Prigozhin was much more likely aiming for concessions and a greater role for himself and his allies, using force as a last resort as MoD leadership pushed him out of the picture. This was a desperate bid, but possibly better than fading away with no security guarantees
1/n
That’s no longer possible. I have to believe that witnessing the Russian military’s failures in Ukraine firsthand has led to some hubris on the part of Prigozhin and co.
Up to now, Wagner has had the benefit of initiative (even as TG channels report that authorities planning armed response since yesterday). Rosgvardia and MPs don’t want to be the ones to kick off a gunfight.
3/n
But now we have Prigozhin going on record claiming that Wagner has downed two Mi-8Ts, possibly an Mi-35, with additional reports about downing of transport aircraft, battles in Voronezh, along highways.
4/n
Pro-Wagner channels temper this by claiming helo crews are alive and thought they (the crews) were firing on UA forces, fooled by MoD. Doesn’t matter, this can’t be walked back.
5/n
Putin has condemned Prigozhin, accused him of treason, and we can see propagandists like Solovyev pick up the narrative in real time. There’s no more ambiguity about official line.
Effectiveness of the response is an open question. The temptation is to look at RDK incursions, lackluster performance in Ukraine, the shake -up in Rostov and consequently underestimate the Russian state response.
7/n
But there is a precipitous (to say the least) imbalance of men and equipment. Everyone likes to dunk on Russian military’s tires etc, but Wagner has no independent logistics and supply chain to sustain anything beyond short, sharp shock.
8/n
Unless they are counting on mass defection and battlefield capture. Which I don’t believe they will get, especially with Surovikin and Alexeev’s earlier denouncements.
9/n
Getting to Moscow would mean fighting up the highways towards a region where a high concentration of units are based. Exposed, along predictable paths, in busses, trucks, and vans. It would be very ugly.
10/n
Lastly, lots on telegram right now as channels scramble for latest development. Folks like @RALee85 and @UAWeapons do a great job of interpreting these and identifying what is most likely to be accurate.
/end
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
- Russian Volunteer Corps claim that Belgorod Governor Gladkov did not agree to prisoner exchange
- Prigozhin offered to meet on exchange, RDK’s Kapustin welcomed the offer
- Prigozhin and RDK express respect for one another
Insider interprets Kapustin’s comments as him saying that he won’t turn prisoners over to Prigozhin, however, but to UA military.
The mutual respect thing isn’t new for Prigozhin (said the same of UA forces in Bakhmut), and UA / UA-aligned forces have generally expressed respect for Wagner, not least of all because it further undermines MoD and elite cohesion in Russia.
Prigozhin is claiming that Wagner’s route out of Bakhmut has been mined by MoD. Today, he also publishes report from a Wagner Engineer-Sapper Battalion accusing 72nd Separate Motor Rifle Brigade of firing on Wagner sappers on May 17th. Claims commander of that MoD unit was drunk. twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
The report specifically accuses a lieutenant colonel of v/ch 13647 of being intoxicated and the cause of the friendly fire incident
Prigozhin’s post is in response to question from “MOS. NEWS” (note that Prigozhin’s press service often plants questions w friendly publications or simply invents them) where he is asked about June 2nd claims about MoD mining of Wagner routes out of Bakhmut.
Pro-Wagner channels have for months posted dubious but very detailed maps on the situation in Bakhmut. This isn’t unusual in the milblogger space, but the effort put into these across multiple channels is unique. Now they are pivoting to highlight “MoD retreat”
This map is from Aleksandr Simonov, who is embedded with Wagner. It accuses the following MoD units of leaving their positions in last 48 hrs
- 9th Motor Rifle Regiment
- 4th Separate Motor Rifle Brigade
- 72nd Separate Motor Rifle Brigade
- 374th Separate Motor Rifle Brigade
In response to MoD spokesperson Konashenkov’s announcement of “regrouping” of Russian forces near Bakhmut, Prigozhin responds by saying that they are in fact fleeing the lines and have allowed UA forces to advance to tactically advantageous areas like the route to Chasiv Yar.
It’s entirely possible Prigozhin is bluffing to make the MoD look bad, as he has warned about concern of encirclement for weeks, and has already accused MoD units of abandoning their posts.
He also trolls Shoigu by inviting him to Bakhmut to see the situation for himself. Prigozhin has distinguished himself from MoD leadership by his presence at the front.
In 27-minute May 9 video, Prigozhin rambles about lack of ammunition for Wagner, MoD deserting positions, & inserts an interesting phrase: “The happy grandfather thinks he is fine…what if it turns out he is a complete asshole?” “Grandfather” is established nickname for Putin.
This is characteristically ambiguous, could be directed at other leadership he has historically criticized, but has captured the attention of Russian journalists in the aftermath of Putin victory parade speech.
He also says here that Wagner was threatened with treason charges if they abandoned positions. Another escalation.
As usual, predicting what will happen in the next 24 hours with Wagner is nigh impossible (incomplete info, Prigozhin as unreliable source) but we can interpret possibilities based on his announcement that they are staying.
1. Best case for Wagner, Surovikin is magic bullet
1/
Wagner now gets access to ammunition at least to levels they were in the fall. Doesn’t resolve manpower issues with prison recruiting halted, what the counteroffensive will portend for Wagner etc. but opens possibility of claiming victory in Bakhmut.
2/
Whether that means they and/or MoD then push east towards Kramatorsk or Slavyansk, unclear. Good for Wagner, bad for unity of command, bad precedent for blackmailing military leadership.
3/