🧵 1/
People wonder why clothing changed so much between the early 20th century and now...Or why people would ever dress "So formally"
What people don't realize is how much lifestyles have changed in that time
2/
Early 20th century people walked Everywhere. In all weather.
And there was unlikely to be much climate control one way or the other when they got there.
Outfits in the 40s and before were designed so you could walk 10 miles in them in November, + pockets for all you need
3/
Cars were a recent curiosity that most didn't have and could not yet be relied upon consistently... As late as the 40s the Wehrmacht built its logistics around horses, and as late as the 1960s! horses were used in northern regions where winter made roads impassible
4/
In addition to the cold, The summer sun could cause serious sun burns in an era before sunblock.
Old timey swimsuits were not artifacts of prudishness, but self preservation
5/
Thus the significance of hats before modern transportation.
They would protect one from the sun, provide shelter in rain, and prevent heat loss to the cold and wind
6/
This blend of everyday fashion with the rigors of hard outdoor travel are almost entirely gone.
The only remain artifacts are hiking outfits
7/
And military kit
8/
Neither of which are designed to seamlessly transition to the Office or Church once you arrive after your 5-10km walk there
9/
Yet this style of outfit remains the apex of tasteful fashion
Rather than being archaic this blend of style and function has become more fashionable in our era.
10/
In Christmas Classic Its a Wonderful Life George Bailey is supposed to be on the edge of destitution... About to end his life over a sum of 8000 dollars ($132,000 inflation adjusted)
This is how a he dresses day to day
11/
A barely middle-class man on the edge of ruin from the 1940s looks exquisite today...
Largely because he's not fallen into the inherent slovenliness that marks modern clothing, that makes everyone look barely dressed, because they are.
12/
One cannot look put together if one is not dressed sufficiently to conduct oneself or merely survive a full 8 hours outside.
This is why even nice summer outfits wind up focused on layers and hats... that's what you need to survive if you're staying outside
13/
Much as many might like to dismiss fashion as pointless style over substance...
More often than not its the substance that creates the style.
Yet our fashion designers are obsessed with creating the opposite
14/
Thus why we live in one of the ugliest ages of fashion.
The car and climate control has deprived us of the need for any substantive quality in our clothing...
That is until they break down
15/
Growing up in Canada, My parents would always admonish me if I drove off or left home improperly dressed or without a coat...
In my mind the 1 minute winter chill getting to the car, then the store once the car was parked didn't demand a whole lot
16/ But the point wasn't to be dressed for what one planned to do, it was to be dressed for what one might have to do, like unstuck a car
This is why casual fashion is a contradiction. Good fashion equips you for the world. If you're ill-equipped you'll look Ill dressed
PS. I write things!
Checkout my piece on Motorcycles, evading IR, and the Future of Irregular Warfare
Tolkien is capeshit wearing the skinsuit of the Anglo-Saxon tradition.
Contrast Beowulf, Le Morte De Arthur, the Germanic Eddas, the Odyssey, The Aeneid... And you can see none of the structure or values or the stories are at all comparable. Tolkien never wrote a single revenge cycle.
But rather his values and stories resemble nothing so much as Modern Marvel movies.
A sexless world of Eternal Children and equally sexless bearded men, with no meaningful desires except for trinkets and Macguffins meant to show their virtues are sins and they should have had no desires at all... and villains who when not faceless beasts and disposable vermin, have committed the crime of... Wanting something.
Not a single one of his heroes has a rivalry or hatred of any of his villains, and certainly nothing familial, personal, or romantic such as is the case of every classical and anglo-saxon story.
One wonders why Gandalf went to Bilbo at all... So Bilbo could find a wife? Found a new hobbit Kingdom with his fortune? Avert some terrible destiny? Slay an enemy or rival?
No! So he could just come home and do nothing for another 50+ years.
For all the shit GRRM rightly gets for Game of Thrones devolving into feminist/social justice anti-narrative and plodding hopeless misery (Name any children BORN during A Song of Ice and Fire and the war of 5 kings who live? Indeed it contradicts his own worldbuilding, since half the cast was born or married and formed families as a direct result of the earlier Robert's rebellion)... inspite of all that Game of Thrones is far CLOSER to traditional western storytelling and values, with named characters with families and hopes and dreams, and lusts and rivalries and children and revenge cycles on all sides.
By contrast Tolkien, very uniquely even by the standards of the 40s and 50s, creates a sexless world where pretty much no one has families, romances, lusts, hopes, desires, etc. Save some abstract desire to "Save the world" or "defeat evil"
Name a single Tolkien Character who has a significant Relationship with their father, mother, or wife?
The only exception is Denathor... Ie. A Mad King to be overcome. Arwen doesn't even appear in the main text of the books
But what about...
Are you going to reference something published by JRR Tolkien? Or Christopher Tolkien?
I agree Christopher Tolkien was vastly more in touch with the Western Tradition than his father.
Hanania makes Casey Affleck at the start of "Assassination of Jesse James" seem normal and well adjusted
There is something deeply wrong with any figure who decide to interact with him and pretend the most unsettling thing ever seen isn't happening right in front of them
Every inflection is wrong, every muscle spasm, every lip movement, every reaction, every part of his face that's unusually plump, smooth, and youthful, or that's strangely aged, worn, & thin
Every part of him is disingenuous, faking something human or concealing something alien
he's 39... Yet not a single trait of him is 39... He combines the most bizzare traits of an autistic 10 year old and 90 year old jewish woman... As much an age that has never existed before as Madonna post-plastic surgery.
Young white men are so damned close to terror and ethnic cleansing it is unreal.
Having every rule rigged against them, their every institution betray them, and then called losers by the people their tax dollars subsidize and the boomers their childhood suffering gave peace to
That a full moratorium on all immigration for 15 years and complete repeal of the 1964 civil right isn't the opening bid, is a the sign we're headed to hot civil war.
An entire generation of boys sees Hitler as the only figure in history who didn't want them enslaved and killed
I will ask @ThomasEWoods and @BobMurphyEcon who for some reason are defending Elon and Vivek.
Why do you want you children enslaved, immiserated, disenfranchised in their homeland, reduced to a minority, and inevitably killed by ethnic enemies?