We've got another Dominion slide deck from its March 21 hearing.
Interesting tidbits follow.
The Fox News Decision Team sent a memo to "Those Concerned" on November 3, 2020, laying out how many states with early Trump leads in the early hours would subsequently shift to Biden which "does NOT mean that there are problems with the integrity of the vote count."
In this 11/11/20 email -- previously redacted -- Fox CEO Suzanne Scott says that after Fox's Arizona call for Biden "A trust has been broken and it's our jobs to help them through this to the other side ...and certainly speaking to the audience with respect is critical."
Jeanine Pirro's executive producer re: her 11/21/20 show (which was filled with Dominion lies): "She is refusing to drastically change the open despite the fact check."
Executive overseeing show: "Understood."
Mystery solved: Eric Trump emailed Sean Hannity asking him to help after "someone at Fox denied DJT's newest campaign ad" and he cc'd Murdoch calling it "above my pay grade."
In January 2021, Fox executive producer Justin Wells said he suggested booking Megyn Kelly but "Rupert and Lachlan are a hard no."
11/20/20 emails between Suzanne Scott and Rupert Murdoch about firing Bill Sammon and Chris Stirewalt (or as Rupert called him, "the other guy").
Previously redacted 11/6/20 Rupert-to-Scott email: It would be great if we call it for Biden as soon as he gets over, say, 35,000 ahead in Pennsylvania. Whenever we do it it will all be over. Regardless of Arizona."
In a follow-up expressing "second thoughts," he told her "Maybe 50,000 in Pennsylvania and subject to litigation."
From a previously redacted October 2020 memo from Raj Shah about Tucker Carlson Tonight: "Framing any and all policy announcements as 'socialism' and taken from an AOC-Bernie Sanders playbook will likely animate Tucker's core audience."
Raj Shah, discussing internal data re: Tucker viewers, cites a "Concern that Tucker may take the info on affirmative action/diversity/inclusion as a green light from
corporate to go harder at the issue when he's already devoting tons of programming time to it."
Previously redacted quotes from a Raj Shah memo to Lachlan Murdoch on 11/13/20: "Fox News is facing a brand crisis... open revolt... precipitous decline in Fox's favorability among our core audience... poses lasting damage to the Fox News brand unless effectively addressed soon."
Previously redacted Fox internal memo on "Instances of Talent Support for the 'Stolen Election' Narrative" with "break outs for Mark Levin, Newt Gingrich, and Gregg Jarrett."
That's it for now.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Does Florida under DeSantis have a particularly distinguished record in crime reduction?
I'm asking because the question isn't answered by this long New York Times report telegraphing a DeSantis attack on Trump as "soft on crime." nytimes.com/2023/03/29/us/…
Two true statements:
1) Crime data is notoriously difficult to grapple with, many factors go into its rises and falls.
2) Crime went up under Trump and is going back down under Biden.
Assessing DeSantis' record might be particularly difficult because "Florida and California had the lowest percentages of law enforcement agencies turning over crime data to the FBI last year." axios.com/2022/11/26/flo…
Media Matters has obtained a slide deck that Dominion lawyers used at a March 28 hearing in the Fox defamation lawsuit.
I'll be sharing some takeaways here.
In an email, Fox CEO Suzanne Scott responds to Fox's Eric Shawn fact-checking a Trump falsehood: "This has to stop now... this is bad business... the audience is furious and we are just feeding them material."
Here's a Maria Bartiromo email from November 7 in which she says that "We have to go to a full on war. They have used all systems to defraud." And adds that "Jared says he doesn't want to hear about any conspiracy theory."
Fox's advertiser upfront pitch includes Jeanine Pirro, who was taken off the air following the 2020 election because execs thought she would promote election conspiracy theories, then brought back for segments Dominion is suing over in their lawsuit. mediamatters.org/fox-news/fox-p…
Fox executives do not think they did anything wrong after the 2020 election and they only thing they plan to do differently going forward is curtail accidental truth-telling.
What Fox advertisers are actually paying for is a propaganda channel that tries to elect Republicans -- it's not just me saying that, it's Rupert Murdoch! mediamatters.org/foxdominion-la…
I can't tell if this is happening more frequently or if I'm just noticing it more often, but I don't love the argument strategy where people criticize a policy initiative aimed at a specific problem because it wouldn't solve a broader, more complex social ill.
Ex: Forcing TikTok's sale won't fix "disinformation" or "social media." True! But it seems like a fix for the discrete problem of "the Chinese government can control TikTok." If you don't think that's a problem, or don't think that would solve it, argue that.
Ex: Keeping people from smoking fentanyl on public transit won't solve drug addition or homelessness -- but the point is solving the narrow problem of "people won't use public services if they don't feel safe."
Got some bad news for Republican leadership — even if their dumbest members shut up and stay off TV, the party’s infotainers will still be telling its base that SVB collapsed because it was too “woke.”
Also it’s not like this argument is exclusive to uninformed backbenchers — this is the chairman leading the GOP’s investigations!
The right's culture war obsession has totally swamped its interest in policy -- you can see this starting in the beginning of the Biden administration, when the attack on Biden's $1.9 trillion stimulus proposal was that .06% went to "social justice stuff" mediamatters.org/coronavirus-co…
Tucker Carlson's Newsmax competitors have devoted nearly 7 times (!) as much coverage as his Fox colleagues to his Jan. 6 footage. mediamatters.org/fox-news/newsm…
The rest of Fox has devoted 32 minutes to Tucker's Jan. 6 revisionism.
Major shows like Hannity, Fox & Friends, and The Five have totally ignored it.
Newsmax has given it... 3 hours 34 minutes, across 18 different shows.
Newsmax often tries to lure viewers away from Fox by attacking it from the right.
In this case, it appears to be leveraging Carlson’s hero status among Trumpists – and even using his own network’s unwillingness to promote his shoddy work to suggest that Fox is being dishonest.