoke survived better than their erstwhile masters. Shelley’s Ozymandias really captures the desolate remains of this vanished empire.
Jun 28, 2023 12 tweets 5 min read
A generation after the disaster at Pliska, war again loomed over the Haemus Mountains.

During these preparations a secret embassy arrived in the capital, imploring Emperor Theophilos for his help.

The Emperor accepted & initiated one of the greatest rescue missions in history. After crushing the Byzantines at Pliska, killing Emperor Nikephoros I, & famously turning his skull into a chalice, Khan Krum extended his Empire south into Byzantine territory. Integrating these Byzantines into the Bulgarian state was a key priority for the Khan.
Jun 16, 2023 9 tweets 3 min read
Roman adoption of a slave plantation economic model can be traced back to the Punic Wars & the acquisition of Sicily & its fertile land.

This would prove seriously damaging to Rome’s Republican institutions & perhaps surprisingly, was an artifact of the Carthaginian Empire. Image An earlier thread talked about how the Punic Wars kicked off a vicious cycle of slave labor, military professionalization, and the impoverishment of citizens but the economic model that made this possible could have also been a poisoned chalice from Carthage herself.