Jeremy Raper Profile picture
Jul 8 11 tweets 3 min read Twitter logo Read on Twitter
Thanks for all feedback so far re $CMD.AX Cassius. Basically pushback has fallen into two camps:
- why dont they have litigation financing in place yet?
- hasnt Ghana already 'blocked' the arbitration?
- wont this take years?

All good questions but worth examining.
Re the litigation financing - this is key. Co recently raised capital, idea is to get to seat selection stage - putting the arbitration in motion - to derisk the process, then lock down litigation financing at best possible terms. Obvi I have my views on strength of the case...
...and if they can get lit financing at anything close to $GRX.AX terms (10-15% of gross payout if they win) then the balloon upside optionality goes vertical. Clearly buying now has increased risk given this is not in place, but given the facts as they lay i think its a risk
worth taking.

Re Ghana 'blocking' the arbitration - this is a total furphy, based on misleading Ghana press reports. Ghana has actually refused to appoint their tribunal rep, which, if not done by July 20, would mean the PCA in the Hague would appoint one for them.
Cassius actually put out a PR explaining this:
Frankly if Ghana continues to play hardball and wont even accede to the arbitration, it speaks volumes to the strengths of the $CMD.AX case, in my view. No doubt the arbitrators would look upon that lack of engagement as a measure of guilt..though it may make it harder to collect
And as for 'this is going to take a long time' - that is a fair point; cant really argue. Assuming a full arbitration I expect at least 18mos, maybe 24mos, before a decision is handed down.

But again - the facts of the case are very straightforward; especially so if Ghana...
...refuses to engage. And the key investment point is that we have a number of catalysts along the way to derisk us from current, near-zero option value; to something much more meaningful (quantum analysis; higher claim number; litigation financing; beginning of arbitration; etc)
All in all - prob worth remembering what i said at the outset (ie this is a SPECULATION). but i think its eminently reasonable to expect the speculation to turn into just a risky investment proposition, over the coming months as these catalysts unfold.
And as (or if) that happens this is simply not going to trade at 4% of claim value (or maybe 2% of claim value, if the claim goes up to where I expect). I would be shocked if this gets to arbitration, litigation comes in, and quantum analysis comes through...
...and this has not made it to 8-10c at that time. But we shall see!

GLTA, DYODD 👊👊 $CMD.AX

• • •

Missing some Tweet in this thread? You can try to force a refresh
 

Keep Current with Jeremy Raper

Jeremy Raper Profile picture

Stay in touch and get notified when new unrolls are available from this author!

Read all threads

This Thread may be Removed Anytime!

PDF

Twitter may remove this content at anytime! Save it as PDF for later use!

Try unrolling a thread yourself!

how to unroll video
  1. Follow @ThreadReaderApp to mention us!

  2. From a Twitter thread mention us with a keyword "unroll"
@threadreaderapp unroll

Practice here first or read more on our help page!

More from @puppyeh1

Jul 6
I'm a value guy at heart but every now and then I find slightly hairier opportunities that offer blinding asymmetry even if absolute downside is significant.

Cassius Mining $CMD.AX is one of those times. Note I recently became the no 5 shareholder, see here:
This will be a long thread, but before reading you should consider 1) this is a <1% position for me and thus sized like a lottery ticket; 2) this has deep upside but obvious 🍩 risks so must be sized as such; 3) always DYODD, what follows is simply my (informed) opinion only.
$CMD.AX is a small-cap junior miner w/ a pending arbitration claim against the Ghanian government. Market cap today ref 4c is $19mm AUD, they have about $1mm AUD net cash, call it an $18mm AUD EV.

They have a cpl of exploration assets, incl a v promising limestone quarry...
Read 35 tweets
Jun 21
$FAR.AX perhaps worth unpacking what this is worth now. As usual mkt misunderstands latent value in small-caps - perfect example. Think this is basically a >50% IRR from here w/ very understandable and limited risk. Keep in mind I am v long this so dyodd but read on...
Main risk here was always 'will mgmt burn all the cash and buy something dumb?' Obvi completely off the table now. Returning 95% of cash essentially says 1) we will not buy anything (they cant) and 2) we will wind-up posthaste (given language ard Woodside monetization).
Remember there are only two assets of value here - the cash pile and the earn-out. No operations; barely any employees; nothing. If they pay back the cash and then sell the earn-out there is no other alternative to a wind-down. Should all be pretty clear now.
Read 13 tweets
Jun 8
Pretty interesting smallcap illiquid shitco for all you degenerates out there. Bathurst Resources $BRL.AX trading around a $30mm EV give or take, prob neg EV by end 3Q.

