The U.S. can stop Tunisia's descent into full-blown dictatorship. Here's how. The practical steps I lay out in this @ForeignAffairs article are actually things the Biden administration can do. But it has to do them now.
Often people mention Tunisia's still-pending IMF bailout in passing, but no one has really laid out in detail how using the loan as leverage might actually work. There are risks, which I acknowledge in the piece. But on balance this is the best (and likely last) option available.
Yes it's unlikely. But institutions are made up of individuals who have agency. And it's possible that enough people in the State Department and the White House might wake up and at least consider putting brakes on the IMF deal. It's doable.
There are two modes of think tank research. One is to accept the constraints of U.S. policy and work within them. The other mode is to push hard against the status quo and try to change the terms of debate. Why should we settle for tinkering around the margins of a failed policy?
We have a brief window to change the policy conversation on Tunisia. The window will likely close in the matter of weeks. So please share this piece far and wide with anyone who works on the Middle East, particularly in government.
This is probably the 5th time I've read the Khomeini interview and it never gets old. There are so many howlers. You almost get a Trumpian vibe from Khomeini in these moments, a kind of post-modern playfulness and looseness with observed reality.
Like, at this point, Khomeini is just messing with us. It's performance art of the highest level.
In some ways, cancel culture was worse after 9/11. And the implications for U.S. policy were nothing short of disastrous. Be careful what you wish for. The post-Trump era, as bad and polarized as it might seem, is far preferable to recent alternatives. shadihamid.substack.com/p/reading-sayy…
People complain about the "youth" a lot, including me. And on certain things the trend lines are pretty discouraging. On the other hand, when it comes to topics like the legacy of Sayyid Qutb, they feel empowered to write in a much more nuanced way.
I kind of love how my students apply concepts like "lived experience" to Sayyid Qutb. They have a point. In a culture that valorizes victimhood, it's fair to say that Qutb had some pretty real grievances. After all, he was tortured, executed and lived under an actual dictatorship
I had forgotten there was a large number of liberals obsessed with using the word “fascist” as a catch-all epithet. I wasn’t online as much, and I generally try to avoid following the news, for reasons @SarahTheHaider helpfully explains here: sarahhaider.substack.com/p/the-news-is-…
Many of you probably are inclined to think the worst of me. Because let's be honest, that what you *want* to do. It feels good to to find someone ostensibly on the left, particularly if they're brown, and declare your moral superiority over them.
The category of religion was created and weaponized for particular purposes. Like all belief systems, liberalism and nationalism require their own foundational myths.
With 9/11 and its aftermath, liberalism found an enemy against which to define itself—an Islam that was untamed, illiberal, and resistant to progress. Respectable observers tried to distinguish between Islam and "radical Islam" but this was easier said than done.
This was a lot of fun. We discussed Biden's classified docs, the professor fired over an image of Prophet Mohamed, Andrew Tate's conversion to Islam, and raw milk 👇🏽 open.spotify.com/episode/480YRG…
As I discuss here, the painting of the Prophet the professor got fired for depicts the beginning of the Islamic revelation when the Angel Gabriel says to Mohamed, ‘recite.’ It’s a powerful moment in the Islamic tradition. So how could it be Islamophobic?
If anything, the "offensive" image of the Prophet Mohamed is Islamophilic, not Islamophobic. It's a painting that honors the Prophet and beautifully captures one of the founding moments of Islam.
In this clip, I try to sum up the failures of US policy in the Middle East. It's a structural problem. And to solve it, US policymakers will need to commit to an entirely different way of looking at the region.
Full conversation 👉🏽
I also talk to @feyzasays about the myth of authoritarian stability: autocratic regimes seem stable until they're not—and then it's too late. Moreover, "pro-American" Arab autocrats aren't even reliable. Case in point Saudi Arabia.
If we're going to prop up repressive regimes, we might as well get something in return. But we don't even get that. After Biden tried to make nice with MBS in last summer's photo-op, MBS went out of his way to engineer an *increase* in oil prices.