In today's #vatniksoup we'll visit Germany for the first time, as I introduce a Russo-German "journalist" and propagandist, Alina Lipp. She's best-known for her pro-Russian TG channel "Neues aus Russland" ("News from Russia") where she spreads propaganda and disinformation.
1/20
In her previous life she studied sustainable governance at the Leuphana University Lüneburg, focusing on environmental studies. Lipp was involved in German politics as a member of the Greens party, but at some point suggested that they were too "anti-Russian" for her.
2/20
Lipp's mother is German and father is Russian. According to Alina, her father told him the truth about the Russo-Ukrainian conflict around 2014, after the Revolution of Dignity and after Russia annexed Crimea.
3/20
After the annexation, she actually travelled to Crimea and started a YouTube channel called "Glücklich auf der Krim" ("Happy in Crimea").
I consider Lipp to be a part of the group of "relatively attractive, young women who do pro-Kremlin propaganda" along with people...
4/20
...like Mira Terada, Maria Butina, Liubov Sivaya and Anna Chapman. Their job is to show everything Russia does in a good light and constantly criticize the West and Ukraine. They have all now relocated to Russia or to areas that Russia occupies illegally.
5/20
In an Orwellian way, she calls herself a "peace journalist". At some point she started reporting from Donbas, where she often complained how badly the civilians are doing due to "Ukrainian shelling". She's stated that in most, if not all, cases Ukraine "fired first".
6/20
In Jan, 2022, she was part of the big group claiming that Russia does not want war and is a peaceful country. On 16 Feb, 2022, she was visiting a conference called "Geopolitical war of the West against Russia: the Ukrainian case" in Russia.
7/20
At the end of Feb, 2022, she reasoned that the "special military operation" was necessary due to the "genocide" of Russian-speaking population in Donbas by the Ukrainian "Nazi regime". Based on Lipp, Putin doesn't kill civilians and actually "saves lives".
8/20
As of today, her "Neues aus Russland" is one of the biggest pro-Russian Telegram channels (and definitely the biggest one in German) with over 185 000 subscribers. Most of its content is naturally just parroting of the most popular Kremlin narratives.
9/20
She's spread (fake) horror stories of "Ukrainian organ trade" and refuted Russian bombing of kindergarten. She's claimed that it was actually the Ukrainians who bombed the Mariupol theater with children and women inside.
10/20
She's also downplayed the number of civilian casualties, spicing it up with an image from Russian music video where a "corpse" moves inside a body bag. This same video was shared during the COVID-19 pandemic, claiming that it was actually a hoax "plandemic".
11/20
Lipp uses this method a lot: she often posts debunked or fake videos from various contexts, usually from Russia. Sometimes she deletes her posts after someone points out the truth, sometimes she doesn't.
12/20
Now there can be two explanations for her actions: she is either a) willingly spreading debunked disinformation, or b) gullible and naive. I honestly don't know which one of these is worse.
13/20
In Nov, 2022, she was guest at the Forum of International Friends of Crimea held at the Russian Foreign Ministry in Moscow. There she even gave an empowered speech in support to Russian troops that she claims are now "fighting against NATO".
14/20
Her website is still very active, and her latest blog post and video on Donbas is from 6 Mar, 2023. In the first part she explained how Ukrainians "terrorize" Donbas and in this second edition she interviews pro-Putin actors about these "terrors".
15/20
She's even tried to do some comedy, but as we all know that Germans and humor are usually not a very good mix (just kidding). In a video she published on her website she played the German minister for foreign affairs, Annalena Baerbock.
16/20
German government has stated they are investigating Lipp's propaganda activities in Ukraine, and she may face up to three years in prison. The accusations were especially about the "genocide in Donbas" narrative, which have been proven to be a lie on many occasions.
17/20
All this information came from Lipp herself, so it should be taken with a grain of salt. In Germany, hate speech is still very much against the law and the authorities are simply following these laws, but it has become a very effective propaganda weapon against the West...
18/20
...for all pro-Russian actors, including Alina herself. But even if she was sentenced to prison for 3 years (which I REALLY doubt), that would still be 5 years less than what the Russian opposition leader Ilya Yashin got for discussing over the Bucha massacre.
19/20
Interestingly, most of her channels and her website don't contain any ads (or perhaps they've been demonetized), so in theory it is unclear how Lipp makes a living.
