Thread by @DiscordIslam

📖"Sunni" scholar's plagiarism of the Promised Messiah AS

"Hakīm al-Ummah" Ashraf Ali al-Tahānwī (Thanvi), a renowned "Sunni" scholar, copied the works of the Promised Messiah AS, word for word, pages upon pages, innumerable times without citation. 1/

https://twitter.com/D1mashqi/status/1634117092868866049

List of Books/Texts of the Promised Messiah AS that Thanvi plagiarized from:
1. Philosophy of the Teachings of Islam - 1905
2. Barakatud Dua - 1903
3. Naseem e Dawat - 1903
4. Arya Dharam - 1895
5. Noah’s Ark - 1902
6. Al-Hakam January 23, 1899

Ashraf Thanwi's copy-paste book was 'Ahkam-e-Islam Aqal Ki Nazar Main'. Written in 1334 AH (1915) republished in the computerized format in 2009. Thanwi also plagiarized Maulānā Ḥakīm Nūrudīn al-RA through Maulvi Fazal Khan Changawi.

The following will be a list of examples of clear-cut plagiarism of Ashraf Thanwi on the books of the Promised Messiah(AS)

Example 1:
The Philosophy of the Teachings of Islam Page 338
Ahkam-e-Islam Aql Ki Nazar Mein pages 205-206

Example 2:
Barakatud Dua Pages 7-8
Ahkam-e-Islam Aql Ki Nazar Mein page 87

Example 3:
Arya Dharam Pages 37,38, and 39
Ahkam-e-Islam Aqal Ki Nazar Main, Pages 161-162

Example 4:
Barakatud Dua, Pages 11-12
Ahkam-e-Islam Aqal Ki Nazar Main, Page 88

Example 5:
Arya Dharam Pages 22-23
Ahkam-e-Islam Aqal Ki Nazar Main, Pages 140-141

Example 6:
Kishti-e-Nuh(Noah's Ark), Pages 69-70
Ahkam-e-Islam Aqal Ki Nazar Main, Pages 50, 51, and 52

Example 7:
Naseem e Dawat Pages 436-438
Ahkam-e-Islam Aqal Ki Nazar Main, Pages 224-226

Example 8:
Al-Hakam January 23, 1899 pages 2-3
Ahkam-e-Islam Aql ki Nazar mein pages 262-265

What is ironic about this plagiarism instance is that after copying a ton of Promised Messiah AS's words, Thanwi will change one word to a synonym. The red underline represents this...

...For example, Thanwi changed "Sadaqato" meaning "Truth" to 'Haqiaq'/'Haqeeqat' which also means "Truth". A poor attempt to cover up the fact that he had stolen the entire word-to-word paragraph before and after.

Not only did Ashraf Thanwi copy from the Promised Messiah AS, Maulānā Ḥakīm Nūrudīn RA, but he also copied other companions of the Promised Messiah such as Maulvi Muhammad Ali. Maulvi Fazal Khan Changawi quoted Maulvi Muhammad Ali in his book Asrar-e-Shariat...

However, Thanwi copied the entire passage with no credit. This plagiarism of Asrar-e-Shariat has been highlighted in a book that displays instances of Urdu Plagiarism.

Example 8:
Asrar-e-Shariat Volume 2 Baab Kitab ar-raq page 265
Ahkam-e-Islam Aql Mein Nazar Main pg 187-188

There are many more instances of Thanwi plagiarizing Promised Messiah AS and other Ahmadis however for now this seems to be sufficient.

It is quite strange how Ashraf Thanwi was plagiarizing the books of the Promised Messiah AS even when he had declared him a non-muslim.

The Deobandis have no choice but to admit to the greatness of the Promised Messiah AS as their Wajib ul Taqlid Imam copied from him.

The true Hakīm al-Ummah is not Mufti Yaar Khan Na'eemi of the Barelvis or Ashraf Thanwi but rather Maulānā Ḥakīm Nūrudīn al-Bhairawī RA