MrMenno 🏳️‍🌈🎶 Profile picture
Jun 8 16 tweets 5 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
1 / The difference between actual civil rights movements and the ‘trans’ movement is that none of them fought for rights on the basis of something they were not, or passing themselves of as another demographic of people. Black people didn’t say “Hey, we’re white!” Women didn’t
2 / say “Hey, we’re men!” and gay people didn’t say “Hey’ we’re straight!” They fought for rights on the basis of what set them apart.

But ‘trans’ is about claiming the identities and rights of others. Men claiming to be women. Women claiming to be men. Straight men claiming to
3 / be lesbians.

It is the only movement that wants the right to identify into demographics of people that already exist within their own right.

It’s a form of colonisation. Not only that, under the guise of ‘trans’ the meaning of words and material reality all have to be
4 / turned upside down to ‘accommodate’ this colonisation. Actual women are now ‘cis’ women so that men who call themselves ‘trans women’ can be seen to be every inch a women as them, even if they have an extra couple of inches dangling between their legs. Actual lesbians become
5 / ‘cis’ lesbians and are told they can’t have female only events anymore as they’re be breaching anti-discrimination laws that prioritise the demands of blokes who call themselves lesbians.

This is co-opting, appropriation, colonisation and the rewriting of reality. It is
6 / identicide: by trying to identify into the class of people they don’t belong to, they are killing off what they actual class of people represents. All because they are intent on killing off their own true identities.

We’re seeing how dangerous this is in sports, in prisons
7 / in rape shelters, in toilets / bath rooms / changing rooms / hospital wards, etc. It’s becoming more clear every day.

And it’s all rooted in a movement trying to make us believe they are not what they actually are.

No other movement has ever done that, it’s unique to
8 / the ‘trans’ movement. Just like the story of “The Emperor’s New Clothes” it was a sham from the very beginning.

And that’s why Monty here is trying to compare ‘trans’ activism and the response to it to other movements, to make it look like it’s the same, that ‘trans’ is
9 / simply ‘the next frontier’ and that we should learn from how actual civil rights movements have historically been discredited and not let the same fate befall the ‘trans’ movement.

But that’s just a trick to disguise how ‘trans’ is about interlining and pretence. Just as
10 / men pretend to be women, and women pretend to be men, this movement pretends to be a human rights movement.

It is not. It trashes them.

And as for the “OMG they’re coming for the kids!”… in the case of the ‘trans’ movement that is EXACTLY what’s happening. ImageImage
11 / Did the gay rights movement ever say “My 3-year-old son is a homosexual and he needs gay rights!” Erm… No.

But for the ‘trans’ movement the myth of the ‘trans child’ is their very trump card, and so they try to sell it to us at any given opportunity to justify the
12 / destruction of the hard-won rights of the actual civil rights movements Monty tries to compare the T with.

It is all just a pack of lies dressed up in baby pink and blue. Which tells you all you need to know about who their target is.

#LeaveTheKidsAlone Image
13 / ‘Interlining’ = interloping 😉
14 / ‘Trans rights’ = identicide

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Identicide
15 / @janeclarejones switched me on to this when she spoke about it at the first ever @AllianceLGB conference in Oct 2021. It was a real lightbulb moment for me 💡 She also talks about it in the Adult Human Female docu 😉
16 / And here in Shahana’s words 👀😉

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with MrMenno 🏳️‍🌈🎶

MrMenno 🏳️‍🌈🎶 Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @MrMennoTweets

Jun 5
@yanisvaroufakis 1 / Dear genuine friend / supporter, the LGB and the T are inherently very different, even diametrically opposed. Years of us being lumped together as LGBT (now LGBTQIA2S+ or an even longer variation) doesn’t mean we *are* the same or have the same goals. LGB is about same-sex
@yanisvaroufakis 2 / attraction, whole TQ+ is about ‘gender identity’. An increasing number of LGBs is realising that this concept is highly regressive as it relies on sexist stereotypes which many LGB people have spent a lifetime fighting. It is also the basis for socially and medically
@yanisvaroufakis 3 / ‘transitioning’ young people who may well grow up to be LGB - in some cases we’re dealing with medical gay conversion, driven by external homophobia, internalised homophobia or a combination of both. I hope you can see that this is quite a serious issue as it’s a social and
Read 10 tweets
Jun 4
1 / “What is a woman?” is the WRONG question.

We all know what a woman is. It’s just a diversion tactic.

The real question is “What is trans?”

#whatisawoman #whatistrans
2 / One of the only consistent things about the term ‘trans’ is that it keeps changing and expanding, to the point where it’s now common to see it mentioned as ‘trans+’ or ‘trans*’. Normally if there’s an ‘*’ behind a word there’ll be a footnote with an explanation. Not so with
3 / ‘trans’. There are no clear, coherent, meaningful definitions and yet ‘trans’ is the basis on which other well-defined groups are expected to hand in their rights and freedoms.

At the same time we’re told that any attempts at clarifying #whatistrans are ‘transphobic’
Read 28 tweets
Jun 2
1 / I find this line really chilling…

“Prof. Stock, who previously faced criticism for questioning the prominence of gender identity over biological sex…”

As if 1️⃣ it’s somehow established fact that ‘gender identity’ is a thing, and

lbc.co.uk/news/oxford-co…
2 / 2️⃣ that this should naturally override the reality of sex (no need to say ‘biological’ sex @EJWardNews as there is only one type of sex…) and 3️⃣ that even daring to question this is somehow valid reason for criticism. Like… how very dare she!

The way @EJWardNews so
3 / casually inserts that line in an article where he calls the new policy “a bold stance against transphobia”, the college a “trailblazer” and says its leader is taking “a decisive step” shows not just how much the college has been captured by genderwoo, but also parts of the
Read 11 tweets
Jun 1
1 / A few days ago I got a call from someone from Amnesty. "You've supported us in the past so I wondered if I could interest you in playing a monthly lottery game we've started doing" or something like that. He was a man who struck me as perhaps in his 40s, very calm, and so
2 / I thought I'd hear him out, especially after he said the call was being recorded. "Are you OK with that?' he asked. I wanted to say "Hell yeah!" but just said "That's fine." So he starts doing the spiel, and eventually he asks if I'd be interested. I said it sounded like a
3 / good idea but that I could, to my regret, no longer support Amnesty. He was a bit surprised, and asked why. So then I explained that as a gay man I could not support an organisation that, like Stonewall, was working hard to set the rights of women and gay people back. That
Read 10 tweets
May 30
1 / “I don’t think a transwoman is a woman, I’m sorry I just don’t think that’s true.” - Kathleen Stock

Plain and simple.

Never think it is the ‘unsayable’; it is the very thing that needs to be said to stop the toxic climate of fear & intimidation spun by the gender brigade.
2 / Just like the woman on Question Time.

Willoughby: “What you said there effectively is that transwomen are men”

Woman: “In my opinion they still are men.”

Again, she just said it, plain and simple.
3 / And just like the service station attendant at 1:44 in this clip who was asked “What do you assume [I am] looking at me?” by a man in a wig / dress.

Attendant: “I assume that you are a man.”

Plain, simple, but most importantly: honest.
Read 8 tweets
May 28
Things kicking off at #letwomenspeak but police taking decisive action 👏
2 / 3 TRAs led away by police. One big burly bloke, 2 masked / hooded women from what I could see
3 / TRAs doing the usual
Read 5 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(