All the cash comes from a highish cost met coal mine in NZ - not great bob - but actually the key issue is...
...a RIDICULOUS (yes all caps justified) JV structure whereby they own 65% of the key metcoal mining asset but do not have board control ie the 35% junior partner (the Talleys) can veto any cash upstreaming/divs to the parent entities.

Guess what they are doing 😒
Bit of a Mexican standoff here: neither party, the Talleys nor BRL holdco (and hence s/holders) can get cash w/out the others' approval. we still have no idea what the Talleys actually want (they are businessmen in NZ, billionaires, not idiots).

Talleys also own 10% of BRL stock
Read 8 tweets
Jun 5
I’m continually shocked by the amount of value available in off the run/illiquid/small cap securities. Todays eg - Sierra Rutile $SRX.AX. Mkt cap $91mm AUD ref 21.5c, they have prob $60mm USD net cash, no debt currently so EV is tantamount to zero.

👇🏻👇🏻
$SRX.AX produces 30% of the global supply of rutile (basically a TiO2 feedstock, so paint input) from a single mine in Sierra Leone. This mine has only 3yrs worth of reserves so there is a massive new project, Sembehun, almost at DFS (end this yr) that would offer 30+ yrs…
…of mine life. New project has an NPV of $180mm USD (from memory, am on the 🏖️) but will cost $350mm or so to develop.

Recall mkt cap is $90mm AUD and implied cost of equity is this punitively high.
Read 11 tweets
Jun 4
In Okinawa for a few days r&r trying to forget how poorly a bunch of my (mostly commod-related) names have been doing. Will go back to pina coladas and throwing kids in water-slides promptly, but worth thinking about how cheap some of these names are becoming right now...
Eg $SMR.AX. kinda softish 1Q print (on FCF) but not horrendous by any means. They paid $150/t to acquire to BHP assets; current implied valn (ref $2.5) is about $124/t and equity is too low to acquire Daunia etc...

Maybe 1.5x EV/EBIT, 2x EV/NPAT at spot...
then there's $YAL.AX. I am not currently long, but this is frankly the cheapest on an EV basis it has ever been. Updating a historical chart I shared... Image
Read 7 tweets
Apr 24
Fairly interesting transaction announced this AM in 🇦🇺, Samuel Terry (STAM) bidding 93c for micro-cap Eildon Capital $EDC.AX. I have no position and no vested interest. Just an interesting example of how much value exists in Aussie small caps...
$EDC.AX comprises a bunch of debt + equity investments (all RE related) sitting in a trust (ECT) and an investment mgmt biz (Eildon Capital), which as $360mm in adjusted FUM (they just closed a new fund) and a cpl of direct equity investments. Image
STAM bid 93c (see link below). Per above, they are basically bidding NTA for the RE assets in ECT, and getting the ECL assets - 17c of NTA, and the Funds Mgmt biz - 'for free.'

asx.com.au/asxpdf/2023042…
Read 13 tweets

Did Thread Reader help you today?

Support us! We are indie developers!


This site is made by just two indie developers on a laptop doing marketing, support and development! Read more about the story.

Become a Premium Member ($3/month or $30/year) and get exclusive features!

Become Premium

Don't want to be a Premium member but still want to support us?

Make a small donation by buying us coffee ($5) or help with server cost ($10)

Donate via Paypal

Or Donate anonymously using crypto!

Ethereum

0xfe58350B80634f60Fa6Dc149a72b4DFbc17D341E copy

Bitcoin

3ATGMxNzCUFzxpMCHL5sWSt4DVtS8UqXpi copy

Thank you for your support!

Follow Us on Twitter!

:(