TUCKER CARLSON, MARTIN LUTHER, & THE NEW MEDIA: a 🧵
Perhaps I’m the only one who sees @TuckerCarlson’s departure from @FoxNews as good news.
If I’m a Democrat strategist, I want him there so that I can, by applying pressure to Murdoch, at least control him a little….
2/
Carlson, for example, after an initial rollout of the #Jan6th tapes, went silent on the subject.
He also gave no coverage to @DineshDSouza’s 2000 Mules film which exposed massive election fraud. Perhaps these reflect Carlson’s own opinions, but one suspects he was…
3/
…receiving pressure from above.
In 1519, Martin Luther was invited to debates Papal representative Johann Eck, a ruthless rhetorician without scruples. Luther, still a naive academic, sought a fair hearing for his ideas. Eck’s goal was to label Luther a heretic.
When Eck…
4/
…asked Luther if he agreed with the ideas of John Hus—who was burned at the stake as a heretic—Luther, taking the question seriously rather than seeing the trap that it was, deliberated and said he agreed with many of Hus’s ideas.
Eck, replied that if Luther agreed…
5/
…with the heretic Hus, then Luther was a heretic.
In strictly debate terms, Luther lost. He left Leipzig shaken. Heretics were burned, and Luther now carried the label. But Leipzig was Pyrrhic victory for the Papacy.
To date, Luther had largely confined his criticism of…
6/
…the Papacy to the sale of indulgences. After the Leipzig Disputation (as it became known), however, Luther had nothing to lose. Henceforth, he’s let them know what he really thought, and the Protestant Reformation began in earnest.
Carlson isn’t Luther, but I think you…
7/
…get my point. Media has changed massively in the last decade, and with @elonmusk’s $44 billion Twitter purchase, it has changed yet more in just the last six months.
Carlson’s audience on Fox, the largest in cable television, averaged 3.5 million. @joerogan’s podcast…
8/
…averages 11 million per episode.
Carlson, now free and with nothing to lose, enters into those waters where his potential reach, and thus his influence, would dwarf that of cable television, a rapidly diminishing medium.
9/
Add to this that Musk is hinting that he intends to turn Twitter into a media platform that will challenge the space Instagram currently occupies.
So, don’t cry for Tucker Carlson. He can write his own ticket. This was the Left’s Pyrrhic victory and Fox’s suicide.
THE END
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
I watched the interview multiple times. Watch it. Cooper likes making sweeping, authoritative, controversial pronouncements with Trump-like self-assurance. Unless you’re a specialist, and Carlson isn’t, you might shrink from…
3.
…challenging him.
To wit:
• “Churchill was the chief villain of the Second World War.” (45:34ff)
• Holocaust caused by a logistical mistake and a desire to be “humane.” (46:40ff)
• Hitler wanted peace/Churchill wanted war (48:43ff)
Over the years I’ve heard stories about Laurence Olivier, Charleton Heston, Tony Blair, Judy Dench, Alice Cooper, Mick Jagger, Richard Harris, and many others.
But this is my favorite story.
A taxi driver tells me he picked up an old guy on London’s West End one evening…
3.
…outside of a pub. He doesn’t look in his rear view mirror very carefully, but nonetheless offers a bit of friendly chat chat to his passenger as he might do with anyone:
How are you?
Where to, sir?
Eventually he asks: “So, what do you do for a living?”
This is me filming in front of the US embassy in Mexico City last week.
These are all people trying to get into the US via the CBP One App—a program funded by you.
They didn’t want me filming. You’ll hear a Mexican security guard stop me and…
2/
…demand I delete the video.
I had been assured by Mexican lawyers that I could film anything so long as I did not enter the US embassy. As you can see, I did not enter.
The US uses a Mexican security firm outside the embassy and they had clearly been instructed to stop…
3.
…me. He spoke a mix of Spanish and English. I refused to give him my phone and, being much bigger than him, I did not let him detain me even though he tried.
He threatens to call the police. I kept walking while my translator distracted him.
As a guy who travels A LOT, I’m having a hard time with the fact that Tim Waltz has been in China 30+ times. It smells.
Let me explain to you how this works practically….
2.
China isn’t Canada. Meaning, there’s a visa process for Americans. It’s not visa-upon-arrival as in some Latin American countries. You must apply for entry. It takes time.
Communist states are historically suspicious of Americans, and for good reason. We seldom share…
3.
…their values. In the age of Google, which prioritizes negative results for conservatives, communist states make liberal use of the Leftist search engine.
For example, I slipped into Cuba a couple of years ago with a cigar tour group. The police came to our hotel to…
Yesterday @MattWalshBlog got dragged across Twitter concrete for his take on the #RNC platforming #AmberRose.
Judging from the responses, his critics didn’t read what he said, but instead read highly emotional takes on his tweet.
Let’s take a look:
2/18
After the tweet above, social media keyboard warriors sprang to Rose’s defense as if Walsh were her verbal assassin perched atop a sloped Twitter roof.
Catturd led the way.
Walsh was an “egomaniac,” he said, who had set himself up as “judge and jury.”
3/18
Heidi here unholstered her Twitter prose like a tiny secret service agent in Butler, PA, saying Rose had already done more for the cause than Walsh.
(NOTE: This is a weak argument I often see Christians employ against other Christians: “He’s done more for the Kingdom…
I saw the BBC doc that provoked @RealCandaceO’s absurd historical claims regarding “Allied ethnic cleansing” of Germans post-WW2.
I’ll record an episode of “Ideas Have Consequences” to address this. But first, a🧵to help you decipher it:
2/
The documentary, “The Savage Peace,” produced by Peter Molloy, focuses on the very real post-WW2 reprisals against Germans in Eastern Europe. The documentary, while factual in many respects, is quite deceptive at 3 key points:
1. WHO DID IT
The documentary ends with…
3/
…these words:
“Peace always has a dark side, and what happened after liberation throws the spotlight on the moral compass of the victors. When ethnic Germans became objects of violence after the war, many saw, but few were interested. The largest ethnic cleansing in…