Nina Vallins Profile picture
Apr 20, 2023 30 tweets 10 min read Read on X
"A special meeting of the party’s ruling state council on Thursday is expected to wave through sweeping changes to the party’s code of conduct, codifying a nine-point definition of transphobia. Plenty of allegations of transgressions are expected to follow."...🧵
#greensarecooked
As @noeltowell predicts, there will be lots of Greens doing a transphobia if the amendment is passed. Saying trans rights conflict with women's? That's a transphobia! Want restrictions on child transition? Transphobic bigot! Asking questions?!? You're doing a genocide. Image
We are literally killing our planet every fucking day. “The party has become a hotbed of authoritarianism and members are too afraid to speak in meetings for fear of retribution,” *anon said. “I can’t even remember the last time the state council discussed climate change.”
No comment from @SamanthaRatnam of course. And @AdamBandt declared his hand recently, in favour of "no debate" and misogyny.
The Greens? No longer. The Regressive Pink and Blues.
This is The Haven System, who's so worried about transphobia in the Greens - also a Nazi and paedophile sympathiser.

#greensarecooked
Here is the current proposal. Note change to (c). Image
this is bullshit. I'll never forget when Haven casually admitted to having sexually assaulted a girl in high school. He said it like it was youthful mistake that we all make and so we should be sympathetic to all the young rapey men causing optical probs for the Greens... No dude Image
In 2020, I was suspended from the Greens for vilification of transgender people and bringing the party into disrepute (like how John Setka brought the CFMEU into disrepute; I seriously affected the public opinion of the Greens, even though basically no one has ever heard of me..)
Doing a transphobia #1: calling for safe spaces for women, and differentiating between women and "male-bodied people": theaustralian.com.au/nation/feminis… Image
Doing a transphobia #2: calling for women's voices to be heard! on matters that affect them! rather than just cede spaces to men!
(Greens position of course is NO DEBATE.)
theguardian.com/australia-news… Image
Doing a transphobia #3: Again, calling for women's spaces; and saying that disagreement is fine and does not create "unsafety". ImageImage
full article here: sbs.com.au/news/article/v…
If that was enough to get me suspended in 2020, what will happen now, with the new amendments to the Greens code of conduct? What will happen to a political party which bans "leading questions"? Watch as the Greens atrophy, shrouded in the sexist baby blue and pink flag.
This is the proposal (page 1) which was sent to State Council to define transphobia and the proposal which was actually passed. It defines all the conduct in (a)-(i) as conduct which harms or creates serious risk of harm to trans people. Like misgendering. Very harmful. ImageImage
The deranged mind of the Haven System (she/it) then wrote a 7-page Q&A to head off any of your doubts! Most normal people who read this pile of rubbish and want to turf the whole thing. Not the Greens! So let's see what the Greens signed off on...
The Greens are apparently a hot-bed of transphobia. Like, some trans members have even felt *uncomfortable.* Whoa. And if you don't think that transphobia is a problem in the Greens, you are a transphobe. Says a trans identified male, so he knows. Image
what about free speech?! Well, just like with racist speech, the Greens limit free speech so no diff here. Trans are the new black. Image
This amendment covers subtle forms of transphobia. Probably most people wouldn't even notice them. Image
WHAT ABOUT SEGREGATED SPACES? OMG, WIMMS, JUST GET OVER IT ALREADY. Obvs trans are the most oppressed, the only folx who need / deserve their own spaces, away from oppressors. For the normies, that means that men can come into women's spaces, but women don't get women only spaces Image
Also, "unintentional misgendering is harmful & always unacceptable & should be proscribed in the code of conduct." FYI Haven once said he kissed a girl without her consent but no big deal. But! a person mistakenly misgendering should be sanctioned. But he won't push it for now.
Also some bullshit about actual genders. Genders don't matter mate. Gender is not an axis of oppression. Sex is. You're not oppressed dude. Stop it.
SEX IS A LABEL THAT OVERSIMPLIFIES COMPLEX BIOLOGY INTO MALE/FEMALE.
OMG reality is just SO simplistic at times right? Why do reality when you could do a Butlerian performance? Amirite?
Actually, yes, sex is simple: there are two sexes. That's it. Image
Conversion practices are abusive indeed. Converting young gay kids or boring kids who are embarrassed for being yt oppressors and so need to queer up into trans or gender-diverse is abusive. Don't transition kids. They can't consent to it.
Giving puberty blockers to children should be outlawed. Greens members should be able to refer to the best evidence in the world, systematic studies from the UK, Sweden, Finland, to challenge the Greens policy. This code of conduct stops policy change. This is a party in failure.
oh dear goddess: no leading questions. The Greens are a political party who have just outlawed "leading questions." So if I were engaging in a contest of ideas in the Greens, I could no longer put forward a proposition which would challenge the listener to share my conclusion? Image
Will these rules get overapplies? Yes. @VictorianGreens will have a very busy misconduct panel. Image
Here are some helpful links to the intellectual poverty of the Greens and in opposition to doing a transphobia. Look at the branch meetings listed below and how many people actually attended in order to endorse putting proposal to State Council. Image
It was then passed by a State Council made up of 15 people. And that's the State of the Greens for ya.
This is what the Haven System is FYI. Image
I'd say that Sean Mulcahy and Haven are equal most effective trans activists in the Greens.
Haven says he has won the war on women, acknowledging he is a man who wages war on women. Remember he's the Nazi sympathiser who promotes incest and paedophilia. Still in the Greens! Image

