NEW THREAD: We are back from lunch. Boyce is on the bench and jurors are being brought in.
Wright is back on the witness stand. Blake will continue her questioning.
On Oct. 16, the device associated with Alex Cox left Lori's apartment and went to the Comfort Inn in Hurricane, Utah. It stopped there for the night and the next day (Oct. 17) went to the Las Vegas airport.
The next day, on Oct. 18, the device went back to Rexburg. Lori Vallow had taken a flight from Las Vegas to Hawaii on Oct. 17.
We now see a map and chart explaining Alex's device on Oct. 18. It was at Chick-fil-A in Ammon from 7:58 - 9:32 p.m. A data point is then collected near the Salem LDS Church near Chad's house from 10:45 - 11:53 p.m.
There becomes a period of time without any data but the next data point is near US Highway at 11:53 p.m. The device does not go back to Alex's apartment - rather, it goes to the Hilton Garden in Idaho Falls.
The next slide is a map that shows where Alex's device lingered at the Salem LDS Church. The distance between Chad's house and the church is around 2.5 miles. Thirty minutes of data points are collected and then there is 1.5 hours of no data.
Wright says police could not identify anyone else who Alex knew living in the area.
Wright points out on a map where data points were collected outside the LDS Church building the night Tammy Daybell died. "We then don't know where the device is for an hour and eight minutes."
Wright identified three days when Alex's device went in the vicinity of the Daybell residence: Oct. 9, Oct. 15 and Oct. 18.
Blake has no further questions. John Thomas will conduct cross-examination.
Thomas asks Wright about his professional and educational background.
Wright retired in Aug. 2021 as a special agent and is now a consultant doing background investigations for the FBI.
Thomas asks about Wright's interaction with Ian Pawlowski. Wright sat in during an interview Ian had with Rexburg Police in December 2019.
Thomas asks Wright how long it takes to develop enough data where you can develop a pattern on a person. "If I saw something happen every day for a week at a certain time and place, I would start to think that's a pattern.
In this case, I only had those two months to look at. When I say pattern, it's based only on that information."
Wright says Alex didn't have much of a pattern to his activities and they varied day-to-day.
Thomas asks Wright about mapping software he used for the GPS data. Wright says his colleague Nick Ballance imported all the data into a Google Earth file and that's what was shown on the screen today.
Thomas asks Wright about the phone associated to Alex being at Chad's house on Sept. 23. "Based on your training, your experience, your knowledge working with the FBI -
that's not enough time to dig a hole, dig a grave, chop up roots around the grave, find stones - 17 minutes is not enough time to do all that?" Wright says he was there when JJ was found and he believes it would have taken a lot more time than 17 minutes.
Thomas has no further questions. Blake has some re-direct questions.
Blake asks for clarification on cell activity and data points. She then says, "You were also asked if 17 minutes was enough time to dig that grave. In your opinion, would 17 minutes be enough time for one person to dig that grave?"
Wright says it would be hard for one person to dig the grave. Blake asks if it's possible more than one person was involved. He says yes and reminds everyone that the 17 minutes is the time the device was there - and not necessarily the time to dig the gravesite.
Blake has nothing further.
Wright leaves the witness stand and Blake asks for a brief sidebar. White noise is played in the courtroom. Before standing up, Thomas turned around and gave his daughter (who is sitting in front of me) a big thumbs up and a wink.
Fifteen of the 18 jurors stand to stretch their legs. Many are chatting with each other. Many in the audience also standing. These days can be long sitting for 6-7 hours.
Blake calls Dr. Erik Christensen to the stand. He is the Chief Medical Examiner for the State of Utah.
Christensen explains his background in forensic pathology.
Christensen performs autopsies and has worked as a forensic pathologist in Virginia and South Carolina before moving to Utah.
Blake asks Christensen the process in which autopsies are performed in Utah. Thomas objects and says Utah procedures don't matter in this case. Blake responds that Christensen performed an autopsy in this case (Tammy Daybell). Boyce overrules the objection.
Utah does not have the coroner system. In Idaho, each county has a coroner to investigate cause of death. Medical examiners are used in Utah.
Christensen has performed around 7,200 autopsies in his career.
Christensen performed Tammy Daybell's autopsy. He says his office was contacted in Nov. 2019 by the Fremont County Sheriff's Office with questions about exhuming a body and having an autopsy done. Christensen was there when Tammy was exhumed and her body was loaded into a vehicle
He then went to his office and was there when the body arrived.
Christensen says it's routine for him or someone in his office to attend an exhumation when they are needed.
Christensen obtained Tammy's medical records before she was exhumed. Over the course of his career, he says he's been involved in "a dozen or two" exhumations. They are not common.
