Wagner PMC chief Yevgeny Prigozhin’s attempted military coup was one of the most serious political events to take place in Russia in the last 20 years. Why did it happen, what does it mean and what lessons can be learned from it? 🧵
1. Let’s start with its meaning. For the second time since Putin took power, Russia had a revolutionary situation. The first was the mass protest against the election results in 2011-12
2. Now, for the second time, the democratic opposition failed to take advantage of the situation because it was preparing for different scenarios. The democratic movement needs to learn a lesson: regime change will not come from the ballot box
3. Imagine if Prigozhin had not simply destablilized the situation, but taken power with the acquiescence of democratic forces. He would not have freed political prisoners or declared free elections. So, it’s not elections we should be preparing for
4. Prigozhin’s mutiny demonstrated to the West a likely scenario for regime change in Russia and the political forces that might take over the Kremlin
5. The mutiny was positive and signaled the end of Putin’s reign. But Prigozhin is as much, if not more of a bandit than Putin. Unless the West wants a new bandit in charge of nuclear Russia, it needs to bet big on the Russian democratic anti-war opposition, and grant it agency
6. There are institutions, which are quite representative, on which such a bet can be placed. Such as the Russian Action Committee, which includes a lot of Russia’s most visible opposition figures: ruskd.com/en/
7. If Western authorities recognize opposition institutions as legitimate representatives of Russian society with the associated opportunities, this will help the opposition compete with the militarized national patriots
8. The West must decide whom to align with for Russia’s future. Aligning with Putin and his team is pointless after Prigozhin’s mutiny. The most important result of those events was that Putin was seriously weakened, lost legitimacy and is becoming a lame duck
9. It showed that Putin does not control the country or troops, the population does not believe his myths about the war. He had to run to Lukashenko and Kadyrov for help ending the mutiny, and the people in the captured cities welcomed the Wagner fighters
10. Prigozhin’s march may not have ended with him seizing power, but it did strip Putin of a significant amount of power and brought forward the end of his rule. This is why we cannot say this was all theatrics – it was very real
11. It appears Prigozhin decided to rebel knowing he may lose his private army and, as a result, his political influence and his life. Prigozhin also knew the state of Putin’s war machine and the level of morale of the troops
12. This knowledge led him to understand that his mutiny had a serious chance of success. This is the main takeaway from his march to Moscow. Now the country and the world know it’s possible to rebel against Putin without being put down, because Putin is weak
13. This means regime change is getting closer. And we ALL need to be ready for it.
• • •
Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to
force a refresh
Prigozhin claims Wagner mercenaries have seized the military HQ in Rostov-on-Don, police on high alert in Moscow region, the FSB launched a criminal investigation against Prigozhin
Prigozhin announced a “march of justice” against defense minister Sergei Shoigu and General Valery Gerasimov around 9pm on June 23 (Moscow time)
He posted a clip on Telegram allegedly showing the aftermath of a rocket attack by Russian military against the positions of his Wagner PMC and said he was going to get “revenge” on military leaders — but there’s no real evidence such an attack took place
The Kremlin controls all Russian broadcast and print media, most major news sites and the country’s biggest search engine.
Yet tens of millions of people a day are being directed to Putin’s propaganda by… Google
🧵A thread 1/14
Google doesn’t do business in Russia anymore. It has been handed enormous fines by the regime for its work fighting against Putin’s propaganda.
But the algorithms that generate its recommendations have unfortunately been subjected to manipulation
2/14
Using Discover, a feature of the Google app preloaded onto all Android phones, Russian users are visiting news sites 33 million times a day. More than 70% of phones in Russia run on Android, so this service and its recommendations matter
Today marks 20 years since the arrest of Alexei Pichugin, security manager at Yukos — the company I owned at the time — and the first victim of the regime’s campaign against the company and me personally
🧵A thread 1/10
After his arrest he was drugged, interrogated, and pressed to provide a false testimony against myself and Leonid Nevzlin. But as a man of integrity, Alexei refused to lie, and has been held as Putin’s hostage ever since
2/10
The European Court of Human Rights has twice ruled that Alexei’s trial was unfair and illegitimate. But the dictator does not care for European courts, or for human rights, as he proved last year when he pulled Russia out of the court
Sergey Karaganov, a Russian foreign policy expert close to Putin, has suggested a preventive nuclear strike against targets in Central Europe. His aim — to intimidate the West.
What does this mean, how should we respond to it, and should we expect nuclear war? 🧵
Karaganov is influential and well-connected. Certainly, he has more influence on Putin than, for example, former president Medvedev does. But does this make his threats real?
Quite the opposite. Karaganov’s words do not represent an escalation, they are a mere inflation of existing threats. Putin and other officials have threatened to use nuclear weapons many times. But in those cases, they were talking about tactical nuclear weapons and targets… twitter.com/i/web/status/1…
Russia has dropped by nine places to 164th in this year’s World Press Freedom Index due to the increased crackdown on independent media since the war in Ukraine began. Let’s talk a little about how freedom of the press has been wiped out in Putin’s Russia 🧵
According to Reporters Without Borders, there are 22 journalists imprisoned in Russia right now – the highest number since they started keeping count. Many more have been jailed or even murdered since Putin took power
The Russian broadcast media is entirely under the regime’s control. Pretty much everything is state-owned, and anything that isn’t might as well be, because any outlet that goes against the state’s narrative is quickly taken off air