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Nina Vallins

Nina Vallins Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @ninavallins

May 17, 2023
Spoiler: election results show that the "debate" faction has a blocking minority on @VictorianGreens State council, the party's governing body. The gender radical faction still has a majority, but the minority should stop them making extremely ridic decisions.
Thorough anaylsis from Guy Rundle: "The “gender” group wants, and has recently got, the state party to commit completely to the total “gender affirmation” model — you is whatever you say you is — ...
and to explicitly ban, and label as transphobic, any internal debate that questions whether categorisation by embodied sex (in state institutions such as hospitals or prisons, for example) should play a role in a more complex modelling of sex and gender in social life..."
Read 11 tweets
May 14, 2023
@VictorianGreens are very concerned about passing anti-vilification laws to protect trans people. People have been scared! And so this must be rushed through! @GabrielledeVie wants laws to protect gender, sexuality, HIV status or disability.
theage.com.au/politics/victo…
Do you see what's missing?
Yep. "Sex."
Oh, little women, why should you care about vilification and want a bit of that protection the Greens are proposing? Surely you wimms don't get vilified?
Let's look at how women are treated online...
Is it because 37% of women who had experienced online abuse or harassment said that on at least one occasion, these online experiences made them feel that their physical safety was threatened? (2018 survey)
Read 7 tweets
Mar 19, 2023
@MoiraDeemingMP is being misrepresented by @JohnPesutto as having links to neo-Nazis. Neo-Nazis stood 20 metres away from feminists (including me, a Jew): have we caught Nazism John? They were not amongst us. John you are a man seeking to silence women in the most repugnant way.
Read 4 tweets
Mar 19, 2023
I volunteered for Adam on all of his campaigns from 2007 - 2019 (not Lord Mayor campaign). I donated to his campaigns. I have looked after his dog and house-sat while he was on holidays.
He's lying. He knows I'm not anti-trans. He knows I'm Jewish and NOT PROTECTED BY NEO-NAZIS.
SHAME on you Adam for saying that Nazis are my allies. SHAME on you Adam for saying that radical feminists, women speaking up for women, women concerned about transitioning children, are the allies of Nazis. ...
You make participation in public society harder and less safe for women who know that there are two sexes and that children should not be transition.
YOU SILENCE WOMEN.
Read 4 tweets
Jul 31, 2021
i have always been a feminist. At 9, I complained at school because boys got the footy workshop with the AFL stars but girls didn't. Suffered my first sexual assault was at 10, which was formative. In my teens I changed 'He' to 'She' when I read from the prayer book at schule...
I learned at university that sex = biological categories, female and male. It's binary. That's how procreation happens. "Gender" is a social construct and collection of stereotypes which harms us all. Reject gender, I say: men cry! women play sport! boys play with dolls!...
girls climb trees! women don't have to marry, take their husband's name, have babies, and do all the emotional labour in relationships. Resist!
I was happy to accept transwomen as women because I thought they challenged gendered stereotypes - men can wear dresses and be...
Read 12 tweets
Jan 16, 2021
The Victorian #conversiontherapy (change or suppression practice) bill bans therapists from assisting 'heterosexual' people from exploring if they're homosexual bc all conduct aimed at changing a person's sexual orientation is banned. 😑 @LibertyVic @yourLIV why do you support?
@SamanthaRatnam will you vote for this bill when it comes to Parliament on 2 Feb?
@FionaPattenMLC will you support this terribly drafted bill? the unintended (but nevertheless obvious consequences) of this bill should give you pause and demand it go out to consultation.
Read 8 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us!

:(