Blake asks if a body is exhumed does it make it more difficult to do an autopsy? Christensen says most of the time, the deceased person has been embalmed so it makes their tissues stiffer but that also helps preserves the organs, tissues, etc.
Christensen says Tammy's casket was dry and the conditions were fairly good when it came time to do the autopsy.
Sketches from this morning
Samples are collected during an autopsy to assess under a microscope. Bruises, cuts and scrapes are also examined under a microscope because they give information about how long the injury has been on a body, Christensen says.
Christensen says Tammy's cause of death was asphyxia and her manner of death was homicide.
Blake asks Christensen what asphyxia means. "It's simply a process by which a person is deprived of oxygen. They're not allowed to take in sufficient oxygen for their life to continue."
Christensen says there were no outward visible bruises or injuries that showed she died of those injuries.
Christensen explains there was no indication that Tammy had a history of seizures and her brain was totally normal.
"There are a number of ways people can be asphyxiated with. Suffocation, neck compression, anything that impairs someone's ability to breathe normally," Christensen says. When someone stops breathing, they lose consciousness but their heart can continue to beat for a time.
Christensen says they looked at pesticides and other potential drugs. There was nothing in her system that played a role in her death.
There were bruises on Tammy's arms that happened in the hours around the type of her death, Christensen says. "They are consistent with someone being restrained and would be consistent with asphyxia being cause of death as well."
Blake asks Christensen about seizures and whether he has conducted autopsies of people with seizure issues. He says yes. There are often tongue injuries and bowel or bladder issues. Tammy had neither.
Christensen says it would be uncommon for a 49-year-old woman like Tammy to start developing seizures.
Nothing in Tammy's medical records showed she had seizure or heart issues, Christensen says.
Christensen says testing was done for intoxicants. Blake asks if this means poisons. He says yes, it includes that.
They tested for hundreds of intoxicants, illicit drugs and over-the-counter medications along with insecticides, cyanide, heavy metals, phosphate positions, nerve agents - none of those were found.
"We did a lot more testing in this case than we normally would and everything came back negative except the medication she was prescribed," Christensen says, adding that it's one of the most extensive autopsies he's been involved in.
The optimal substance to test is blood. Because Tammy had been embalmed, liver samples were sent to be tested. Christensen looks directly at the jury while explaining all of this.
"There was not a toxicological explanation for her death," Christensen says.
Boyce announces we are taking an afternoon break until 2:30 p.m.
Boyce is back on the bench and jurors are being brought in.
Blake asks if Tammy's organs appeared normal. Christensen says for the most part, yes...but there was fluid in the lungs & a frothy dry foam in her airways. Blake asks to show a photo to the courtroom. It's a closeup of Tammy's face that shows the pink foam coming from her mouth
The pink foam is a manifestation of pulmonary edema, Christensen says. He has conducted other autopsies where this foam has been present. Pulmonary edema is a physical manifestation of an underlying process.
"We most commonly see this kind of setting in opioid intoxication and can be seen in drownings, heart failure, any number of things that can cause pulmonary edema."
"Whatever caused the pulmonary edema would be the cause of death," Christensen explains. He says this played a part in him determining asphyxia was the cause of death.
Blake gives Christensen a paper to mark where he located the bruises on Tammy's body. Boyce asks what he is using to mark the sheet. Christensen responds that it's a blue pen.
Christensen has finished marking the exhibit. Blake asks the diagrams be shown to the court.
The exhibits are now being shown on the screen. We see a diagram of the front of Tammy's body.
Christensen marked three blue dots representing bruises on Tammy's upper right arm, a blue dot on the lower right arm, a mark on the chest above her left breast and a blue dot on the left arm over the bicep.
On the diagram of the back, there are bruises on the back of the right upper arm, one on the lower part of the arm and one on the left arm.
Blake now wants to show close-up photos of the bruises found on Tammy's body.
The first photo shows Tammy's left upper chest with a bruise. We are not shown the image but Christensen describes it. The next picture shows a closer view of the bruise. We see this image. It is black/dark blue.
The following photo will not be shown but it's her upper arm with bruises on her right bicep. The following photo is a close-up of the bruise and we see the picture. We now see an image of Tammy's right forearm with bruises on it.
The next picture is the front side of Tammy's right forearm with a bruise. Other photos show more bruising on Tammy's arms.
Christensen says it's more than likely the bruises were on Tammy's body before she died because once circulation stops, it's much harder to cause a hemmorage.
Christensen says the injuries on Tammy's body occurred around the time of death.
More photos are shown of the bruising on Tammy's body. Some of the photos are shown to the entire courtroom, others are not. Christensen explains the injuries.
