Holly Stallcup Profile picture
May 25 16 tweets 3 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
Before I leave for NYC, here is my thread on seeing Taylor this weekend while she is dating a racist, Islamophobic, anti-semitic overall problematic white man. While I don't necessarily "owe" anyone this thread, it is important to me to take my public leadership seriously.
I have spent the last two weeks trying to listen to as many marginalized fans of Taylor as I can. Trying to follow their lead on how we can or can't separate the person from the art. I don't have easy answers and don't know what I will do past this weekend.
Some marginalized fans are choosing to keep engaging with Taylor's music at some level and some aren't. I am trying to figure out my place with my privilege.

It is not news to me that Taylor is not a bastion of intersectionality. I would not call her a role model for my littles.
Taylor's financial situation alone is enough reason for me to stand on the opposite side of her ethically. I want our government to tax the shit out of her earnings and will continue to vote to make that happen. Billionaires shouldn't exist.
I have wrestled with attending her concert this weekend and know that her shitty, harmful decision to date this man will impact my experience in ways that I wish it wouldn't. I also know the bulk of white women that will be there have not thought critically about being there.
I often wish that public figures would simply talk about the private wrestling they are doing with complicated things even in broad terms like I am doing here. This is me acknowledging the reality that is happening and saying to you I am not just ignoring it.
Taylor is doing something wrong & harmful. She doesn't hold responsibility for men's actions. She DOES hold responsibility for her own. My biggest commitment is to keep following the lead of marginalized fans in this situation. Following that lead I'm choosing to go this weekend.
I know that I have to continue to interrogate if I'm just looking for marginalized fans saying it is "OK" to keep being a fan because that is what I want to hear & not listening to everyone. I know that the end result may be disengaging with Taylor's music for a time or forever.
I don't know that I am making the "right" decision but I know I am trying. I know that celebrity continues to be problematic for me overall especially around money but I also know that Lizzo and Kelsi Ballerini (a white woman in country music) are doing what I wish Taylor was.
Also, yes, Taylor has a responsibility to speak up about things. If I need to write this essay with eight thousand something followers she needs to be outspoken about the myriad of violence happening across our country. (I know that there are security things that factor in.)
I also wanted to acknowledge that through a set of circumstances I could never have expected the tickets I have are very nice tickets. A lot of you pay my salary & so it's important for me to acknowledge I have a ticket that through a very unexpected path was affordable for me.
Again, I don't necessarily think I "owe" you that information but it will give me freedom I need to fully enjoy this gift to let you know that I continue to believe a budget is a moral document both at Rise and for me personally and I am holding the tension of the ticket I have.
That is NOT to say that people who bought full price more expensive tickets made a morally wrong choice. Just to say that I know I talk a lot about money publicly and so always want to hold expensive things with tension and thought.
I’m planning to try and post with freedom now this weekend. I have had a truly horrific five months and want to remember joy. I’m going to my favorite city with one of my favorite people to sing music that gives me many good things.
I’ve kept comments closed here because in this I’m not looking for feedback or affirmation. I’m not going to dialogue with Swifties who don’t appreciate my criticism here & I’m not looking to be lauded as some wonderful person for really doing the bare minimum.
If you are a fan of Taylor who falls into a marginalized group more intimately impacted by this I would be happy and honored to hear from you.

Thanks for listening & for letting me be human. Sequined romper pictures coming soon!

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Holly Stallcup

Holly Stallcup Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @HollyStallcup

Sep 10, 2022
Alright my white women, want to pull up a chair and hear some thoughts on the Queen's death and how we have and can be responding and where we do or don't express those responses and why we have those responses to begin with?

(Comments off for now so we don't cause harm.)
Cards on the table, I've not had any feelings about this news. While that means I may understand you a little less I think it means I may be able to be a pretty objective voice.

You know I care about you and what you are feeling and you know I care about you enough to push us.
Number one, we have caused harm this week in our public responses. It may not have been our intent but it has been our impact and so in love we pause. One of the things we know is that we can pause even while we are confused or feel hurt or frustrated ourselves.
Read 25 tweets
Jul 24, 2022
Every day I do vocational ministry I am more and more convinced pastors should spend less time on sermon prep and more time on pastoral care. People are desperate to be cared for. People need someone to listen without hurry. To organize meals for them. To track down resources.
There is a place for learning, challenge and comfort via preaching. But my God how we have elevated it. And we have not changed our framework of pastoring as more resources to learn outside the local church have become available.
And we have refused to acknowledge how late stage capitalism, more women working outside the home, people living in individualistic nuclear families often a plane ride away from bio family has changed the capacity of primarily women lay leaders to do (unpaid) pastoral care.
Read 7 tweets
Jun 25, 2022
We need $544 more tonight as we raise money to help a woman get out from under predatory payday loans. This money will help her catch up on her car payments and other bills after an unexpected move and large medical expense.

Could you give $10?

nowsherises.churchcenter.com/giving/to/rise…
$40 taken care of! $504 to go!
$39 given! $465 to go for the night!
Read 5 tweets
Jun 25, 2022
A note from the director of a non-profit that meets women's tangible needs including caring for their kids. It is IMPOSSIBLE to meet the needs of all women and children through private individual assistance alone. The numbers don't add up. The government has to be involved.
You cannot love people with ideals. Love requires pragmatism. I believe God multiplies and can do the impossible. He does it in my work often.

I also believe God gave us brains to look at policy and stats and voting records. Kind church members are not the solution to injustice.
Mutual aid is incredible and it is keeping people alive every day. But there are just as many people not getting lucky, not finding the person who can help raise funds.

Grassroots nonprofits are changing lives and we absolutely have no desire or ability to take care of everyone.
Read 19 tweets
Jun 24, 2022
Today's goal is to hit the halfway point in meeting this need! We need $619 to do that.

We have the chance to be the safety net we all deserve and that all of us end up needing at some point. Could you chip in $5? Could you share this need with others?

nowsherises.churchcenter.com/giving/to/rise…
$30 down! $589 to go!
$35 more donated! $554 to go for tonight! Could you chip in the next $5, $10 or $20?
Read 4 tweets
Jun 24, 2022
I want to get this need down to $1,500 by the end of the night. We need $454 more to do that!

Let's be this beautiful woman's safety net so she no longer has to rely on for profit predatory lending.
$50 taken care of! $404 to go for tonight!
$25 given! $379 left for the evening!
Read 4 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(