And a little dessert: Alina's little propaganda event in Berlin was cancelled by @BrotfabrikBln after they received more information on the nature of her work.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
In today's #vatnik soup, I'll introduce a Spanish-Russian "journalist" & political scientist,Liubov "Liu" Sivaya (@liusivaya). She's best-known for her YouTube channel where she spreads pro-Kremlin narratives and denies war crimes conducted by the Russian military for money.
1/18
I consider Sivaya to be a part of the group of "relatively attractive, young women who do pro-Kremlin propaganda" along with people like Mira Terada, Maria Butina, Alina Lipp and Anna Chapman.
She'll probably join some Prigozhin-run propaganda committee in the near future.
2/18
Sivaya has lived in Spain for 10 years, and she's claimed and received Spanish citizenship, and on occasion she has exhibited both passports online in order to defend herself from critics, whilst being fully aware that Spain does not allow double citizenship with Russia.
In today's #vatniksoup I'll be talking about genocide, children and national trauma. Throughout the 20th century, both in the Soviet Union and in Russia children have been suffering because of bad politics and structural negligence & now the kidnapped children face the same.
1/17
Last November I wrote about the genocide that Russia is conducting in Ukraine through forced abductions of children, cultural appropriation and outright mass killing of civilians:
It's not the first time they have done this, however, as the Soviet leaders killed 3,5 - 5 million Ukrainians through organized famine referred to as Holodomor. 1,7 million children died as a result of this horrible event.
In today's #vatniksoup I'll introduce an American academic, political scientist and Quincy Institute author, Max Abrahms (@MaxAbrahms). He's best-known for his pro-Russian and pro-Syrian views, and especially for trying to fit them into an academic framework.
1/15
On 7 Mar, 2023, @TheAtlantic published an op-ed titled "I Teach International Relations. I Think We’re Making a Mistake in Ukraine" written by Abrahms. You rarely see op-ed titles with this much of self-satisfaction,but we'll let that slide - let's take a look at the content.2/15
His article clearly is an attempt to create a "scholarly perspective" on the war in Ukraine. He's suggesting that if the West wants to help Ukraine, it should actually STOP the military & weapons aid, and that the US is provoking Russian aggression by sending weapons to 🇺🇦.
In today's #vatniksoup I'll introduce an Austrian diplomat, journalist and politician Karin Kneissl. She's best-known for serving as Austria's Minister of Foreign Affairs, blogging for RT, and being in the supervisory board of Russian integrated energy company, Rosneft.
1/18
In her youth Karin was active in Amnesty International and supported environmental efforts and human rights activism worldwide. She studied international relations in Jerusalem and in Amman, subsequently earning her PhD in international law in 1992.
2/18
Between 1990-1998 she worked as a diplomat in the cabinet of ÖVP. She left the diplomatic service after this & got more involved in politics.She's said that she was involved in founding of the Austrian section of Médecins Sans Frontières,but the organization has denied this.
3/18
In today's #vatniksoup we'll do our first trip to Italy as I introduce an Italian politician and Deputy Prime Minister of Italy, Matteo Salvini (@matteosalvinimi). He's best-known for his Russia-related funding scandals, and for his Euroskeptic and pro-Putin views.
1/16
Matteo joined a right-wing populist party, Lega Nord in 1990. He was active member of the party, and in 1997 he started writing for their official newspaper, La Padania. He's been registered as a journalist on the list of Italian professional journalists since 2003.
2/16
Some have described Salvini as one of the main leaders of the populist wave in Europe during the 2010s, after Putin's "economic war" took a hold of many European countries, and his anti-immigration views gained a lot of popularity and traction.
In today's #vatniksoup I'm going to be talking about the most dangerous profession in Russia: journalism. Many investigative journalists have sacrificed their lives to shed light into corruption, kleptocracy and war crimes committed in both Soviet Union and in Russia.
1/24
Journalists working in Russia and not toeing the Kremlin line live under constant threat of being attacked, stigmatized as "foreign agents", or even killed. Partly for this reason, as of 2022, Russia ranks 155 out of 180 countries in the Press Freedom Index.
2/24
As the Soviet Union and Russia were and can be dangerous places, many journalists have died as a result of their work, for example in crossfire incidents and purely criminal or domestic cases of manslaughter. But many of them have also been targeted by contract killings,...