Christensen noticed signs of lividity. This is when the blood pools at the lowest point of a person's body following their death. Over time, the lividly becomes "fixed" & the blood will no longer be moveable. Christensen says on Tammy's body, there was fixed lividity on her back.
Blake asks Christensen is lividity permits him to determine a cause of death. He says no. Blake asks what rigor mortis is. This is the stiffening of the joints and muscles a few hours after death.
Blake asks Christensen if a time of death can be determined off rigor mortis. He says it can be looked at and helps but the longer a person has been dead, the wider the time of death estimates would be.
Christensen was not present the day Tammy died and says he relies on external information to help determine when a person dies. Christensen says based on what Chad said about Tammy being cold and stiff at 6 a.m., it's likely she died a couple hours earlier.
Christensen says he looked at other causes of death and did not find them to be likely in Tammy's death. He again stresses the cause of death was asphyxia and the manner of death was homicide. Blake has no further questions for the medical examiner.
The monitors will now be arranged to the jury, attorneys and judge can see the graphic images of Tammy's bruises. The audience will not be able to see them.
Blake shows the images as Christensen describes them.
Lori is not looking at the monitor that shows the bruises.
The photos have all been shown to the jury. Black has nothing further. Defense attorneys will cross-examine starting tomorrow.
Court is adjourned. Some big developments today. I’ll break it all down tonight on ‘Courtroom Insider.’ Join me at 7:30 p.m. on the EastIdahoNews.com YouTube channel and my Facebook page.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
NEW THREAD: Back in the courtroom. Boyce is on the bench and jurors are being brought in.
I have seen Garrett Smith and Josh Garner in the courtroom today. They are both attorneys for Melani Pawlowski. Smith represented her in Arizona, Garner represented her during grand jury proceedings in Idaho.
Kaaiakamanu is on the stand and Blake requests that a firearm seized from Alex's house be brought into the courtroom. "We will make sure all firearms are unloaded and steps have been taken to render them inoperable," Boyce says to the jury.
NEW THREAD: We are back in the courtroom. Boyce is on the bench and jurors are being brought in.
Next witness is Fremont County Det. Vince Kaaiakamanu. Lindsey Blake will be questioning him.
Kaaiakamanu is over the detective division and worked as a supervisor over the patrol division. He has worked at the sheriff's office for 18 years. He and Helena Kaaiakamanu, the dispatcher who testified earlier in the trial, are brother and sister.
It's day 21 of Lori Vallow Daybell's trial and we are back in the courtroom. We ended yesterday with the defense playing a podcast Lori recorded with Melanie Gibb and others in 2018.
Chad Daybell's neighbors completed their testimonies so we expect to have a new witness on the stand first thing this morning. You can get caught up on what happened yesterday here. eastidahonews.com/2023/05/day-20…
Lori has entered the coutroom. She's wearing a navy blue long-sleeved shirt with a navy polka-dot puffer-type vest. Defense attorneys and prosecutors are at their tables.
NEW THREAD: We are back from lunch. It was a longer break due to technical difficulties. Boyce is on the bench and jurors are in their seats. Todd Gilbert remains on the stand for cross-examination by Jim Archibald.
Archibald asks what church Gilbert attended with Chad and Tammy Daybell. He says the LDS Church Salem 3rd Ward.
Archibald asks Gilbert if he was familiar with Chad Daybell before Chad moved in. Gilbert says he had read some of Chad's books - "they were kind of interesting. They were based on fiction mixed with some of the visions he had seen."
NEW THREAD: We are back from the break. Jurors are being brought in.
Gilbert says she and her husband reached out to visit Chad on Oct. 26 after Tammy's death. Chad said he would come to their house. "He came over to our place and I made cookies. He came in and sat in the kitchen. We asked how he was doing.
He said, 'Actually I'm going very good.' He said he met the woman he was going to marry." Gilbert and her husband were shocked. Chad went on to say how beautiful Lori was and said they met at a conference in St. George.
It’s day 20 and Utah Medical Examiner Dr. Erik Christensen will be back on the stand for cross-examination. Yesterday he testified about bruises found on Tammy Daybell’s body during her autopsy. You can read about his testimony and other developments from Monday here.
Courtroom gallery is full again. I'm sitting next to a man who drove six hours from The Dalles, Oregon to be here. He was shocked he was able to get a ticket to be in the actual courtroom. Plenty of seats remain open every day in the Ada County and Madison County overflow rooms.
Bailiff giving instructions to the courtroom - phones must be silenced, no photos or video, no eating. Larry and Kay Woodcock are here. Defense attorneys and prosecutors are at their tables. Lori Daybell is dressed in black today and is chatting with lawyers.