In the early 1930s there was a Jewish journalist living in Germany. The journalist loved cats so he had a subscription to a cat magazine. At first the magazine had articles about grooming your cat, toys for your cat, what you would expect in a magazine dedicated to cats. /2
But as the 30s went on the journalist started noticing articles appearing in the magazine about the German cat. How the nature of German cats were superior. How essential the loyalty of German cats were. Slowly some variant of this message made it into every article. /3
In the total state every aspect of life must relate back to the power of the regime. No academic discipline, piece of art, or hobby can simply exist for its own sake. It only exists to point back to the power of the regime. /4
In more formally totalitarian regimes we understand how this works. In the 3rd Reich or USSR there was an official official organ of the state in charge of coordinating propaganda. Forcing every piece of media to point back to the state. /5
That doesn’t exist in our society so we need to explain why we can still observe the same phenomenon. Our regime is governed by a decentralized network of consensus manufacturing institutions sometimes called the cathedral /6
Our ruling class don't have their orders handed down by one official propaganda office but they do all attend one essential institution during their formative years that shapes their morality, worldview, and personal networks: The university. /7
The people who operate our key institutions and shape our culture all share the same moral system. They read the same things, attend the same parties, watch the same programs, and need to signal the same types of virtues to succeed in personal and private life /8
This is why every bit of entertainment is now about progressive ideology. The elites who create it share the same interests values and culture as other cultural elites and will become preoccupied with the same causes placing them above the stated purpose of the institution. /9
When you notice that every company is woke, every show or video game is about social justice, every school is more interested teaching gender ideology than math or reading you’re noticing the German cat, the decentralized narrative of the cathedral. /10
This illustration and the concept of the cathedral was taken from Curtis Yarvin who you can read here: graymirror.substack.com 11/11
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Formal religions were essentially banned from being adopted by government organizations, taught in schools, and eventually from even participating in the public square 2/
Because progressivism, or wokeness if you prefer, has no holy book or formal church it faces no such restrictions, and because humans are deeply narrative and religious creatures we will inevitably adopt such a framework 3/
For a long time progressives made great strides by transferring conflicts of moral vision out of the realm of the sacred and into the realm of the scientific
By making things cold, clinical, rational, and secular the left were able to deconstruct load bearing social norms 1/🧵
It's hard to sell the redefinition of marriage in a religious context, but if you can shift the discussion of sexuality to the realm of biological determinism then it becomes easy to advance your political ideology 2/
It doesn't matter if the left immediately abandons that biological determinism the minute it makes contact with any other social issue, they never really cared about the science
They just cared about the political victory it could deliver 3/
They’re trying to pull a head fake, giving one minor concession hoping conservatives will be satisfied
Meanwhile they turn to the LGBTQ mob and woke investors with a vague accusation of “violence” which allows them to pretend they are doing this for safety reasons 2/
As I explained previously these companies still need red America for their bottom line but they simultaneously need to appeal to the new elite religion
They can’t be seen directly concerning to the plebs 3/
For some the hope is that if you travel far enough up the chain of elites you eventually run into a competent set that don't believe the madness that has gripped the west
Sure they would be evil, but at least they would have a plan 1/🧵
It we be easier for us to believe that clown world was manufactured by rational actors with specific ends in mind, even if those ends were plainly evil, then to admit that rationality does not rule us the way we pretend it does 2/
We would rather see our reality as shaped by cool calculating forces, no matter how malevolent they might be, than admit that something beyond our control is acting on us as individuals and a wider culture 3/