Debt is the New Equity: A look into Sponsored Buyouts in Chapter 11 and recent events surrounding Bed Bath & Beyond including volume in the company's bonds and the appointment of Holly Etlin to Chief Restructuring Officer. #BBBY
This six page Kirkland and Ellis paper (2009) details Sponsored Buyouts and the Plan Sponsor Transaction through Chapter 11 bankruptcy proceedings. The following quotes will summarize the paper, but it's worth a full read.
"This chapter 11 process creates an opportunity for a private equity fund to employ capital and to use the target company balance sheet as leverage..."
"...because many of today's distressed companies have no equity value, the control play is through the target company's debt."
"...to purchase the debt of a distressed company and then convert that debt to equity in connection with the restructuring process."
"The winners in this scenario will be the distressed company itself and the investors who own equity of the restructured distressed company."
"Specifically, chapter 11 provides distressed companies with a breathing spell from their creditors. And, chapter 11 allows distressed companies to:
1. right size their balance sheets and 2. emerge from bankruptcy stronger and leaner."
"For a class of claims to approve a plan, more than 50 percent in number and at least two-thirds in dollar amount of voting creditors must vote in favor of the plan."
"A plan sponsor invests "new money" in conjunction with a plan of reorganization. And, the new money is distributed to certain creditors in exchange for (1) their claims and (2) an affirmative vote on the plan."
This post from last week details the current creditor relationship between JP Morgan Chase and Bed Bath & Beyond, which may well have forced the company into Ch. 11 proceedings and negotiations of a Plan Sponsored Transaction for control of the company.
If you follow the leveraged buyout schematic, you know this entire story has been told with the company's bondholders since the debt exchange offering last year.
This Nov deal is a direct example of institutional investors converting debt to equity.
There have been several days of large volume in Bed Bath bonds, indicating an investor may have been further positioning themselves for an LBO, or now a Plan Sponsored Transaction w two-thirds dollar amount vote.
It appears as if a flurry of bonds traded yesterday, May 1st as well. Reminder, quarterly payment on these bonds are due May 3rd.
And finally, Bed Bath & Beyond, "appointed Holly Etlin to serve as the Chief Restructuring Officer ("CRO") of the Company..." on Apr 22nd, the day before filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcy.
A role and job she's done before.
In this 2017 interview with the American Bankruptcy Institute, Etlin details her role with BCBGMaxAriza and an $85 million DIP loan put up by the owner which bridged that company to a successful sale.
On Apr 23rd, Bed Bath themselves entered into a DIP loan agreement with Sixth Street and TAO Talents, "in an aggregate principal amount of $240 million..."
The company also received financing before Chapter 11 as well, raising $360 million from their Feb securities offering.
Admittedly, I thought I found more to share about the company's $1b Apr securities deal with B. Riley which has now been canceled. My argument could not be supported with primary sources so I decided to remove this piece. David Kastin is the securities expert, I'm just a fan.
Regardless, this $600m in financing will allow Bed Bath to continue operations and bridge to a buyout in Chapter 11. Evidence suggests the board and executives have been scheming a leveraged buyout since last summer and soon the Plan Sponsor Transaction may be approved by courts.
On Mar 30th, Bed Bath files $300m ATM offering to be completed Apr 26th or face bankruptcy. The funds would close the ABL w JP Morgan 3 years before maturity. Any acquisition requires JPM approval, except in chapter 11 proceedings. #BBBY
The $300m ATM offering Mar 30th states,
"Upon filing our annual report Form 10-K, which is due by April 26th, 2023, we will lose S-3 eligibility and therefore we expect all sales made pursuant to the sales agreement will cease by April 26th, 2023...
…If we do not receive the proceeds from the offering of securities covered by this prospectus supplement, we expect that we will likely file for bankruptcy protection."
5 Days to Bankruptcy: Cohen argues a multi-billion $$ valuation of BABY as the Ultimate Destination for Babies. He sells his Bed Bath position in Aug at the start of M&A negotiations. His letter suggests his willingness to hold the board accountable. #BBBY
"Given that BABY is estimated to reach $1.5 billion in sales in Fiscal Year 2023 with a double-digit growth profile and at least 50% digital penetration, we believe it is likely much more valuable than the Company's entire market capitalization today."
($1.6b at time of writing)
"We believe under the right circumstances, BABY could be valued on a revenue multiple, like other ecommerce-focused retailers, and justify a valuation of several billion dollars."
The math presented in the following tweet assumes 550m shares outstanding at Bed Bath.
9 Days to Bankruptcy: Jake Freeman announces ownership of 2024 notes and 6.21% equity stake in Bed Bath & Beyond on July 21st, proposing a bond issuance to raise cash while opposing a sale of the company or a significant amount its assets. #BBBY
"Freeman Capital advocates for a debt realignment that does not change or affect the control. BBBY's effective realignment is a top priority for Freeman Capital and is made in the context of a disinterested shareholder-"
"Freeman Capital does not advocate for a sale of BBBY to another company, Freeman Capital does not advocate for the sale of a significant amount of the issuer's assets, Freeman Capital does not advocate for the restructuring of the issuer..."
Bloomberg reported Sunday, "Bed Bath Begins Three-Week Countdown to Possible Bankruptcy". I'd like to celebrate our final days to April 26th w a daily discussion of various topics hinting at the latest corporate raid of @Carl_C_Icahn
"On or around January 13, 2023, certain events of default were triggered under the Company’s Credit Facilities (as defined below) as a result of the Company’s failure to prepay an overadvance and satisfy a financial covenant, among other things."
Why didn't JP Morgan seize assets right then? What kind of sophisticated investment bank issues default on a company with a 'Going Concern' and doesn't immediately collect on it's loans? Bed Bath owed JPM $550m on its Asset-Backed Loan as of Nov 26th (as reported in the default)
I'd Like To Solve The Puzzle:
A 12-Page Report Exploring Strategic Acquisitions with GameStop CEO, Matt Furlong,
🍎 GameStop Achieves Near-Term Profitability
📙 Mathematical Analysis of Acquisition
🍎 GameStop Achieves Near-Term Profitability
At Q2 FY22 earnings, Furlong announced a transition of focus, "on a new set of priorities that include achieving profitability". He mentions a 14.3% reduction in SG&A as they, "right-sized corporate expenditures and headcounts."
I'd Like To Solve The Puzzle:
A 60-Page Report detailing the Marriage of Carl Icahn and Bed Bath & Beyond,
🍎 WHAT: Leveraged Buy-Out, Spin-off BABY
📙 HOW: Bond Exchange, The Team & Kastin
🌲 WHY: Merger with WestPoint and Newell
🫐 WHEN: Filings, Earnings, Bond Payment
🍎 WHAT: Leveraged Buy-Out, Spin-off BABY
On Jan 13th, an input into Pitchbook indicates a rumored leveraged buy-out was negotiated. The same day, certain events of default were triggered with the JPM loan. The ABL mentions a change in control is considered an event of default.